When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Whisky For Old Fashioned (2024 Update)

If you're looking for the perfect whisky to use in an old fashioned, there are a few factors you should consider before making your purchase. Firstly, you should think about the flavor profile of the whisky. A good old fashioned typically calls for a whiskey that is full-bodied and has rich, caramel notes. Secondly, you should consider the price point of the whisky. You don't want to break the bank for a bottle of whisky you'll only be using for a cocktail. Finally, you should research the distillery that produces the whisky. Look for distilleries that have a reputation for producing high-quality spirits.

When it comes to choosing the best whisky for an old fashioned, there are a lot of options to consider. Some people prefer a higher rye content in their whisky, while others prefer a smoother, more rounded flavor. It all comes down to personal preference. However, there are a few questions that can help you narrow down your choices. For example, do you prefer a classic, traditional old fashioned or do you like to experiment with different ingredients? Are you looking for a top-shelf whisky or something that won't break the bank? By answering these questions, you can more easily find a whisky that suits your needs and taste preferences.

11 Best Whisky For Old Fashioned

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
Ideal for serving whisky or other spirits in vintage-style glassware, with a 12oz capacity and attractive cut glass design.
2
The product is ideal for serving drinks at home or entertaining guests with its stylish and timeless design.
3
The product is ideal for drinking spirits like bourbon, scotch whisky, cocktails, and cognac in lowball bar tumblers.
4
This product is ideal for scotch and bourbon lovers looking for stylish and high-quality whiskey glasses.
5
Ideal for enjoying premium whiskey and other spirits in style with handcrafted, weighted bottom tumblers made in Germany.
6
Ideal for enjoying your favorite whiskey or mixed drink in a chic and timeless glassware.
7
Ideal for serving whiskey or cocktails on the rocks in a classic, stylish glass.
8
Ideal for drinking whiskey, scotch, bourbon, cognac, Irish whisky and old fashioned cocktails. Made of premium crystal with a rock style.
9
This product is ideal for chilling and enjoying whiskey, bourbon, tequila, and scotch.
10
The product is ideal for serving whiskey or other spirits in a stylish and stackable crystal glass set.
11
It is ideal for serving and enjoying whiskey or other types of old-fashioned cocktails.
Ideal for serving whisky or other spirits in vintage-style glassware, with a 12oz capacity and attractive cut glass design.
The product is ideal for serving drinks at home or entertaining guests with its stylish and timeless design.
The product is ideal for drinking spirits like bourbon, scotch whisky, cocktails, and cognac in lowball bar tumblers.
This product is ideal for scotch and bourbon lovers looking for stylish and high-quality whiskey glasses.
Ideal for enjoying premium whiskey and other spirits in style with handcrafted, weighted bottom tumblers made in Germany.
Ideal for enjoying your favorite whiskey or mixed drink in a chic and timeless glassware.
Ideal for serving whiskey or cocktails on the rocks in a classic, stylish glass.
Ideal for drinking whiskey, scotch, bourbon, cognac, Irish whisky and old fashioned cocktails. Made of premium crystal with a rock style.
This product is ideal for chilling and enjoying whiskey, bourbon, tequila, and scotch.
The product is ideal for serving whiskey or other spirits in a stylish and stackable crystal glass set.
It is ideal for serving and enjoying whiskey or other types of old-fashioned cocktails.

1. Vintage Whisky Tumblers By Libbey

The Libbey Hobstar Double Old Fashioned Glasses are an elegant and stylish addition to any home bar. With a capacity of 12oz/340ml, these glasses can easily accommodate your favorite cocktail, whiskey, or any other beverage of your choice.

Crafted from high-quality glass, these glasses are designed to be sturdy and durable. The unique hobstar pattern on the glass adds an extra touch of sophistication and style to your drinkware collection. The glasses are easy to clean and maintain, making them perfect for everyday use or special occasions.

This set of four glasses is perfect for entertaining guests or simply enjoying a drink with family and friends. The glasses are versatile and can be used for a variety of drinks, from classic cocktails to refreshing juices. They are also dishwasher safe, making clean-up a breeze.

