When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Dishes For Thanksgiving Potluck (2024 Updated)

If you’re looking for the best dishes for your next Thanksgiving potluck, you’ve come to the right place. This annual gathering is a perfect opportunity to join with loved ones and celebrate the season with good food and great company. But what should you consider before whipping up that signature dish?

One of the most important factors to consider is the size of your dish. Remember, a potluck is all about sharing, so be sure to make enough to feed a crowd. You’ll also want to take into account the time and effort it takes to prepare your dish, as well as any special dietary restrictions your guests may have, such as gluten or dairy allergies.

When choosing what dish to bring to the potluck, consider what you’re known for cooking best. Are you a dessert master or a savory sensation? Pick something that highlights your skills and will make your dish stand out. Don’t forget to also take the time to carefully select your ingredients and presentation, as these details can make all the difference.

Still stumped on what to bring? Ask yourself some of these questions: What is the theme of the potluck? What are some classic Thanksgiving dishes that are always a hit? What is something unique and unexpected that will surprise and delight your fellow potluck guests? With these factors in mind, you’ll be sure to impress the crowd with a delicious and memorable dish.

10 Best Dishes For Thanksgiving Potluck

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
This product is ideal for serving meals and showcasing food in a stylish and classic way for six people.
2
This dinnerware set is ideal for serving meals at home or entertaining guests with its 16-piece, double bowl design in vibrant cobalt blue.
3
It is ideal for making classic herb-seasoned stuffing, perfect for Thanksgiving or other home-cooked meals.
4
This product is ideal for those looking for a durable and lightweight dinnerware set that can serve up to six people.
5
This product is ideal for baking dishes, as it is chip and crack resistant and safe for use in various appliances.
6
Ideal for serving meals at events or parties where easy clean-up is desired.
7
Idahoan Real Premium Mashed Potatoes are ideal for making mashed potatoes quickly and easily without sacrificing taste or quality.
8
The product is ideal for keeping food warm and serving during parties, holidays, and entertaining events using oven-safe chafing dishes.
9
The product is ideal for serving and keeping food warm at events, parties, catering, and home dinners with adjustable temperature and chafing dishes.
10
The product is ideal for serving meals to a group of four with a colorful and autumn-inspired design.
This product is ideal for serving meals and showcasing food in a stylish and classic way for six people.
This dinnerware set is ideal for serving meals at home or entertaining guests with its 16-piece, double bowl design in vibrant cobalt blue.
It is ideal for making classic herb-seasoned stuffing, perfect for Thanksgiving or other home-cooked meals.
This product is ideal for those looking for a durable and lightweight dinnerware set that can serve up to six people.
This product is ideal for baking dishes, as it is chip and crack resistant and safe for use in various appliances.
Ideal for serving meals at events or parties where easy clean-up is desired.
Idahoan Real Premium Mashed Potatoes are ideal for making mashed potatoes quickly and easily without sacrificing taste or quality.
The product is ideal for keeping food warm and serving during parties, holidays, and entertaining events using oven-safe chafing dishes.
The product is ideal for serving and keeping food warm at events, parties, catering, and home dinners with adjustable temperature and chafing dishes.
The product is ideal for serving meals to a group of four with a colorful and autumn-inspired design.

1. Amazon Basics 18-Piece Kitchen Dinnerware Set, Plates, Dishes, Bowls, Service For 6 – White

Introducing the 18-Piece Round Dinnerware Set, the perfect addition to any kitchen! This set provides service for six and is made of AB-grade porcelain, which is both lightweight and durable. The elegant white finish complements any existing kitchen décor and is sure to impress dinner guests.

This dinnerware set is BPA-free and safe for use in the microwave, oven, and freezer, making it incredibly versatile. The plates can withstand a maximum temperature of 572 degrees Fahrenheit, allowing you to use them for a variety of dishes. Additionally, this set is dishwasher-safe, making cleaning up after meals a breeze.

The set includes six each of the 10.5-inch dinner plate, 7.5-inch dessert plate, and 5.5-inch bowl. Please note that this set does not include mugs. Upgrade your dining experience with this stylish yet functional dinnerware set!

