20 Best Waterproof Eyeliner For Swimming (2023 Updated)

I’ve cycled through several waterline eyeliners and Annabelle’s is my favorite. Super inexpensive, deep color, no bleeding and pretty long lasting!

Really awful! Went on smooth but awfully flaky throughout the day. Made my eyes itch like crazy. Too bad, I was intrigued by slowly that would smudge but set down to waterproof.

I’m at a lost with this one. I was in a position where I felt I could only be successful with a quick, legitimate wing with higher end liquid liner. I had to take another chance, and man! I was so impressed.

Dried so quick, allowed buildup, never smudged or ran while trying to be quick with my morning routine [sub. teacher, mon. -fri. ], AND, I enjoyed the thin line allowing for a nicer, leaner wing. But, it has been less than a month, not even doing the winged liner everyday like I use to, and it is already dried out where I can not count on it for tomorrow morning for the job interview of my life.

The top doesn’t click down, it hardly even “shuts” close and this is something that Loreal really has to fix. I may purchase again asap since I can’t take the chance, but if it dries out as fast again.

I’m going to have to move on. Pic. from this morning when I wasn’t able to build up my right side to size of the left side because it wouldn’t spout out anymore BUT, you can see how nice it is too after a 9+ hr.

day.

Thank you topbox circle for gifting me the loreal Infallible Precision Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Green for free in exchange for my honest review. I really like the colour of this eyeliner, it is a dark green and it is very rich.

I like the pigmentation of the colour a lot and how easy the felt tip was to apply. It did not feel dry and the colour went on easily. The tip is very soft and the formulation did not irritate my eyes which I really liked.

The eyeliner is long lasting and also at a great price point. I would love to try out other colours in this line too! I will continue using this product! #freeproduct #trywithtopbox.

This gives me the smoothest eyeliner application. I have tried other brands and variations (including different types of brushes) but nothing comes close to how easy this is. The applicator has a very precise end, so I use that if I want a precise line.

If I am in the mood for a more bold style, I tilt the eyeliner a little and it gives me a thicker line. It is also very pigmented and I don’t need to go over one area twice. Definitely adding this to my must have life saver products list.

Would recommend. #freeproduct #trywithtopbox.

I used to always a competitor’s brand of a similar eyeliner, but they were out of stock and I really needed something, so I gave this one a try. I loved it! I prefer a felt tip as opposed to a brush, which this one had.

The ease of getting a precise line was great and there was no smudging with this liner. It lasted all day and night which was another bonus. The only thing I would change is for the liner to have more of a matte finish, but other than that, this was a great inexpensive option.

Will definitely purchase again!.

I love this product. I wear glasses and wearing a mask all day long does not help either perspiration goes up my eyes, but eyeliner does not smudge. I use oils to remove makeup and eyeliner after wearing all day long is still tough to remove.

Want a bigger bottle at least double the amount. I have used several brands of waterproof eyeliners which after running around all day long ran down my face and leave dark smudges on my face.

I’ve been using this eyeliner for at least 7 years. I have hooded eyelids so it’s hard to find an eyeliner that will stay on. This one stays on forever even when it was raining; we got rained on, my eyeliner stayed on and my friends asked what eyeliner I was using.

I’ve recommended this to everyone I know and they all love it.

This liner stays put! My skin is oily plus the humidity here makes my skin super dewy. I thought for sure this eye liner would have me looking like a raccoon after a few hours but nope! It stayed put even through 99% humidity while I was gardening.

I purchased this after I heard Laura from Garden Answer mention it and knew I had to try it. I’m never purchasing any other liner again! I also have somewhat hooded eyes and was surprised that I didn’t have crease lines like I typically do.

The color is rich and dark and it’s very easy to apply. Overall I am super impressed and have to thank Laura for recommending it. I plan on checking out other products from Wunder and I’m excited to try them out.

Love it. I only use “waterproof” eyeliner these days (the ones that set after a few seconds smudge time) on my upper lash line ( as I’m getting older I can’t get away with lower line smudging, so it’s important not to get any transfer).

I bought one from another brand recently that was also cruelty free snd vegan but it transfers all over the place. Bought this is black and brown. Doesn’t smudge all over your face half way through the day but gives you a few seconds of smudge/wipe away time before it set in case of any slips (and with arthritis setting in, there are a few!!) I always thought of Wunder2 as a young persons brand, but it works well gif me in my late 40s.

