20 Best Sugar Free Ice Cream For Diabetics (2023 Updated)

This product was a disappointment for me. Could accomplish the same thing. maybe better, with my magic bullet. It’s difficult to get the blade clean as fruit pieces get stuck in the teeth. It’s not smooth, like they make it look on the ad.

It’s like frozen chunks. Not worth the trouble set up, clean up, and doesn’t satisfy my craving for ice cream. I’ve emailed them twice to ask about a return, but they don’t respond.

This machine is amazing. Kids love it. Take frozen fruit (follow directions) Slightly thawed. Smush in machine and out comes a yummy sweet healthy treat. I love it. Very healthy treat. You do have to take the parts off and clean then so it’s not the easiest to clean (easy to me means put in dishwasher do nothing) but def worth it.

Most of the time I get my fill of ice cream, frozen yogurt and popsicles in the summer and early fall but there are times that I crave something cold and sweet in the dead of winter. Blenders can handle almost anything if they have enough horsepower but you need to use the pulse button or take the lid off and move the ingredients around so there’s contact with the blade.

When I saw a demonstration of the Yonanas Deluxe Ice Cream Treat Maker (also referred to as Yo’Nanas Frozen Healthy Treat Maker) I thought it would be perfect to use with all of the frozen berries and bananas I had in the freezer for baking.

If you want super soft and tasty bananas you should freeze them before cutting them up and mashing them, you will get a ton of flavor from them that way. While this is easy to use, it isn’t going to yield something that tastes like ice cream unless you add milk, cream or yogurt to it.

That’s good for people who are lactose intolerant and are looking for something that they can make special desserts with but if you want a regular ice cream maker, this isn’t for you. It isn’t going to make enough per batch to serve as you would ice cream but for single portions or diet portions for two people, it’s just right.

I have used a ton of different frozen fruits in this and the only thing that didn’t turn out all that great were grapes. I think the skins were too thick but this managed to tear through everything else I put in it so I can’t see how grape skins were a huge challenge.

The noise level is pretty high but you only have to run it for three to four minutes. It is relatively safe to use but wouldn’t allow those under the age of thirteen to use it without supervision. Most of the parts are dishwasher safe but I prefer to hand wash and air dry it so there’s no chance that the plastic will crack.

I bought the vegan bundle on the special golf 59. 99. I used my affirm. It does charge a bit of interest at time, but actually, in September, it had a special of no interest. ( Goli Apple Cider Vinegar Vitamns did this to me as well.

I got their special of 42. 00 on Afterpay, no interest & was charged 4 payments of 100. ) I only use these apps of affirm and afterpay to double secure my debit card due to fraud these days. So, let’s keep in mind, at 59.

00, even if there was a little interest, it would not have been doubled. My afterpay came up at 18. 72 a month making it 112. 72 which is over double of the 59. 99 of what the special was. This is exactly what happened on Goli which I have yet to get an answer from the company.

I do not appreciate or respect companies who do this. No matter how good the ice cream might be, customer service should be your number one priority. So, whoever is reading do not use any method like Affirn or afterpay where companies like this one or others with no integrity can try to double their money by keeping yours due to the fact that the other company has no idea what the deal was.

This is for the customer’s information only.

Best bundle ive had so far. Flavors are great. The hazlenut kram had way too many nuts. Would have been great if at least half the nuts were removed. There was more nuts than ice cream. I was happily surprised by how much i enjoyed the swedish cookie flavor.

My husband’s favorite was the peanut butter cup. He says it tasted better than Reese’s.

These fruit bars absolutely blew my mind. Most products in America are now made with high fructose corn syrup (cheap and heavily processed), and gelatin (to slow the melting and make less mess for kids and what not).

These are made with REAL cane sugar. The lemon were absolutely hands down fantastic! I don’t know who the people are on here that wrote the one-star reviews that have comments saying they had a bitter taste or whatever, I’m wondering if they had covid and a loss of taste because these taste EXACTLY how they are supposed to taste.

Made with real ingredients, no shortcuts in the process, no fake flavoring at all. If you like real food, whole food, you will love these. If you are used to eating fake lemon flavored items, such as super processed goods like snack cakes, you are not going to like this taste.