Pros

  • Made of lightweight yet durable AB-grade porcelain
  • Elegant white finish complements any kitchen décor
  • Safe for use in microwave, oven, and freezer
  • Dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning
  • Can withstand temperatures up to 572 degrees Fahrenheit

Cons

  • – Does not include mugs

2. Gibson Elite Matisse 16 Piece Double Bowl Dinnerware Set, Cobalt Blue

Enhance the elegance of your dining room with the Gibson Elite Matisse 16 Piece Dinnerware Set. This stunning set features a reactive glaze that creates a unique pattern of light dashes and darkened rims, giving your table setting a touch of sophistication.

Crafted in Cobalt Blue color, this set includes four 10.5in dinner plates, four 8.5in dessert plates, four 5.25in cereal bowls, and four 8.25in dinner bowls. Each piece is designed to accommodate all your dining needs.

This dinnerware set is not only aesthetically pleasing but also practical. You can safely use it in the microwave and dishwasher, making cleaning and reheating a breeze. Elevate your dining experience with the Gibson Elite Matisse 16 Piece Dinnerware Set.

Pros

  • Unique pattern of light dashes and darkened rims create an elegant aura
  • Includes all the essential pieces for your dining needs
  • Safe for use in the microwave and dishwasher for convenient cleaning and reheating

3. Pepperidge Farm – Herb Seasonsed – Classic Stuffing – Pack Of 3 12oz Bags

Enjoy a gratifyingly delicious side dish with this 3 pack of 12oz bags made from premium breads. Each bag is crafted from a blend of unbromated unbleached enriched wheat flour, whole wheat flour, salt, sugar, yeast, canola oil, unsulphured molasses, spices (contains celery), onion powder, calcium propionate (to retard spoilage), malted barley flour and soy lecithin. The wheat and soy in this product make it a great source of protein and fiber. This versatile side dish is perfect for any meal and will satisfy your taste buds with its rich flavors and superb texture.

These breads are made with premium ingredients that are carefully selected and blended to create a delicious and nutritious side dish. The unbromated unbleached enriched wheat flour, whole wheat flour, and soy lecithin make this product a great source of essential nutrients, such as protein and fiber. The addition of spices, onion powder, and unsulphured molasses gives this side dish a unique and savory flavor that pairs perfectly with any meal.

Indulge in a mouth-watering side dish with this 3 pack of 12oz bags. Made from premium breads, this side dish is crafted from a blend of unbromated unbleached enriched wheat flour, whole wheat flour, salt, sugar, yeast, canola oil, unsulphured molasses, spices (contains celery), onion powder, calcium propionate (to retard spoilage), malted barley flour, and soy lecithin. The combination of these ingredients creates a delicious and fulfilling side dish that is perfect for any occasion.

Pros

  • Made with premium breads for a gratifyingly delicious side dish
  • Crafted from a blend of premium ingredients such as unbromated unbleached enriched wheat flour, whole wheat flour, and soy lecithin
  • A great source of protein and fiber
  • Versatile and pairs perfectly with any meal
  • Unique and savory flavor from the addition of spices, onion powder, and unsulphured molasses

4. Winter Frost White Corelle Dinnerware Set

The Corelle 18-Piece Set is the perfect dinnerware set to have for a full table service of 6. It includes (6) 10-1/4-inch dinner plates, (6) 6-3/4-inch appetizer plates, and (6) 18-oz soup/cereal bowls. The bread and butter plate measures 6.75" W x 6.75" D, the dinner plate measures 10.25" W x 10.25" D, and the bowl measures 6.75" W x 3" D.

The Corelle dinnerware set is made of triple-layer-strong glass plates and bowls, making it lightweight, easy to handle, and durable. This feature makes it less prone to chips and cracks, and allows for compact stacking which takes half the space of ceramic dishes. It is ultra-hygienic, non-porous, and easy to clean, making it dishwasher and microwave safe.

Corelle's minimalist approach to its crisp, bright, and classic design brings a timeless aesthetic to this dinnerware set, blending with most kitchen environments. This dinnerware set is designed to provide the best dining experience while requiring low maintenance.