2. Waterford Connoisseur Lismore Heritage Double Old Fashioned Set Of 6

The Connoisseur Collection by Waterford is a top-of-the-line crystal drinkware collection, designed to bring out the best in your favorite spirits. Made from the finest crystal, each piece is expertly crafted to enrich the bouquet and enhance the flavor profile of your drink.

This collection features six unique patterns, all sourced from the Waterford Archives. Each design is carefully crafted to showcase the beauty of the crystal, while also providing a functional and comfortable drinking experience.

Whether you prefer whiskey or brandy, this collection is perfect for sharing your favorite spirits with friends and loved ones. And with its classic Waterford packaging, it makes for an elegant and thoughtful gift for any occasion.

To ensure the longevity of these beautiful pieces, it is recommended to hand wash them with a soft cloth. With proper care, the Connoisseur Collection by Waterford will be a cherished addition to any home bar for years to come.

3. Crystal Whiskey Glasses – The Perfect Gift!

Impress your guests and elevate your drinking experience with these elegant twisted whiskey glasses. Crafted from the finest quality crystal, these glasses are perfect for sharing a toast on special occasions with family or clients, or for playing poker and partying with friends.

The thick walls and heavy weighted base of these glasses are extremely durable and keep your drink insulated at the perfect temperature for longer, whether you prefer it ice cold or room temperature. The twisted design makes them easy to hold, and at 10 oz, they're the perfect size for a double shot and mixer, or even as classy juice or water glasses. They can fit large ice cubes up to 2", perfect for drinking any liquor like Scotch Whiskey, Bourbon, Old Fashioned Cocktail, Cognac, and more.

Packed in a satin-lined, padded presentation box, this set makes a wonderful gift for men or women for birthdays, Christmas, housewarming, or wedding anniversary. Add some elegance to your dining table and some wow factor at parties with these sparkling glasses. They're dishwasher safe and are covered by a lifetime warranty, so you'll never need to worry about them breaking.

Try these whiskey glasses risk-free with the satisfaction guarantee and lifetime warranty. The manufacturer stands by their products with outstanding customer service, and if you don't like them within 30 days, just return them for a full refund. If you ever have a problem with them, contact the manufacturer and they'll send you a free replacement. Click Add to Cart now and try them 100% risk-free today.

4. Premium Whiskey Glass Set For Scotch Lovers

Experience the ultimate whiskey drinking experience with this premium quality unique glass set. Featuring a stunning rock style design, this old fashioned cocktail glass set is perfect for serving scotch, whiskey, or mixed drinks. Whether you prefer Single Malt, Tennessee Rye, Brandy, Beer, Vodka, Old Fashioned Cocktails, Gin and Tonic, or any liquor, this set is sure to impress. You can even use them as a classy way to serve water or juice at your dining table.

Crafted for serious whiskey lovers, these glasses are designed to enhance your drinking experience. Your favorite liquor has been aged in a barrel for 18 years, and it deserves to be poured into a glass that maintains its full flavor profile. These glasses are perfect for that purpose, ensuring that you taste every nuance and detail of your favorite drink.

This set includes 6 short whiskey glasses that you can use for whisky, scotch, bourbon, vodka, and almost any cocktails you can think of. They have a standard size of 11 oz, making them feel comfortable in your hands and not too small for ice cubes. You'll love using them for special occasions or just for enjoying your favorite drink at home.

This set makes for the perfect gift for whiskey lovers. Each glass is hand-blown from lead-free crystal and sparkles beautifully in the light. They are an exceptional value and an excellent gift for any occasion, whether it's a birthday, Mother's or Father's Day, engagement, wedding anniversary, christening, or Christmas.

The glasses are dishwasher safe, making cleaning up a breeze. And if they are damaged in any way upon arrival, the manufacturer will send you a replacement set free of charge. So why wait? Order your set today and experience the ultimate whiskey drinking experience!

5. Hamilton Crystal Whiskey Glasses – Handcrafted In Germany.

Introducing the Crystal Whiskey Glasses "Hamilton" – a stunning addition to any whiskey lover's collection. These glasses have been expertly crafted by hand in Germany by the skilled artisans at EISCH glassworks. Made from lead-free crystal, they have a thick weighted bottom that provides a comfortable and balanced feel when holding the glass.

