When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Tomatoes For Tomato Soup (2025 Update)

If you’re looking for the perfect tomatoes to add to your tomato soup recipe, then you’ve come to the right place. The type of tomato you choose can make all the difference in the flavor and texture of your finished soup. There are a few factors to consider when selecting tomatoes for your soup recipe.

Firstly, you should consider the ripeness and firmness of the tomato. Overripe or soft tomatoes can cause your soup to become too watery and lack texture. On the other hand, underripe tomatoes can result in a flavorless soup. Therefore, make sure to choose tomatoes that are ripe, firm, and juicy.

Another important factor to consider is the variety of tomato. There are many different types of tomatoes available, and each has a distinct flavor profile. Some tomatoes are sweeter, while others are more acidic. You should consider your personal taste preferences, as well as what other ingredients you’ll be adding to your soup.

Do you prefer a creamy tomato soup, or a chunkier, broth-based soup? Will you be adding any other vegetables or herbs to your soup? These are just some of the questions you should ask yourself when selecting the best tomatoes for your tomato soup recipe. With the right ingredients, you can create a delicious, comforting soup that will warm you up on even the coldest days.

10 Best Tomatoes For Tomato Soup

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
It is ideal for those looking for a low-sodium, organic option for tomato soup in bulk quantities.
2
This product is ideal for those who enjoy creamy tomato soup in convenient, pre-packaged cans for easy serving.
3
The product is ideal for individuals who enjoy having soup or need a quick and easy meal.
4
Ideal for those looking for a convenient and delicious organic soup made with roasted red peppers and tomatoes.
5
Ideal for individuals seeking a healthy, gluten-free, organic, and low sodium tomato soup option, sold in bulk quantities.
6
It is ideal for those who want ready-to-eat organic creamy tomato soup in bulk without compromising taste and quality.
7
It is ideal for individuals seeking a gluten-free, organic, low-fat, and low-sodium option for their cream of tomato soup.
8
Ideal for those seeking a creamy, gluten-free and reduced sodium tomato soup option in a bulk package.
9
It is ideal for individuals who are looking for a healthy, gluten-free and organic soup option that is low in fat.
10
Ideal for a quick and convenient hot soup option on-the-go, at work, or at home.
It is ideal for those looking for a low-sodium, organic option for tomato soup in bulk quantities.
This product is ideal for those who enjoy creamy tomato soup in convenient, pre-packaged cans for easy serving.
The product is ideal for individuals who enjoy having soup or need a quick and easy meal.
Ideal for those looking for a convenient and delicious organic soup made with roasted red peppers and tomatoes.
Ideal for individuals seeking a healthy, gluten-free, organic, and low sodium tomato soup option, sold in bulk quantities.
It is ideal for those who want ready-to-eat organic creamy tomato soup in bulk without compromising taste and quality.
It is ideal for individuals seeking a gluten-free, organic, low-fat, and low-sodium option for their cream of tomato soup.
Ideal for those seeking a creamy, gluten-free and reduced sodium tomato soup option in a bulk package.
It is ideal for individuals who are looking for a healthy, gluten-free and organic soup option that is low in fat.
Ideal for a quick and convenient hot soup option on-the-go, at work, or at home.

1. Health Valley Organic Soup, No Salt Added, Tomato, 15 Oz (Pack Of 12)

This product is a healthy and delicious option for those who are looking for a low-sodium and low-fat tomato product. It is made with organic tomatoes, ensuring that you are consuming a product that is free from harmful pesticides and chemicals.

One of the benefits of this product is that it is low in sodium and contains no added salt. This is especially important for those who are watching their sodium intake, as a high-sodium diet can lead to a number of health issues.

In addition to being low in sodium, this product is also a good source of fiber and an excellent source of antioxidant vitamin C. These nutrients are essential for maintaining good health and can help to boost your immune system and protect against disease.

This product has been certified by the USDA Organic, American Heart Association, and Gluten Free Certification Organization. This means that you can trust that you are consuming a product that is not only healthy but also meets strict quality standards.

Finally, the can lining used for this product is not derived from BPA. BPA has been linked to a number of health issues, including cancer and hormonal imbalances, so it is important to choose products that are free from this harmful chemical.

2. Heinz Soup, Cream Of Tomato, 13.2 -Ounce Cans (Pack Of 8)

Introducing the Pack of Eight, 13.2-Ounce Cans each, a convenient and delicious way to enjoy a tasty meal that is both healthy and satisfying. With no artificial flavors or preservatives, this product is perfect for those who are health-conscious and want to enjoy a meal without worrying about harmful additives.