Don’t be fooled by the soft texture of this when applied, it sort of ‘sets’ within a few seconds & it really doesn’t budge. I’m a liner freak, I smudge mine slightly & I’ve used this for a flight to New Zealand, it didn’t move! The holiday in NZ, often hot sweaty conditions & days spent sightseeing.

It still didn’t move. I wear it regularly for everyday use. Have just ordered another 2 in different shades. Currently have the black sparkle & ultraviolet one, navy & brown on the way. Buy them, you won’t regret it.

Pro MUA here. When it comes to products, I use high-end brands with price tags to match, along with drugstore options – both new and old. In my mind, if it works, it works – regardless of the name on the label.

That being said, this product is definitely on my list of favorites. The small felt tip applicator allows for EXCELLENT precision and detail, along with the ability to get a wider coverage area to save time filling in those wings.

It’s a beautiful finish and wears well throughout the day. It holds up fairly well to watery eyes, but I wouldn’t consider it waterproof. If you have allergies or tend to have issues with liner lasting throughout the day due to excess moisture, I would probably pass on this formula; HOWEVER, finding a true waterproof – or even water-resistant – formula in a liquid liner is a near impossible task.

Some liquid liners have a tendency to dry down too quickly after applying on the skin, causing either cakey-ness or where the thin eyelid skin will almost “reject” it if you try to apply multiple layers or heaven forbid, try to fix a mistake.

Luckily, this formula is NOT one of those. It seems to be easy to work with and works well with a multitude of skin types and textures. I also love how it dries down. It doesn’t crack or look dry, which is a common issue with many matte formulas.

I LIVE for the felt tip applicator, and I feel it lasts FOREVER! Definitely recommend – especially for the price point. *PRO-TIP* When the liner runs out or dries out, use tweezers to remove the felt tip, flip it around and insert the other end into the pen.

You’ll get sooo many more uses out of it, and the tip itself will feel like a brand new liner.

The liquid is good conistency, dark and waterproof, the brush glides nicely and sharpely. ALL FOR ABOUT 2 USES. I first bought this liner couple years ago and it was amazing for about 2 purchases. Then i bought it again after i ran out and after couple uses, it started to bleed so badly out of the pen or the brush flares out.

I thought bad batch maybe. I purchase again, same thing. i waited a couple months to buy again, and same thing. I loved this eyeliner cuz its drugstore and super dark/waterproof. but its impossible to use the product, I have to grab a tissue blot off the excess runnyness, wasting ton of product.

even opening the lid after first couple uses become difficult, you have to open it hard then the already leaking liner splatters everywhere from the force. I tried laying it flat, standing, backwards, doesnt matter, its only perfect the first 2 times you use it and after the functionality of the pen is horrible.

I dont know who designed this, it had so much potential since the liquid product in it is actually amazing. but they obviously do not care as they are still producing the same dysfunctional product for years.

and I have retried this product so many times giving it too many chances hoping they fixed it. i have bought at least 6 now, and all only last me a week at most before it leaks, brush spreads out or dry up.

after reading the reviews Im glad I wasnt crazy and it really is just a horribly desgner product, at this rate its more worth to buy an expensive liner that actually lasts.

I have been using this powder for like 6 years, and I have never had issues with it!! I like the way it blurs and mattifies the skin. This is the only powder I’ve tried that minimizes creasing in my undereye area! I personally have very fair, normal/dry skin, and use low-medium coverage, water-based skin tint and concealer as my base makeup, and everyone’s needs for a powder are different.

This powder will give a lot of flashback if you’re heavy-handed with it, as it is supposed to be a finishing powder. It’s pure silica with no other ingredients or pigment to minimize flashback or provide other benefits to your makeup.

It’s definitely a “less is more” product IMO. I’ve mixed this product into other loose powders and I personally think it works great that way as well. I would highly recommend using a fluffy powder/blush brush to apply this to the face, or a smaller fluffy brush for harder-to-reach areas.

A damp sponge can be used if u are careful to tap off excess powder. TLDR: If you’re looking for something to bake with, provide coverage/brightening, or to *really* set a full-converage look, this might not be for you.

Some cream and liquid products may not work well on top of this powder, so use it as a finishing step to your makeup!.

I’ve been on the search for good felt tip liner for years now. I’ve spent TONS of money on brands that were supposed to be the best bc I’m a firm believer that you get what you pay for but I was disappointed each time.