The unique "frozen" look of the silk-matt cut is simply breathtaking and will leave your guests in awe. The cut is not only visually striking but also provides a tactile experience that will have you reaching for these glasses time and time again.

The EISCH Whiskey Tumblers come beautifully packaged in an attractive gift tube, making them the perfect present for any occasion. The gift box not only looks great but also serves to protect the glasses during transportation. Whether it's a Christmas, birthday, wedding, or Father's day gift, these glasses are sure to impress.

The EISCH Whiskey Tumblers are also incredibly easy to clean. They are 100% dishwasher proof, meaning you can simply pop them in the machine and let it do the work for you. You won't have to worry about hand-washing delicate glassware or damaging the appearance of the glasses.

When it comes to quality, EISCH is a name you can trust. They are one of the last traditional family-owned glass manufacturers in Germany and have been producing high-quality glassware since 1946. Their commitment to excellence is reflected in the numerous awards they have won for their unique design, innovation, and exceptional quality standards.

6. Waterford Whiskey & Water Double Old Fashioned, Pair 12 Oz

If you're a fan of vintage cocktails, then the Whiskey & Water Double Old Fashioned set of two is the perfect glass for you. This glass is specifically designed to enhance your drinking experience, making it the ideal choice for whiskey enthusiasts. The glass set features a grey cut with a unique design on the base of each, combining the words Whiskey and Water in a sleek and stylish way.

The Whiskey & Water Double Old Fashioned set of two is not only functional but also visually appealing, with its unique cuts and retro-style shapes. These elements come together to create an interesting mix-and-match barware story that will elevate any home bar or cocktail party.

Inspired by the Irish spirit of togetherness, sharing, and interaction, this glass set is perfect for those who enjoy entertaining and hosting guests. The glasses are designed to encourage socializing and conversation, making them a great addition to any gathering.

The Whiskey & Water Double Old Fashioned set is made from high-quality materials, ensuring durability and longevity. The glasses are also easy to clean, making them a convenient addition to any home bar.

7. Riedel H2o Classic Bar Old Fashioned Whiskey Glass, Set Of 6, 15.12 Ounces

Introducing a machine-made crystal glass that is both elegant and functional, perfect for enjoying classic cocktails, whiskey, or even just water. Crafted from high-quality, non-leaded crystal, this glass boasts a clear and pristine appearance that is sure to impress your guests.

Not only is this glass visually stunning, but it is also highly durable and dishwasher safe, making it an ideal choice for everyday use or special occasions. Whether you're hosting a dinner party or enjoying a relaxing evening at home, this glass is sure to enhance your drinking experience.

Looking for a thoughtful gift for a friend or loved one? This crystal glass makes the perfect present for any occasion. Its timeless design and superior quality make it a gift that will be appreciated for years to come.

8. Premium Crystal Whiskey Glasses: Rock Style Collection.

The Szmmg Whiskey Glasses offer a superior value for their price point. Compared to other vendors that sell only 2 or 4 glasses at the same or higher price, Szmmg offers a set of 6 high-quality whiskey glasses.

These whiskey glasses are made with the best quality lead-free crystal, which is known for its transparency and lustrous appearance. The modern twisted design of the glasses sparkles beautifully in the light and adds an elegant touch when serving scotch or other drinks. The glasses are perfect for sharing a toast on special occasions with family or clients, or for playing poker and partying with friends.

The classic design of the glasses features a thick, weighted bottom that can accommodate oversized ice cubes or whiskey stones. Each glass can hold a full 10 ounces of your favorite drink, making them ideal for friends and loved ones who enjoy manhattans, whiskey, scotch, bourbon, rye, cocktails, or mixology enthusiasts. The whiskey glasses come in premium gift packaging, making them an excellent choice for birthdays, Mother's or Father's Day, housewarming, wedding anniversary, christening, or Christmas.

The SZMMG whiskey glassware is solid and durable, thanks to the platinum glass production process. These glasses are heavier than others, giving a real sense of strength and substantiality. The glasses are virtually unbreakable and dishwasher safe, making them easy to maintain. They are also durable enough to retain their sparkle for many years to come.