The new recipe includes reduced salt, sugar, and fat, making it a great choice for those who want to maintain a healthy diet without sacrificing taste. Each can contains 13.2 ounces of nutritious goodness, providing a hearty meal that will leave you feeling full and satisfied.

Whether you're looking for a quick and easy meal on-the-go or a tasty snack to enjoy at home, this Pack of Eight, 13.2-Ounce Cans each has got you covered. With its high-quality ingredients and delicious taste, this product is sure to become a staple in your pantry.

So why wait? Try the Pack of Eight, 13.2-Ounce Cans each today and experience the perfect combination of taste and nutrition.

3. Heinz, Soup Cream Of Tomato, 14.1-Ounce (12 Pack)

Introducing a delicious and convenient option for soup and stew lovers, this Packaged Soup and Stew is a must-have in every kitchen. With a package dimension of 15.900 cm L X23.901 cm W X31.191 cm H and a weight of 5.788 kg, this product is easy to store and handle.

Sourced from the United Kingdom, this soup and stew pack is made with high-quality ingredients, ensuring a delectable taste that will satisfy anyone's cravings. It's perfect for those busy days when you don't have time to cook, or for when you simply want a warm and comforting meal in minutes.

This packaged soup and stew provides a balanced and nutritious meal that's suitable for any time of the day. It's an excellent source of essential vitamins and minerals, making it a healthy option for those who want to maintain a well-balanced diet.

The product's package includes all the necessary ingredients, making it easy to prepare in no time. Simply follow the instructions on the package, and you'll have a delicious and hearty meal ready in minutes.

4. Pacific Foods Organic Creamy Roasted Red Pepper & Tomato Soup, 32 Fl Oz (Pack Of 12)

This delicious tomato soup is a perfect blend of organic vine-ripened tomatoes, slow roasted red peppers, organic milk, and a warm blend of spices, creating a unique taste that is a step up from traditional tomato soup. The soup is also infused with garlic and onion flavors, which round out the flavor and add depth, making it a perfect comfort food for any occasion.

This soup is vegetarian and gluten-free, making it a healthy option for people with dietary restrictions. The soup is easy to prepare; it can be heated in the microwave or on the stovetop, making it a convenient option for busy individuals.

The soup comes in a 12-pack of 32-ounce convenient resealable, twist open cartons, making it easy to store and use as needed. The cartons are also Kosher Dairy, Soy Free, Wheat Free, and Yeast Free, making it a great option for people with specific dietary needs.

5. Amy's Soup, Gluten Free, Organic Chunky Tomato Bisque, Light In Sodium, 14.5 Ounce (Pack Of 12)

Amy’s Organic Chunky Tomato Bisque Soup is a delicious and healthy option for those seeking a quick and easy meal. The package includes twelve 14.5-oz cans of soup, each containing organic sun-ripened tomatoes blended with a touch of organic cream to create a savory bisque. Additionally, this soup is light in sodium, with 50 percent less sodium than Amy's regular soup.

This canned soup is a great source of plant-based protein and fiber, containing 5g and 4g per serving, respectively. It is also Non-GMO, USDA-Certified Organic, Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, and Certified Kosher, making it a high-quality plant-based food that everyone can enjoy.

Preparing this soup is a breeze. Simply heat it up in a microwave-safe bowl for two minutes, or warm it up in a saucepan on the stove and stir occasionally. This makes it a convenient option for those who are busy or looking for a quick, healthy lunch option.

Amy’s Kitchen has been producing delicious, quick, and convenient vegetarian meals since 1987. By choosing Amy’s Organic Chunky Tomato Bisque Soup, you can enjoy a tasty meal without having to compromise on quality or nutrition.

6. Pacific Foods Organic Creamy Tomato Soup, 32oz (Pack Of 12)

Introducing the delicious and nutritious Organic Tomato Soup by Pacific. Made with fresh organic milk and tangy sweet tomatoes, this creamy soup is sure to be a family favorite. This vegetarian soup is also non-GMO and gluten-free, free of preservatives and additives, making it a clean and simple option for those looking to maintain a healthy lifestyle.

Not only is this soup delicious, but it is also packed with 5 grams of protein, making it a great option for a quick and easy meal or snack. The high-quality organic ingredients used in this soup ensure that you are getting only the best in every bowl.

Convenience is key with Pacific's Organic Tomato Soup. This pantry staple can be stored for later use, with its resealable 32-ounce cartons that are shelf-stable. Simply reheat in minutes in the microwave or on the stove for a delicious and comforting meal anytime.