Crafted with pride in Corning, New York, Corelle Dinnerware has been a staple of modern eating for everyday occasions, filling hearts and tables since 1970. This item comes with a 3-year limited warranty.

Pros

  • Includes enough pieces for a complete table service of 6
  • Made of triple-layer-strong glass plates and bowls for added durability
  • Lightweight and easy to handle
  • Compact stacking design saves space
  • Ultra-hygienic, non-porous, and easy to clean
  • Dishwasher and microwave safe
  • Minimalist design blends with most kitchen environments
  • Low maintenance
  • Comes with a 3-year limited warranty

5. French White Ceramic Bakeware Set With Lids

This 12-piece CorningWare set includes a 2.5-qt oval casserole with glass and plastic lids, a 1.5-qt round casserole with glass and plastic lids, a 16-oz round casserole with a plastic lid, a 24-oz round casserole with a plastic lid, and two 4-oz ramekins. The set is made from high-quality ceramic that is durable and resists chips and cracks, making it a long-lasting household essential. The plastic lids are non-toxic and BPA-free.

Designed to provide the best kitchen experience with low maintenance, this bakeware set is dishwasher, freezer, microwave, and pre-heated oven safe. The high-gloss exterior is non-porous and easy to clean. This bakeware set is oven-to-table ready, making it a great addition to your serving ware collection. The bakeware's effortless elegance elevates your everyday by offering superior craftsmanship.

This bakeware set comes with a 1-year limited warranty, giving you peace of mind when making your purchase.

Pros

  • Comes with a variety of sizes to accommodate different cooking needs
  • Made from high-quality ceramic that is durable and resists chips and cracks
  • Plastic lids are non-toxic and BPA-free
  • Low maintenance and easy to clean
  • Oven-to-table ready for easy serving
  • Effortlessly elevates everyday dining
  • Comes with a 1-year limited warranty

6. Dixie Ultra Printed Dinner Plates, 64ct

Introducing the new and stylish design of Dixie Ultra heavy duty paper plates that can handle your heaviest meals with ease. These 10-inch disposable paper plates are built strong with Flex-Proof Technology to offer you the same great plate you love, but with added durability.

These plates are 3x stronger than the leading comparable store brand paper plate and can hold up to 2lbs of food. You no longer need to worry about messy and heavy meals as Dixie Ultra plates are microwave safe, cut resistant, and soak-proof shield that can handle anything from salad dressing to burger grease.

This pack includes 64 plates, making it ideal for any occasion or gathering. These plates are perfect for indoor and outdoor use and are designed to keep your food safe and secure. Upgrade your dining experience with Dixie Ultra heavy duty paper plates.

Pros

  • Stylish and new design
  • Flex-Proof Technology for added durability
  • 3x stronger than comparable store brand paper plates
  • Can hold up to 2lbs of food
  • Microwave safe, cut resistant, and soak-proof shield
  • Ideal for indoor and outdoor use

7. Party Perfect Buffet Warmer Set

The electric buffet server offers a versatile way to serve holiday favorites and crowd-pleasing appetizers. Measuring 15.71 x 25.16 x 5.71 inches, it comes with 3 oven-safe chafing pans that have a capacity of 2.5 quarts each. These pans are made of durable stainless steel and come with transparent domed lids that keep moisture in while serving. The lids have spoon slots for easy serving.

The buffet server also features a food warming tray that can accommodate heat-safe dishes and pans. This tray keeps food warm without overheating it, thanks to its consistent and adjustable heating system. Simply turn the dial to the desired temperature, and the buffet server will cycle on and off to maintain it. This way, the food stays warm for hours without getting overcooked or dried out.

The electric buffet server also offers contactless serving, thanks to its convenient lid rests. These rests hold the lids open, allowing guests to serve themselves without touching the lids. This feature ensures a safe and hygienic serving process, especially in these times of heightened awareness for hygiene and safety.

Cleaning the buffet server is a breeze, as the stainless steel pans are dishwasher safe. The lids can be easily wiped clean or rinsed clean in the sink. This makes the buffet server a convenient and hassle-free addition to any home or commercial kitchen.