The Szmmg Whiskey Glasses add elegance to your dining table and the wow factor at parties. The size of these rocks glasses is impressive, as they can easily fit a double shot, mixer, and plenty of ice cubes, rocks, or whiskey stones. You can use these glasses for drinking your single malt, rye, cognac, beer, vodka, old-fashioned cocktails, gin and tonic, or any liquor you like. They are also a classy way to serve water or juice at your dining table.

9. Corkcicle's Whiskey Chill: Old Fashioned Perfection

The Whiskey Wedge offers a unique and artistic way to savor your favorite spirits without compromising their flavor. This innovative product includes a Double Old-Fashioned Whiskey Glass and a Silicone Ice Form that freezes the wedge of ice into the glass, keeping your drink perfectly chilled without diluting it.

Using the Whiskey Wedge is simple. All you need to do is insert the silicone ice form into the glass and fill it with water. Once frozen, the ice assumes the shape of a wedge on one side of the glass. This ensures that your drink stays cold for longer, allowing you to savor every sip.

The Whiskey Wedge makes an ideal gift for all occasions. Whether you're looking for a birthday present, anniversary gift, or a token of appreciation for a whiskey lover in your life, this product is sure to impress. It is perfect for spirit enthusiasts who appreciate the finer things in life.

In addition to its aesthetic appeal, the Whiskey Wedge is also highly functional. It is made from high-quality materials that are built to last, ensuring that you can enjoy your favorite spirits in style for years to come.

10. Barski Crystal Whiskey Set – Stackable And Sophisticated

This lead-free crystal decanter and tumbler set is a stunning addition to any home bar or dining table. The crystal material provides exceptional clarity and brilliance, making it a perfect vessel for showcasing your favorite spirits.

The set includes a 12 oz. decanter and two 12 oz. double old fashioned tumblers, each standing at 9" in height. This size is perfect for serving drinks to guests or enjoying a nightcap with a loved one.

The set comes in a pretty box, making it an excellent option for gifting. There's no need to wrap it, as the box itself is a beautiful presentation. It's an ideal gift for someone special or for personal use.

One of the best features of this set is its convenience. It's dishwasher safe, making cleaning a breeze. You won't have to worry about hand washing delicate crystal or spending hours polishing it.

11. Orrefors Intermezzo Blue 8.33 Ounce Old Fashioned/whiskey, Set Of 2 –

The Orrefors Intermezzo Blue Collection has earned its place as one of the all-time bestsellers, with over ten million glasses sold worldwide. This stemware collection, designed by Erika Lagerbielke in 1985, is not only stunning but also highly functional and handmade in Sweden. The Intermezzo Blue Old Fashioned/Whiskey glass, which features a distinct blue drop in its base, has captured the hearts of consumers over the years.

Orrefors is renowned for its exceptional quality crystal and old-world craftsmanship. In the Orrefors hot shops, you can witness the mesmerizing transformation of glass from a molten state to glittering crystal and works of art. The designers, glass blowers, cutters, painters, and engravers at Orrefors all play a crucial role in creating each glass, bowl, vase, and pair of candlesticks, which is a masterpiece of craftsmanship.

Established in 1898, Orrefors is a Swedish crystal brand that offers a range of glass tableware and homeware items, as well as art created by their well-known designers and skilled craftsmen. Orrefors represents the epitome of quality and Scandinavian design, combined with contemporary style and ease of use.

Erika Lagerbielke, the Queen of Orrefors stemware, designed this product. No other designer has created as many series of stemware for Orrefors, nor has anyone matched her success in doing so. Erika's great love for glassmaking craftsmanship and her knowledge of the different characteristics of various drinks are probably the keys to her success. When creating new series, Erika collaborates with wine experts to ensure that each glass is perfect for its intended use.

The Orrefors Intermezzo Blue Old Fashioned/Whiskey pair is handcrafted in Sweden using non-leaded crystal. The glasses have a height of 3.5 inches and a width of 3.2 inches, with an 8-ounce capacity. To maintain their exquisite appearance, these glasses should be hand washed.

With item dimensions of height 9.9" x width 2.6" and a weight of 0.4lbs, this product is the epitome of elegance and sophistication. The fact that it is made in Sweden adds to its allure and authenticity. If you're looking for a beautiful, functional, and exceptionally crafted set of old-fashioned/whiskey glasses, the Orrefors Intermezzo Blue Old Fashioned/Whiskey pair is an excellent choice.