Pacific's Organic Tomato Soup is also soy-free, wheat-free, and yeast-free, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions or sensitivities. This soup ships as a pack of 12, ensuring you always have a convenient and delicious option on hand.

7. Amy's Soup, Gluten Free, Organic Cream Of Tomato, Light In Sodium, Low Fat, 14.5 Oz (Pack Of 12)

Amy's Organic Cream of Tomato Soup is a perfect blend of organic sun-ripened tomatoes and organic cream, providing a delicious and healthy meal option. This pack includes twelve (12) 14.5-oz cans of low-fat and light in sodium soup, with 50 percent less sodium than other Amy's canned soups.

This cream of tomato soup is perfect for those who want a quick and easy meal without compromising on the taste. It is Non-GMO, USDA-Certified Organic, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Vegan, and Certified Kosher, suitable for people with different dietary needs.

One cup of this soup contains only 3g of fat, making it a low-fat option for a healthy lunch or an easy dinner. Preparing this soup is convenient and hassle-free, as it can be heated in the microwave for 1 minute 30 seconds to 2 minutes or in a saucepan on the stove, stirring occasionally.

Amy's Kitchen has been producing delicious plant-based foods and vegetarian meals since 1987. This soup is a perfect example of their commitment to providing convenient and healthy food options for people who are too busy to cook.

8. Progresso Reduced Sodium, Creamy Tomato With Basil Soup, Gluten Free, 19 Oz. (Pack Of 12)

Introducing a savory and healthy option for those looking for a quick meal – the Reduced-Sodium Tomato Basil Vegetable Soup. Made with the finest ingredients, this canned soup is a perfect combination of real tomato and basil, creating a delightful taste that will surely satisfy your appetite.

What sets this soup apart is its commitment to quality. It contains absolutely no artificial flavors, and no colors from artificial sources, ensuring that you only get the best and most natural ingredients in every spoonful.

Preparing your meal has never been this easy! This ready-to-serve canned soup only takes under 5 minutes to heat up, saving you valuable time and effort in the kitchen.

Each pack contains 12 cans, with each can weighing 19 oz., giving you enough servings for everyone in the family. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch, or a warm and comforting dinner, the Reduced-Sodium Tomato Basil Vegetable Soup is the perfect choice for you.

Experience the rich and delicious flavors of this soup, while also taking care of your health. Order now and enjoy a quick and satisfying meal that's perfect for any occasion!

9. Amy's Soup, Gluten Free, Organic Cream Of Tomato, Low Fat, 14.5 Oz (Pack Of 12)

Amy’s Organic Cream of Tomato Soup is a must-have for anyone who desires quick and easy meals without compromising on taste or health. This product comes in a pack of twelve (12) 14.5-oz cans, each filled with rich and creamy soup made from organic sun-ripened tomatoes and a touch of organic cream.

One of the outstanding features of Amy’s Cream of Tomato Soup is that it is low in fat, with only 3g of fat per cup. It is also USDA-Certified Organic, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Vegan, and Certified Kosher, making it a healthy and safe choice for everyone.

Preparing this delicious soup is effortless and can be done in a matter of minutes. Simply heat it in a microwave-safe bowl for 1 minute 30 seconds to 2 minutes, or heat it in a saucepan on the stove and stir occasionally for a hearty, ready-made meal.

Amy’s Kitchen, the creator of this delicious soup, has been producing convenient plant-based food and vegetarian meals since 1987. With this product, you can be assured of quality, taste, and nutrition in every can.

10. Campbell's Sipping Soup, Classic Tomato Soup, 11.1 Oz Microwavable Cup (Case Of 8)

Campbell's Sipping Soup offers a convenient and delicious way to enjoy a comforting cup of tomato soup. This pack includes eight (8) 11.1 oz microwavable cups of the Classic Tomato Soup flavor, perfect for those who love the nostalgic and delicious taste of tomato puree.

This tomato soup is vegetarian and vegan friendly, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions. It is also made without high fructose corn syrup, artificial colors, or added MSG, ensuring that you are getting a healthy and natural soup.

The portable soup cup makes it easy to enjoy this soup on the go. Simply remove the lid, peel off the tab, microwave the soup, let it sit, replace the cap, and enjoy. This makes it a great snack or side dish for meals while on the road or at work.

In addition to its convenience, Campbell's Sipping Soup is also delicious and satisfying. Its classic flavor will bring back fond memories of childhood, while its nourishing ingredients will leave you feeling full and satisfied.