From stila, KVD, Tarte, Too Faced, Smashbox, Morphe, even Nars. They all failed me in one way or another. My expectations are dark black matte, waterproof, smudge proof, durability, sturdy felt tip, and for the product to last me at least a month without drying up.

I wear eyeliner 6 days a week so this is important. I bought this on a whim bc I ran out of my stila and was instantly surprised. When I got home from work and saw that the liner hadn’t budged a bit, I was sold.

I’ve been using this for almost a year now and have only bought 2 or 3 bc they last so much longer than any other brand I’ve tried. I’ve read on some of these reviews that some people don’t think this is waterproof or smudge proof and I have to disagree.

Mine doesn’t budge until I use makeup remover at night and I have really watery eyes. If you’re wanting something that meets the same expectations, I promise you won’t regret getting this and you will save a bunch of money in return!.

I. AM. AMAZED! My eyelids get really oily which causes mascaras and liners to slide around and transfer to other places alot typically, but i loved the retractable version for my waterline so i figured i’d give this a try and it did not disappoint! it’s been 25 hours now since i applied it and it still looked like i had just done it despite it going through a LOT! it has held up through all the christmas eve emotions, cleaning the house, cleaning the garage, tussling with some rusty bolts in the camper to completely get the subfloor out which was a very sweaty task, and an even more sweaty 11 hour sleep where i was tossing and turning all night.

DESPITE ALL THIS THO… it is coming off with EASE with micellar water. this will be my go-to liner forever now. florida’s december weather of 80 degrees outside with 95% humidity had nothing on this liner.

thank you wet n wild!.

I’ve been seeing comments about people saying it not being black enough or waterproof. But let’s be real. If you want your liquid eyeliner to work to its most potential. please wear eye primer. A liquid liner can only do so much on its own.

I have oily lids and with a Milani primer underneath this liquid liner, it works awesome! I have hooded eyelids and have tried all the top brand named eyeliners since high school. I am now 25 years old and I tried this on my very annoying watery eyes for a full shift of 9 hours and at the end of the day beautiful! Idk why everyone is saying it’s not black enough bc to me it is! It’s not shiny at all.

just the right matte not too intense if that’s what you want this won’t be for you. For the price, the wear, and it’s quality. you can’t ask for more. Don’t hesitate, go get it sis.

I wear light eyeliner everyday and this has become my go to! It glides on easily, doesn’t get weird when you sharpen it, and is overall just a solid product. I am pretty much obsessed with this company after trying some of their other products too!.

Bought for first time few weeks ago. Love how it glides in and stays put all day. Does not irritate my eyes which is important. A bit hard to sharpen but overall a great eye liner.

Have used this eyeliner for a while. Love it!

I LOVE LOVE LOVE this product! The brush tip has wonderful precision and makes every stroke shading when using this liner result in a fine line. I have a lot eyeliners that are very similar to this and while they do give me good results when doing my makeup, this product gives me just enough liquid to where I don’t need much reapplying.

If you have sensitive skin like me or really sensitive eyes then you’ll most likely experience itching or a slight burning sensation so i recommend fanning your eyes to relieve your eyes so that you can keep using the product.

The itching or burning doesn’t last long; only a few seconds. Overall, this product is excellent and it really lasts during however long you wear your makeup! Highly recommend!.

I have been using this for a few weeks now but today I decided to review it. I have combination skin, eye area is in the oily zone. Today’s been humid as well so put oil and sweat together but this did NOT smudge.

It stayed precisely as how I put it on. Thin, tapered brush helps in precision. I dont always do liquid eyeliner and this is my first inkwell type but I am able to apply it flawlessly because it is easy to use.

Honestly, I did not expect much but am glad I tried this. What a great buy! And i just love the dark brown color – not to bold and kinda discreet. Great for natural/subtly enhancing look.

Such high quality for an amazing price! When I first began experimenting with eyeliner, my friend recommended it to me since it was the cheapest option. I was surprisingly pleased with how pigmented the color was and the applicator is amazing for beginners.

It’s a thin wand which allows a lot of easy control. If you make a mistake just take a q-tip and one small swipe cleans it up well. Now after experimenting with loads of other high end eyeliners, it’s still one of my favorites.