Best Whisky For Old Fashioned FAQs

Are there any specific regions or countries that produce the best whisky for old fashioned?

When it comes to making the perfect Old Fashioned, the type of whisky used is essential. While there are no specific regions or countries that produce the best whisky for Old Fashioned, certain types of whisky are preferred.

Bourbon, which is a type of American whiskey, is commonly used in Old Fashioned cocktails. Its sweet and smoky flavor profile perfectly complements the bitters and sugar in an Old Fashioned. Rye whiskey is another popular choice for making an Old Fashioned. Known for its spicy and bold flavor, rye whiskey adds a unique kick to the cocktail.

Scotch whisky, which is made in Scotland, is another option for those who prefer a smokier taste in their Old Fashioned. Japanese whisky is also gaining popularity in the Old Fashioned world due to its smooth and delicate flavor profile.

Ultimately, the best whisky for an Old Fashioned is a matter of personal preference. Experiment with different types of whisky to find the one that suits your taste buds.

How much should I spend on a bottle of whisky for making an old fashioned?

The cost of a bottle of whisky for making an old fashioned can vary depending on your personal preference and budget. However, as a general rule of thumb, it is recommended to use a mid to high-range whisky that costs between $30 to $50 for a 750ml bottle. This will ensure that you are using a whisky that has enough complexity and flavor to complement the other ingredients in the cocktail and provide a smooth and enjoyable drinking experience. It is important to note that the quality of the other ingredients in the cocktail, such as the sugar and bitters, also play a significant role in the overall taste of the old fashioned. Therefore, it is worth investing in high-quality ingredients to create a delicious and well-balanced cocktail.

Is bourbon or rye whisky better for an old fashioned?

Both bourbon and rye whisky can be used to make an old fashioned, and the choice ultimately depends on personal preference.

Bourbon tends to have a sweeter and smoother flavor profile due to its higher percentage of corn in the mash bill. This can lend itself well to the sweetness of an old fashioned cocktail. On the other hand, rye whisky has a spicier and drier taste due to its higher percentage of rye in the mash bill. This can add a nice complexity to the drink and cut through the sweetness of the sugar and bitters.

It's important to note that the quality of the whiskey used in an old fashioned is crucial. Look for a high-quality bourbon or rye that has a complex flavor profile and can stand up to the other ingredients in the drink.

Ultimately, the choice between bourbon or rye in an old fashioned comes down to personal taste. It's worth trying both to see which one you prefer in your cocktail.

Should I select a smoky or non-smoky whisky for my old fashioned?

The choice between a smoky or non-smoky whisky for an old fashioned largely depends on your personal preference and the flavor profile you want to achieve. A smoky whisky, such as an Islay scotch, will bring a bold and peaty flavor to the cocktail. This can be a great option if you want to add a smoky dimension to your drink and enjoy the taste of peat smoke. On the other hand, a non-smoky whisky, such as a bourbon or rye, will have a smoother and sweeter taste that can balance well with other ingredients in the old fashioned. Ultimately, it's up to you to experiment with different types of whiskies and find the flavor that you enjoy the most. Keep in mind that the quality of the whisky is also important, so choose a well-crafted bottle for the best results.

Should I use a single malt or a blended whisky for my old fashioned?

The choice between single malt and blended whisky for an old fashioned ultimately comes down to personal preference. Single malt whisky is made from 100% malted barley and is typically smoother and more complex in flavor than blended whisky, which is a combination of different single malt whiskies mixed with grain whisky.

If you prefer a stronger and more complex flavor profile, a single malt whisky may be the way to go. However, if you prefer a smoother and more balanced taste, a blended whisky may be a better choice.

It's important to note that the quality of the whisky used in an old fashioned is crucial to the overall taste of the cocktail. Regardless of whether you choose a single malt or blended whisky, it's important to choose a high-quality whisky that you enjoy drinking on its own.

Ultimately, the decision between single malt and blended whisky for an old fashioned is a matter of personal preference and experimentation. Try different options and see which one you prefer in your cocktail.

What age statement should I look for in a whisky for my old fashioned?