Best Tomatoes For Tomato Soup FAQs

Are heirloom tomatoes better than regular tomatoes for tomato soup?

Heirloom tomatoes can be a great choice for making tomato soup due to their unique flavor and texture. Unlike regular tomatoes, heirloom varieties are open-pollinated and have been passed down from generation to generation, resulting in a wider range of colors, shapes, and tastes. They tend to have a sweeter, more complex flavor profile that can add depth to soups and stews.

That being said, regular tomatoes can also be used to make delicious tomato soup. They are widely available and often less expensive than heirloom tomatoes, making them a practical option for those on a budget. Additionally, certain types of regular tomatoes, such as San Marzano or Roma, are known for their meatier texture and lower water content, which can make for a thicker, creamier soup.

Ultimately, the choice between heirloom and regular tomatoes for tomato soup comes down to personal preference and availability. Both options can be delicious and satisfying, and it's worth experimenting with different varieties to find the one that suits your taste.

Are there any varieties of tomatoes that should be avoided when making tomato soup?

When it comes to making tomato soup, there are certain varieties of tomatoes that you may want to avoid. While any type of tomato can technically be used, some are better suited for soups than others.

One variety to avoid is the beefsteak tomato, as it tends to be too meaty and juicy for soup. This can result in a watery consistency and a lack of flavor. Instead, try using Roma tomatoes, which have a firmer texture and a sweeter taste.

Another variety to steer clear of is the cherry tomato, which is too small and sweet for soup. It can also be difficult to peel and blend, resulting in a chunky and uneven texture. Instead, opt for larger tomatoes like beefsteak or Roma.

Ultimately, the best tomatoes for tomato soup are those that have a balance of sweetness and acidity, are easy to peel and blend, and have a firm texture that will hold up well in the soup.

Can cherry tomatoes be used for tomato soup?

Yes, cherry tomatoes can definitely be used for making tomato soup. In fact, they are a great choice for a sweeter and more intense flavor in soup. Cherry tomatoes are smaller and sweeter than regular tomatoes, which makes them perfect for roasting and then blending into a creamy soup.

To make tomato soup using cherry tomatoes, you can start by roasting them in the oven with some garlic and olive oil for about 20-25 minutes until they are soft and caramelized. Then, transfer them into a blender or food processor and blend until smooth. You can add some vegetable or chicken broth to thin out the soup, and season it with salt, pepper, and any other spices or herbs of your choice.

Overall, cherry tomatoes are a versatile and delicious ingredient that can be used for a variety of dishes, including tomato soup. So, go ahead and give it a try!

How do I choose the best tomatoes for tomato soup?

When it comes to making tomato soup, choosing the right tomatoes is crucial to achieving the perfect flavor. Here are some tips to help you pick the best tomatoes for your soup:

1. Look for ripe, juicy tomatoes – The most important factor in choosing tomatoes for soup is their ripeness. Ripe tomatoes will have a deep red color, be slightly soft to the touch, and have a strong, sweet aroma.

2. Choose tomatoes with a meaty texture – While juicy tomatoes are important, you also want to choose tomatoes that have a meaty texture, as they will thicken the soup and give it a heartier flavor.

3. Consider the variety of tomato – There are many different types of tomatoes, and each will impart a slightly different flavor to your soup. For example, Roma tomatoes are known for their meaty texture and low water content, while beefsteak tomatoes are larger and more juicy.

4. Avoid overripe or bruised tomatoes – Overripe or bruised tomatoes can have a slightly sour taste and may make your soup taste off.

In summary, choose ripe, meaty tomatoes with a variety of texture and avoid overripe or bruised tomatoes for the best tomato soup.

How do I know if the tomatoes I have are good for tomato soup?

To determine if the tomatoes you have are good for making tomato soup, there are a few things to consider.

Firstly, the best tomatoes for soup are those that are ripe, juicy, and flavorful. Look for tomatoes that are bright red in color and feel heavy for their size. Generally, tomatoes that are vine-ripened will have the best flavor, so try to choose those if possible.

Secondly, the type of tomato can also make a difference in the flavor and texture of your soup. Plum tomatoes, also known as Roma tomatoes, are a popular choice for tomato soup as they have a meaty texture and a sweeter taste. However, you can use any variety of tomato you prefer.

Lastly, it's important to make sure that the tomatoes are free of any mold, bruises or soft spots. These can indicate that the tomatoes are starting to spoil and may not be suitable for use in soup.