Consistently pigmented, perfect consistency, lasts all day, and the cheapest price on the market! It comes it other colors and they are all just as amazing.

this is a hard review to write. i really was so excited to purchase this eyeliner, even went to the closest store to me so i wouldn’t have to wait for shipping. let me preface by saying i will continue to purchase and use this product, as it’s the only decent clean eyeliner on the market.

that being said, the fact that they claim this is waterproof is unbelievable to me. this eyeliner is in no way waterproof at all, if i put it in my upper waterline it transfers immediately to the lower waterline, and continues to transfer throughout the day.

if you accidentally smudge the corner of your eye with your finger, say goodbye to whatever eyeliner you put on there. sometimes, i’ll even see it transfer to my upper eyelid, due to my hooded eyes. the color payoff isn’t the greatest either.

it’s not really black, more charcoal, and you need to either press really hard or layer it on for a darker pigmentation. i understand clean formulas do not perform the same as normal products, as it’s still a fairly new way to formulate things, but don’t make claims on the longevity and/or waterproof of a product unless it truly is.

with all the negatives out of the way, the formulation ingredients are great. i have sensitive eyes, and have not experienced any irritation at all with this product. since it is an easily smudging formula, it’s a simple task to make a smokey smudged eyeliner look.

all in all, like previously stated, despite the lack of waterproof and longevity, i will continue to use this product due to it being one of the better clean eyeliners on the market currently.

I purchased this eyeliner pencil with my own money. Not gifted. I’ve been getting into tightlining and lining my waterline just for variety in my looks. My eyes are naturally round, and it really changes the shape of my eyes to more of an almond shape.

Anyways. I was looking for a brown waterproof pencil as I find black too harsh on me. I purchased this Caliray pencil in Secret Spot brown, as well as the Sephora Long Lasting Khôl pencil in Brown (not their regular eyeliner pencil, this is a different product!).

Tried both for about a week each, every day. Tightline, waterline and outside of the lash line. The verdict – they both perform about the same. They both only last a couple of hours on the waterline (disappointing).

They both last all day outside the lash line, without running or smudging (excellent). They’re both extremely easy to apply on the waterline without any irritation (also excellent). I received my Caliray pencil delivery after the Sephora Khôl pencil, and I was excited because I figured it would be so much better based on the reviews but it’s not.

I feel like I wasted my money since the Sephora pencil is half the price, and it’s a full inch longer than the Caliray (there’s only a little more product in the Sephora, but it’s nice that it’s longer because if you mess up when sharpening it you don’t lose as much product).

So, is the Caliray eyeliner a good product? Yes, it deserves 4 stars, minus one star because it’s not waterproof on the waterline, and they should have added a smudger on the other end for the price.

It’s a reliable pencil, but so are my other premium eyeliners (stila and Clinique). The Sephora Khôl performed the same, and is half the price so I will probably choose the Sephora Khôl once I finish the pencils I first purchased.

I hope this was helpful to anyone looking for a product for the waterline.

I’ve been loyal AF to Urban Decay, and as soon as she announced she was doing her own line. NO brainer. Ordered it from her site, when it dropped, it was just the black pencil and the mascara, to which I happily said “take my money!” Mascara is okay, it’s wet like Lancome’s IMO so you’ve gotta give it the time to dry in between coats, tried w/lash primer & w/o, heated eyelash curler.

I LOVE the brush, those always work the best on my lashes. But as for holding a curl. ehh, feeling a bit let down on that. I’ve got cheapie cheapies that perform better. The removal is nice w/the tubing though.

The eyeliner, I always use primer. my UD and other brands wouldn’t budge. This lasts maybe 6 hours. MAYBE. waterline, even set w/shadow, forget it. I WANTED to love them both SO much, but for me, they’re a pass.

I’d sooner do my makeup and know it’ll last as long as my day, needing a touch up (eyeliner, FULLY understand) but I’ve used other ones that literally were still on 24/36 hrs later, after work shift, out to party and then fell asleep.

Hi, I’m a avid user of liquid eyeliner since teen years. Maybe because of my skill and long-term usage of liquid liner I’ve perfected many forms of the winged look. I originally used line stiletto by maybelline since it had a very thin tip that I could easily glide on with.

I chose to stop using it after I became an adult as I care more about my ingredients of products I put on my face, it became more expensive and worse quality. I’ve spent hours looking for a match maker and found thrive for their excellent mascara (I love it, but I can concur with others than it does flake.

) and mistakenly found their liquid liner. I ordered it and was beyond impressed with the performance of the eyeliner. I’m unsure of it being my dry skin or not, but unlike one star reviews I read it DOES NOT flake and is actually a little difficult to remove.