When it comes to making an Old Fashioned, the age statement of the whisky you choose is a matter of personal preference. A traditional Old Fashioned is made with bourbon, which is typically aged between 4 and 12 years. However, some people prefer to use rye whisky, which is also aged for varying lengths of time.

The age statement on a bottle of whisky refers to the youngest whisky in the blend. So, if you are looking for a 10-year-old whisky, it means that the youngest whisky in the bottle is 10 years old, but there may be older whiskies in the blend as well.

Ultimately, the age statement of the whisky you choose will affect the flavor profile of your Old Fashioned. Younger whiskies tend to be more vibrant and have a stronger alcohol taste, while older whiskies are smoother and more complex. It's a matter of personal preference, so experiment with different age statements to find the one that suits your taste.

What are some of the most popular whisky brands for making an old fashioned?

Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail that has been around for over a century and is still popular today. When it comes to making an Old Fashioned, the choice of whisky plays a crucial role in the taste and quality of the drink. Here are some of the most popular whisky brands for making an Old Fashioned:

1. Bulleit Bourbon: This is a popular choice for Old Fashioned as it has a high rye content, giving the drink a spicy kick.

2. Woodford Reserve: This premium bourbon has a smooth and rich flavor with notes of vanilla and caramel, making it an excellent choice for an Old Fashioned.

3. Maker's Mark: This is a classic Kentucky bourbon that has a rich, sweet flavor with hints of vanilla and oak, making it a great option for an Old Fashioned.

4. Buffalo Trace: This award-winning bourbon has a complex flavor profile, with hints of toffee, vanilla, and spice, making it an excellent choice for an Old Fashioned.

5. Rittenhouse Rye: This is a very popular rye whisky that is often used for Old Fashioned cocktails due to its spicy and bold flavors.

Ultimately, the choice of whisky for an Old Fashioned comes down to personal preference, but these brands are a great place to start.

What are the best whisky brands for making an old fashioned?

When it comes to making an old fashioned, the choice of whisky is crucial as it forms the backbone of the cocktail. There are many great whisky brands out there, but a few stand out as particularly well-suited to an old fashioned. One of the most popular choices is Maker's Mark, a smooth and mellow bourbon that pairs perfectly with the sweetness of the sugar and the bitterness of the bitters in the cocktail. Another great option is Bulleit Bourbon, which has a bold and spicy flavor that works well with the other ingredients in the old fashioned. For those who prefer a more complex and nuanced flavor profile, Rittenhouse Rye is an excellent choice, with its notes of caramel, vanilla, and spice adding depth and richness to the cocktail. Ultimately, the best whisky brand for an old fashioned will depend on your personal taste preferences, but these three options are a great place to start.

What characteristics should I look for in a whisky that will complement an old fashioned?

When selecting a whisky to complement an old fashioned, there are a few characteristics to keep in mind. Firstly, you want a whisky that has enough flavor and body to hold up to the sweetness of the cocktail. Look for a whisky that has notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, which will complement the flavors of the sugar and bitters in the old fashioned.

Secondly, consider the age of the whisky. Older whiskies tend to have a smoother, more complex flavor profile that will enhance the cocktail rather than overpower it. A whisky that has been aged in oak barrels will also impart a subtle smokiness that can add depth to the drink.

Finally, pay attention to the proof of the whisky. A higher proof whisky can stand up to the dilution of the ice in the cocktail, ensuring that the flavor remains balanced throughout the drinking experience.

Overall, when selecting a whisky to complement an old fashioned, look for a flavorful, aged whisky with a smooth finish and a higher proof.

What is the ideal proof for whisky used in an old fashioned?

The ideal proof for whisky used in an old fashioned can vary depending on personal preference, but generally falls between 80-100 proof. The higher the proof, the more intense the flavor and aroma of the whisky will be, which can be a desirable characteristic in an old fashioned. However, a lower proof whisky can also work well, as it allows the other ingredients in the cocktail, such as sugar and bitters, to shine through. Ultimately, the key is to choose a whisky that complements the other flavors in the drink and suits your personal taste. It's also worth noting that the quality of the whisky is just as important as the proof, so always choose a high-quality spirit that you enjoy.