Pros

  • Comes with 3 oven-safe chafing pans that have a capacity of 2.5 quarts each
  • Transparent domed lids keep moisture in while serving
  • Lids have spoon slots for easy serving
  • Consistent and adjustable heating system keeps food warm without overheating it
  • Contactless serving feature ensures a safe and hygienic serving process
  • Stainless steel pans are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning

8. Chefman Buffet Server: Perfect For Entertaining!

The Chefman Electric Buffet Server + Warming Tray is perfect for any occasion as it comes with a 5-quart capacity pans and 14" x 14" hot plate surface. This size can fit several dishes at once and will look great on any countertop table or buffet. Its adjustable temperature control and size make it suitable for family dinners, Sunday football gatherings, holiday meals, or other big parties and events. With its sleek design, it will surely complement any occasion.

This buffet server has an adjustable temperature control that makes it easy to quickly heat up your food. The fuse safety feature keeps it from overheating so you can keep your food warm for hours on end. You can keep the hot plate on low to keep food warm throughout the day or adjust to high to heat your appetizers quickly.

The Chefman Electric Buffet Server + Warming Tray comes with three stainless steel warming pans, two 1.2 Qt warming pans, and one 2.5 Qt warming pan. The three high dome transparent lids keep the heat in, ensuring that your food stays warm and fresh. The accessories are dishwasher safe for easy clean up, making it convenient for you to use.

This buffet server can be used with all heat-safe cookware and bakeware, including aluminum or glass baking pans, casserole dishes, pots, pans, and more! Its cool-touch handles make it easy to transport the food, and the added safety feature ensures that it is safe to use.

The Chefman Electric Buffet Server + Warming Tray is CETL approved with advanced safety technology for long-lasting durability. It comes with a 1-year warranty provided by Chefman, so you can purchase it worry-free. If you need any information on how to use your product, you can check the PDF User Guide provided. This buffet server has a capacity of 200 Watts/120 Volts and its model number is RJ22-SS-B.

Pros

  • Adjustable temperature control for easy heating
  • Comes with three stainless steel warming pans and high dome transparent lids
  • Can be used with all heat-safe cookware and bakeware
  • Cool-touch handles make it easy to transport the food
  • CETL approved with advanced safety technology for long-lasting durability
  • Comes with a 1-year warranty provided by Chefman

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for very large events due to its 5-quart capacity

9. Pfaltzgraff Autumn Berry 16 Piece Dinnerware Set, Service For 4, Multi Colored

The Traditional Dinnerware Set is an excellent addition to any kitchen, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere to any table setting. This 16-piece dinnerware set is designed to serve four people for a complete dining experience. The set includes four 10-1/4 inch dinner plates, four 8 inch salad plates, four 5-3/4 x 2-1/8 inch (16 ounce) soup cereal bowls, and four 12 ounce mugs.

Crafted from premium quality stoneware, this dinnerware set is designed to last long and provide a beautiful and durable dining experience. The stoneware construction ensures that the dinnerware set is resistant to chips and cracks, making it an ideal choice for everyday use.

The set is microwave safe and dishwasher safe for easy cleaning and maintenance. You can easily reheat your food in the microwave and then clean the set in the dishwasher without any hassle. With its classic design and long-lasting durability, the Traditional Dinnerware Set is an excellent investment for any home.

Pros

  • 16-piece dinnerware set provides a complete dining experience for four people
  • Stoneware construction ensures long-lasting durability
  • Microwave and dishwasher safe for easy cleaning and maintenance
  • Traditional design creates a warm and inviting table setting

Best Dishes For Thanksgiving Potluck FAQs

How can I ensure that my dish will be a hit at a Thanksgiving potluck?