I love the precision of this liner and the color of it. Liquid eyeliner is not meant to look airbrushed like the plenty of edited photos as you see everyday, and if that’s the look you’re going for you’ll need some pencil liner to smudge a wing/line before applying liquid liner to give it that *umf* you’re looking for.

By far the best liquid liner I’ve tried and it will be my forever liner until they take it offline.

I’m a wedding and wildlife photographer, so I’m always on the lookout for the makeup with the most staying power that is smudge proof (because I have a camera up to my eye/face all the time) and water resistant (because summer weddings are HOT and a lot of the popular barn venues have no climate control.

So I’m for sure going to sweat). I was using another brand with the same properties as this one, but the pen style is too stiff and can skip over the fine lines I’m developing as I get older (I’m 45).

The brush on this is the perfect balance between being dense enough to get a flawless shape with one swipe and soft enough to allow for even easy coverage without skipping. The formula is nice and wet so it goes on easy but dries down quickly so you can’t smudge it before it’s dry.

And it lasts all day even at weddings in a 100 degree heat index and 90% humidity. I am honestly in love.

This is by far the best formula on the market. Hands Down a winner. I love the thin brush, the weighted handle, the bead to thin it before use. And the staying power. Whoa. This stuff stays put. If you’re someone like me who has had the troubles with the eyeliner, give this a try.

Like the pencil, there’s a learning curve. Give yourself a break and remember that skill is developed. It’s not inherent. Practice your application techniques and you’ll be fine and out there loving this stuff like so many others.

My only caveat is that it’s not in pen form. I find the bottle and brush method difficult to use. I’m just used to an eyeliner pen. Get one of those in circulation and you’ll have an eyeliner client for life.

And whatever y’all do, Thrive, please don’t discontinue or ‘revamp’ your current products. Ever. Thank you.

I highly recommend this product if you want to tight line and out product in you water line. This brand on eyeliners we’re designed to be worn on swimmers so it doesn’t smear or budge!! It’s a waterline wearers dream.

The color Ivy which is a burgundy purple which is prefect for brown eyes it just makes them stand out more than wearing a black eyeliner. These have a pencil sharpener attached to the bottom. One thing I can say is that it’s hard to get them perfectly sharpened but I’ve learned they don’t need to be too sharp because of how creamy they glide on.

The formula is for lovers of creamy, buildable, pigmented formulas. It’s like gel formula but a little thicker in a pencil easy to use form for people on the go. I highly recommend this product! I can’t wait to buy other colors, like Ebony which is a pretty shade of purple for brown eyes.

Did I mention I have brown eyes? Lol I’m interested in trying their lip pencils in the aqua formula as well!! I’m addicted to lip pencils! I bet they stay on forever. I like products that you don’t have to reapply and that don’t budge! I want something I do once and leave the house and finish my night and when I look in the mirror at night to wash my face the products still look perfect and this product is one of those products.

If you choose to try this out let me know how you liked it!.

I’m sure the formula is great. But I wasn’t able to test is out until I completely destroyed the top plastic part with a regular sharpener like most phot reviewers here. I found that there is a built in sharpener at the bottom but it was already too late.

I already ripped through the plastic with my girl power. So then I can’t even apply the eyeliner without irritating my eye. They say with this new design, you ca create a winged tip every time by being able to sharpen it.

Well, I only tight line and don’t do winged tips. I find that with the new formula, it becomes dull too quickly. So that means I’d have to sharpen it more frequently. At least bring back the old style so customers have a choice between the two.

With your brand, I’m sure you’ll still make money even if you split your customer base.

ive been using this pencil since early high school (im 33) now. and i always ALWAYS come back to it. it truly is waterproof. (that being said it doesnt blend as well as other pencils but i usually use it to tightline my waterline).

i know its considered pricey for an eyeliner pencil but chanel is even more expensive and i think this works much better! plus you really can use it down to the nub! (which i have! it doesn’t glide on as easily when you’ve had it for a while but what product does?! and besides that color and staying power are still there) i like pairing this with nyx eyeliner in a dark brown color and smudge that out to get a “slept-in” look.

This is a holy grail product for me. Its a nice, long lasting eyeliner, the biggest caveat is that it does dry out, but that’s an issue with all pot eyeliners, and you just kind of have to learn and accept the reality of rejuvenating the product.