Overall, the best way to know if your tomatoes are good for soup is to use your senses and choose those that are ripe, flavorful, and free of any defects.

Is there a specific ripeness level that is best for tomatoes used in tomato soup?

When it comes to making tomato soup, the ripeness level of the tomatoes can play a significant role in the flavor and texture of the soup. Generally, it is recommended to use ripe tomatoes for making tomato soup, but not overripe ones. Overripe tomatoes can be too soft and may not hold up well during the cooking process, resulting in a mushy texture and a weaker flavor. On the other hand, underripe tomatoes can be too tart, making the soup sour.

When selecting tomatoes for tomato soup, look for those that are firm but yielding to pressure and have a deep, rich color. Tomatoes that are slightly underripe can also be used, but they should have a hint of red or orange to them. Avoid using green or unripe tomatoes as they can be too sour and may not produce the desired flavor.

In conclusion, ripe tomatoes are the best option for making tomato soup, but not overripe ones. It is important to choose tomatoes that are firm and have a deep color to create a flavorful and satisfying soup.

Should I use fresh or canned tomatoes for tomato soup?

It ultimately depends on personal preference, but generally, using fresh tomatoes will result in a brighter and fresher flavor in tomato soup. Canned tomatoes are typically cooked and processed before being canned, which can result in a slightly cooked or canned taste. However, using canned tomatoes can also be more convenient and cost-effective, especially if fresh tomatoes are out of season or not readily available.

If using fresh tomatoes, it's important to use ripe and flavorful tomatoes for the best results. Roma or San Marzano tomatoes are commonly used for tomato soup because they have a low water content and a higher concentration of flavor.

Regardless of whether you choose to use fresh or canned tomatoes, it's important to pay attention to the quality of the tomatoes and the other ingredients used in the soup. Adding fresh herbs and aromatics like garlic and onion can also enhance the overall flavor of the soup.

Should I use organic tomatoes for tomato soup or is it not necessary?

Organic tomatoes are always a better choice when it comes to cooking tomato soup. Organic tomatoes are grown without the use of synthetic pesticides or fertilizers, which makes them healthier for both the environment and for human consumption. These tomatoes are also richer in nutrients, have a more robust flavor, and are free of harmful chemicals that can cause health problems.

When making tomato soup, the quality of the tomatoes used is crucial in determining the overall taste and texture of the soup. Organic tomatoes are generally more flavorful and have a better texture than non-organic ones. Moreover, organic tomatoes are less likely to be genetically modified, which ensures that the soup is free from any unwanted genetically modified organisms.

Although organic tomatoes may be more expensive than non-organic ones, the benefits they offer in terms of taste, nutrition, and environmental impact make them a worthwhile investment. So, it is always better to use organic tomatoes for tomato soup for a healthier and tastier outcome.

What is the difference between using Roma tomatoes and beefsteak tomatoes for tomato soup?

The choice between Roma tomatoes and beefsteak tomatoes for tomato soup can impact the flavor and texture of the soup. Roma tomatoes, also known as plum tomatoes, have a firmer flesh and less juicy interior compared to beefsteak tomatoes. This makes them a good choice for tomato soups that require a thicker and smoother consistency. They also have a slightly sweeter taste than beefsteak tomatoes, which can enhance the overall flavor of the soup.

On the other hand, beefsteak tomatoes have a higher water content, which can result in a thinner and lighter soup. However, they have a meatier texture and a more acidic taste compared to Roma tomatoes. This can be an advantage when making tomato soup with bolder flavors, as the acidity can help balance out other ingredients.

Ultimately, the choice between Roma tomatoes and beefsteak tomatoes for tomato soup depends on personal preference and the desired outcome of the soup. Roma tomatoes are ideal for a smoother, sweeter soup, while beefsteak tomatoes are better suited for a more robust and acidic flavor.

What variety of tomatoes is best for making tomato soup?

When it comes to making tomato soup, the best variety of tomato to use is the Roma tomato. Roma tomatoes are known for their dense and meaty flesh, making them perfect for cooking down into a thick, rich soup. They also have a lower water content compared to other varieties, which means they will yield more concentrated flavors and a creamier texture when cooked.

That being said, other varieties of tomatoes can also be used to make tomato soup, such as San Marzano or beefsteak tomatoes. However, these varieties may require some additional steps to remove excess water and achieve the desired consistency of the soup. Ultimately, the key to making a delicious tomato soup is to use ripe, high-quality tomatoes and to cook them low and slow to bring out their natural sweetness and flavor.