To ensure that your dish will be a hit at a Thanksgiving potluck, there are a few things you can do. Firstly, consider the tastes and preferences of the people who will be attending the potluck. If you know that most of the attendees are vegetarians, for example, make sure that your dish is vegetarian-friendly. Secondly, choose a dish that is easy to transport and serve. Potluck dishes that can be served at room temperature or that can be reheated easily are always a good option. Thirdly, make sure that your dish is visually appealing. People eat with their eyes first, so if your dish looks appetizing, it's more likely to be a hit. Finally, aim to bring something unique or different to the potluck. While traditional Thanksgiving dishes are always welcome, a creative and unexpected dish can really stand out and be a talking point among the attendees.

What are some easy-to-prepare dishes for a Thanksgiving potluck?

Thanksgiving is a time for family and friends to gather together and celebrate with delicious food. If you are hosting a potluck this year, you may be wondering what dishes are easy to prepare and will be a hit with your guests. Here are a few ideas:

1. Deviled eggs: This classic appetizer is always a crowd-pleaser and can be made in advance.

2. Green bean casserole: This dish is a staple at Thanksgiving and can be made with just a few simple ingredients.

3. Cranberry sauce: Making your own cranberry sauce is surprisingly easy and adds a homemade touch to your meal.

4. Sweet potato casserole: A delicious and easy-to-prepare side dish that is sure to impress.

5. Pumpkin pie: A classic Thanksgiving dessert that can be made ahead of time and is always a hit.

Remember, the key to a successful potluck is to have a variety of dishes that everyone can enjoy. Don't be afraid to ask your guests to bring their favorite dishes or to assign specific dishes to ensure a well-rounded meal. Happy Thanksgiving!

What are some tips for transporting dishes to a Thanksgiving potluck?

Transporting dishes to a Thanksgiving potluck can be a daunting task, especially if you're bringing something that's delicate or needs to stay warm. Here are some tips to help make sure your dishes arrive safely and ready to serve:

1. Choose the right container – Make sure your dish is in a container that's sturdy and well-sealed. If you're bringing something like a casserole or pie, consider using a carrier specifically designed for that type of dish.

2. Keep hot dishes hot – If you're transporting a dish that needs to be kept warm, wrap it in a few layers of foil and then place it in an insulated carrier. You can also place a hot pack or towel on the bottom of the carrier to help keep the dish warm.

3. Keep cold dishes cold – If you're bringing a dish that needs to be kept cold, use a cooler or insulated bag with ice packs. Make sure the dish is well-wrapped and won't leak.

4. Label your dish – Make sure your dish is clearly labeled so that people know what it is and who brought it.

5. Plan ahead – Give yourself plenty of time to transport your dish, especially if you're traveling a long distance or there's traffic. It's better to arrive early than to be rushing and risk damaging your dish.

What are some traditional Thanksgiving dishes that are perfect for a potluck?

Thanksgiving is a time to gather with family and friends to share delicious food, and a potluck is a great way to ensure that everyone has a chance to contribute. Traditional Thanksgiving dishes that are perfect for a potluck include turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce, and pumpkin pie. These dishes are staples of the holiday and are sure to be a hit. Other popular dishes that can be included in a potluck are green bean casserole, sweet potato casserole, macaroni and cheese, and cornbread. It is important to remember to coordinate with others to ensure that there is a variety of dishes and that there is enough food for everyone. Potlucks are a great way to share the workload and create a sense of community during the holiday season.

What are some vegetarian or vegan dishes that can be served at a Thanksgiving potluck?

There are plenty of vegetarian and vegan dishes that can be served at a Thanksgiving potluck. Some popular options include roasted vegetables such as Brussels sprouts, carrots, and sweet potatoes, as well as quinoa or lentil-based salads. Another classic vegetarian option is stuffing made with vegetable broth and plenty of herbs and spices. Vegan gravy can also be made using vegetable broth and flour, and can be poured over mashed potatoes or roasted vegetables. For the main course, stuffed acorn squash or a lentil loaf can be a delicious and satisfying option. And of course, no Thanksgiving meal is complete without dessert. Vegan pumpkin pie made with coconut cream instead of traditional dairy cream is a delicious alternative. With a little creativity and some simple ingredient swaps, it's easy to create a delicious and satisfying Thanksgiving meal that everyone can enjoy, whether they follow a vegetarian, vegan, or traditional diet.

Leave a Comment