Its not a problem, and I actually would stop using it out of just having the pot for an overly long time even past expiration, rather than ever running out. I consider it a grail because of its other qualities and of its non-irritating quality on my highly sensitive eyes, and I have successfully replaced my old brow products with it.

I have dark brows, so I use it to fill my brows too. It doesnt look super heavy and overbearing on my brows or pull to an odd bluey or reddish tone on my olive-neutral skin the way other brow products did, and its the only potted product I’ve ever put on my brows that DIDNT make the hair start falling out, which both ABH dipbrow pomade and KVD super pomade did.

I’m sort of surprised this product only has 3. 5 stars and the reviews about it coming off after a few hours and being dry. I’m a nurse who runs around like crazy and sweats for 13 hours and it doesn’t come off.

I’ve taken showers with this product on and it stays put. When I dip my brush in, it’s so creamy it sends chills up my spine lol. When I’m doing my makeup I put it in my pocket so my body heat softens the product a bit, perhaps try that? It’s expensive but a little goes a loooong way.

I’ve had my jar since February (now August) and there’s so much product left, I’m nowhere near hitting pan/glass. I use it 3-4 times a week, it’s the only eyeliner I use and I do a pretty dramatic wing.

I guess different strokes for different folks!.

I used to love this eyeliner and have been using it for many years. It always dried out half way through the pot but I just accepted that. I was very disappointed to have to wait over 6 months for stocks in the UK to be replenished but delighted finally to be able to buy another pot a few weeks ago.

The first time I used it I found it as dry as the one I had had for over a year. I returned it and bought another pot from a different retailer and am having exactly the same problem again. You have clearly either changed the formula or these pots have been sitting around somewhere for a very long time before being shipped to the UK.

This is incredibly disappointing and I now have to find another brand instead which will be difficult as I have sensitive eyes and this has been my ‘go to’ for many years.

What completes your eyes and highlights your eyeshadow, I say it’s my eyeliner because using this eyeliner makes my eyes stand out and appear wider more fuller and it helps to bring out my eyeshadow and other features on my face.

I like this eyeliner as it doesn’t smudge or budge throughout the day nor does it tend to run into my eyes during the hot summer nights. I definitely recommend this eyeliner if you are looking for more fuller eyes.

I highly recommend this product. It’s waterproof, goes on smoothly and last me all day for my 10hr shift at work! Can’t go wrong with an eyeliner like that!! I used to hate reapplying makeup. I’m weird when it comes to putting on makeup, my face has to be clean and free of makeup from the day before or hour before.

Yes, THAT weird. Ha!.

For a drugstore brand, this is surprisingly good. I tend to stay away from drugstore eyeliners because my experience with them hasn’t been positive. I picked this up when I ran out of my MUFE Aqua Eyes and was pleasantly surprised when it performed almost (if not) as good as eyeliners 3x its price.

Stayed on my top lashes all day, and I mean ALL day from morning to night. In fact it had to be removed with eye makeup remover because it didn’t come off with soap and water. On my waterline, it didn’t stay as long as I would have liked but that is not the fault of this eyeliner.

Even department store brands don’t stay on my waterline for any length of time. Best of all, it’s highly pigmented. So much so that I have to put eyeshadow over it to tone it down. Sure there are better eyeliners out there for twice or even three times the price but this one can hold its own against more expensive department store brands.

I have been a MAC LOVER for over 20 years. I use and LOVE it all. Powder Plus foundation, lt\med contour palette, Retro Matt lipstick, 3D Black mascara, Carbon Black eyeshadow (with rice paper eye shadow above, of course) Genuine Aubergine brow pencil and Point Black the BEST LONGEST LASTING LIQUID LINER ever made.

This Glide or Die, Has the DARK BLACK and LONG WEAR of the Point black without the dry time!!!! We all know we must be VERY CAREFUL with a liquid liner, and if we are rushing, as most of us are, the slightest smudge must be corrected FAST because liquids have a tendency to smudge if not completely dry.

This is perfect, stays on, stays BLACK but because I LOVE Point Black too; the pencils cannot get as close to the upper lid lash line for me (you young girls need not worry I am 51 years old and the upper lid is not as tight as it was) so after drawing a long sleek line of Glide or die, I still put a very thin line of Point Black so close to the lashes that there is no spot missed!! THANK YOU AGAIN MAC!!!! As always PERFECT.

who would’ve thought we could improve upone POINT BLACK???!!!! (But do NOT discontinue Point black. as I said they work perfectly together for anyone 50+!!!!).

Pros: Color payoff is great. Gentle on the skin and even though it took a little work, it did apply and stay on the waterline. Doesn’t smudge too much which is great, but also means it’s not blendable.

Cons: the product can be a little thick if you want to apply enough to be bold on the waterline. My lashes are short and fine and I noticed one of my shorter lashes got stuck towards my eye after a few hours of wear either due to my eye watering or movement of my lashes.

Caused some irritations and I had to remove it. Not really the fault of the product itself, but it’s something to keep in mind when applying and wearing it. Removes easily with micellar water on smooth surfaces like lids.

If used between lashes you’ll want an oil based cleanser for thorough removal. This is good product if you need good colors and staying power. If it were more comfortable it would be a holy grail product for me.

( I recieved this product complimentary in exchange for my opinion from Lancome, BzzAgent and Sephora) This eyeliner is beautifully designed and the quality is so amazing! I’m really impressed by the longevity of this Liquid eyeliner.

I applied this product in the morning and it lasted hours until night-time when I took my makeup look off. This product comes back off easily with Micellar water, Makeup wipes and/or my Cleanser. The packaging is sleek and looks very stunning! This Eyeliner is for both Novices and Makeup Artists alike.

This applies easily even with a light hand and you don’t need to put on more than once unless you want an intense Makeup look. This liquid Eyeliner is truly waterproof! It stayed on even in the rain and still didn’t give me raccoon eyes either afterwards, so I fully tested this product’s quality.

This is already sold out at Sephora currently and I can understand why this new release is so popular! Lancome never lets me down, they are slaying the Competition! Just buy this already, once it’s back in stock because you won’t be disappointed.

Thank you to Lancome, Sephora and BzzAgent for this opportunity to try this product out and to give back my honest feedback. This will be posted for my followers soon on my latest blog @Beautyobsession_87.

I received this product free via Bzzagent. This kind of “felt pen” style eye liner is the kind I typically prefer. I was excited to try it. I have tried several other high end brands such as Clinque, Stila and Eyeko but I honestly didn’t notice a difference in quality between them and Lancome.

PROS: I did like the style of the pen in that it is easy to hold in your hand. The felt tip of the pen is longer than some of the others I’ve tried so I did feel it was somewhat easier to get to my lash line.

It definitely is a glossy black as the advertisement says. I found that it’s claim to being waterproof was true as some bits still hung on even after a shower. I also wore this on a 9 mile hike and it stayed on the entire time – through wind, watery eyes and a brief rain sprinkle.

The only thing I would have been interested to see is if it would have stayed on through sweat. It was only 50 degrees that day so there was none of that. CONS – Another time I tried this was for a night out with friends.

I applied this eyeliner with the rest of my eye look and went to apply false lashes last. It did not hold up to the lashes being re-positioned. Perhaps that wouldn’t be an issue for someone who gets false lashes right on the first try but for me it was annoying as it essentially took off the entire eyeliner.

I have other eyeliners that have held up to that. Not this one. Waterproof – yes. Lash adhesive proof – No. (Not in my book anyway. ) Overall I would consider buying this product. My previous favorite liner was the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner and when I compare the tips between the two Lancome’s is longer.

It’s price point is right in line with the other high end brands I’ve tried. I’m located in Pennsylvania which has it’s fair share of humid days come summer so I am anxious to see how it holds up in that weather.

I would recommend this product to friends to see if it works for them.

So I am a big fan of Lancome – skincare and their lash primers/mascaras. Very excited to try Idole Liner, but not sold on this yet. I am fairly loyal user of Stila liquid liner which I am using as comparison.

So my first clear noticeable fact was that Idole Liner was drier than the Stila Liner. At first this annoyed me. I typically do a thick cat eye – I figured either liner would do the trick, but Idole needed to be ‘shook/tapped’ to try to get more fluid to the felt tip pen.

It made my eye makeup process quite longer than typical. Now. After a few times of trying, I decided to try something different. I lined my eyes, upper outline shape that I wanted, but filled it in with the Stila liner.

That seemed to work well. The Idole was a great fine tip that didn’t bleed and held form well. I additionally used the Idole liner for the bottom waterline. Useful to me as it was waterproof. I liked that for the top ‘outside’ shape as I felt it would hold the shape of my cateye and not get ‘sweaty’ and smear or anything, which it didn’t.

So, I may use this approach on a go-foward basis. Never thought I’d use two liners, but I did like the point tip and holding power of Idole, just not the ‘juiciness’ of the liner. I do have concerns it may dry out sooner than others.

👁Benefit “They’re Real” Xtreme Precision Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner ($24) is a sleek, glide-on ultra-pigmented liner that features a 0. 1mm tapered brush tip for extreme precision. The design allows for ultra thin lines AND thick, Audrey Hepburn-esqe wings.

Waterproof, smudge-proof and long lasting–this flake free, weightless, quick-set formula is quite buildable–creating crisp and sharp lines with every stroke. This liquid eyeliner took my very breath away.

It has all the power of a traditional liquid eyeliner BUT the ease and convenience of a felt tip liner. I personally have such a hard time falling in love with felt tips because of their tendency to crush and bend over time.

I have always wanted to see a brush-based precision tip like this one and I found it here. The pigmentation is, out of this world, insane. You hardly need any elbow grease at all, just a simple stroke and you can easily glide a perfect wing every time.

The thin, ultra sharp tip is easily controlled and maintained. You can build up the volume, for a more dramatic look or you can keep it simple. What I personally love is that it’s thin enough to draw with–for those more creative and artsy.

I can see this being a boon for graphic liner wearers. Did I mention this liner is BOLD? Because it truly is!! If you are looking for a more natural, basic liner. this is not the one. The reason I bring this up in review is because I read a few reviews prior to mine that claimed it was “too dramatic” or rating it 1 stars based on how much it “resembles Sharpie” but the name says it all.

It never claimed to be natural, it’s actually described as BOLD. So, rating it down based on what it’s supposed to do? That seems harsh and unfair. Don’t buy it if it’s not for you, maybe? 🤷🏻‍♀️ 10/10 would recommend and approve.

Especially if you like extreme, bold and dramatic liner looks. I personally know how hard it is for me to find a good, deep black liner without being gray-casted or dull. It might be a tad bit expensive but it’s definitely worth every penny just by application alone.

Thank you Influenster & Benefit for allowing me this opportunity to test & try out this product.

I received Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real Xtreme Precision Liner liner free from Influenster in exchange for my honest review and I love this liner. I have not been wearing eye liners because trying to apply the tip hurts or the line is not the way I want it or I keep trying and nothing goes on my eyes and then when I get it on it smudges and runs and I get raccoon eyes so I just stopped but the Benefit They’re Real Xtreme Precision Liner has changed all of this for me! It’s very easy to apply and the tip is very thin but strong yet flexible just perfect for applying eye liner on my water line and lining the top of my eye without it hurting my eye and it goes on very easily and smooth on my first try and I use a very light hand.

I wore it all day it didn’t smudge or budge and my eyes watered a lot like always. The tip doesn’t agitate my eye and I can make the line as bold or as thin as I like. I’m 39 so I’m not into wings with eye liners and I never could do them right but I think I can with this eye liner it’s great for beginners.

At last a perfect eye liner in every way, it’s smooth, water proof, it’s smudge and budge free. It’s fast and easy, it’s versatile, the tip. is amazing it doesn’t hurt or irritate my eye it’s the perfect size and flexibility.

The color Xtra black I love it’s a satin finish. I love eye liners and had to stop wearing them for years now I can wear eye liner again thank you Influenster and Benefit!!.

Wow, am I thrilled I get to try Benefit They’re Real! Xtreme Precision Liner. I was super impressed with the They’re Real! Magnetic Mascara, so I had high expectations for this liner. I also use liquid liner almost daily to do a winged makeup look.

I’ve experimented with many kinds of liquid liner, and they are not all made the same. First, the packaging is bright red, making it super easy to find in my makeup bag. That means I’ll use it more often! The pen is also very comfortable to hold.

This is important because you really do need to have a nice grip and angle when you are doing a precise line. The brush works very well. So far, the bristles have not separated, so the liner ink basically goes exactly where you intend it to go.

I also noticed that the brush was nicely saturated with liner ink, unlike other brands, which you have to pump and get going in order to get a nice, clear line. The ink is a nice, deep black, that doesn’t come out appearing faded or like it needs more than one coat.

And, the brush really does make a very precise line-wings this sharp will cut ya! This liner really is a pleasure to use! Very little to NO smudging or transferring, which is mostly awesome but kind of a mixed blessing: If I mess up, there’s no wiping because this stuff stays still! Five stars!.