You will be much more accustomed to the fake lemon flavor versus these REAL fruit bars. I can’t convey fully how fantastic these were. I have told at least 10 people about them in the last week.

A fruit bar acting all healthy when in reality its comprised of mostly cane sugar. To top it off the taste is watered down watermelon. These bars are basically pure cane sugar. There are 13g of sugar per bar and 11gs of it are added cane sugar.

There are 60 calories per bar. There are 12. 5g of sugar in a tablespoon. 13g of sugar equals 50 calories. Nothing more than a tablespoon of cane sugar parading around as a fruit bar.

Loved this product. I would rather have real sugar in moderation than that high fructose corn syrup garbage that your body doesn’t know what to do with it. It never had enough shelf space before the pandemic.

During and since the pandemic, it is no where to be found in the Chicago area. All the original flavor (non-diet) drinks seem to be all HFCS! That stuff is bad news. Guess I got on the wrong boat with Dr.

Pepper Made with Real Sugar. I switched over to Pure Leaf Raspberry Tea. Great resealable caps. It’s brewed (not from powder) and made with real sugar. Get my caffeine boost too.

It is clear that Zero Calorie is different from, and in my opinion inferior to, its predecessor, A&W Diet Root Beer. The new version is not bad, and I will drink it; but over time I expect the amount I buy and drink to diminish because it is not as good.

The biggest difference is in the finish, though the boldness of the overall taste and the carbonation and sweetness levels also seem to have been tweaked. The pleasant vanilla finish is gone, replaced by one that is metallic and has a touch of toothpaste-like faux mint.

I doubt that it is a coincidence that the new packaging does not state “made with aged vanilla,” as the Diet Root Beer cans, bottles and cartons proudly proclaimed. I know there are apologists/publicists claiming that this is just a rebranding and the “formula” is unchanged.

That strikes me as disingenuous. While the ingredients list has not changed, when comparing the two versions side by side it is obvious that there has been a change within one all-important listed ingredient: the “natural and artificial flavors.

” I hope the owners of the A&W brand will see fit to either change it back or to reintroduce the original Diet version as an alternative.

I now live in OKC. Since I cannot find it here, I have to drive to Texas to get it. 3 hours 1 way just for THIS Dr Pepper. Definitely. Last time I stocked up, I bought the store out. All 10 12-packs.

Thank goodness I did! I can no longer find it in Texas either! So disappointing. There is nothing better than THIS Dr Pepper. It tastes more like the DP from my childhood. I have introduced this to many people.

I actually SHARED my stash! Oh how sad I am. CORN SYRUP MIGHT BE CHEAPER FOR PRODUCTION, BUT IT IS NO SUBSTITUTE FOR REAL SUGAR! The flavor is completely different. (lecture about corn syrup withheld here) No, I will NOT buy 12-pack(s) of regular DP after tasting this one.

I guess I will just have to find something else to drink.

My two dogs absolutely LOVE this ice cream! They have tried the blueberry and pumpkin flavors so far and they beg for more. The quality is excellent and human grade and has nothing bad in it. This is a great and fun option for your fur baby to have ice cream with you as a treat.

I highly recommend this for your doggies.

Great for warmer days my dogs loves ice creams. Trying out new flavors this summer I’m sure they will like them all.

8/15/22 – The Good. The Bad. THE UGLY. ❗. I foolishly ordered 2 of these today on Amazon Fresh. My favorite GO TO (SO Delicious) was unavailable, so I thought I would try Breyers. I was hoping that some of the negative reviews were exaggerations.

First. THE GOOD: This Breyers Chocolate Truffle ice cream is creamy and delicious. There are enough truffle pieces that a person would have a piece of truffle in every spoonful of ice crram. Well done.

Second. THE BAD: The truffle pieces. Oh my stars. Those other reviewers were NOT exaggerating. The truffles in this ice cream ruin the whole batch. Breyers, who is your taster and where did you source these truffles? The taster must be a smoker because anyone who says these chocolate truffle pieces are delicious dark chocolate is SERIOUSLY DELUDED!!! To me, they taste the way cheap paper towels smell.

THEY ARE ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE!!!. The. UGLY: Breyers I am surprised that, after all the negative reviews you have had on this product since it was introduced, you would not have learned something and made an effort to improve this product.

Is money your only motive for making this? Because it sure isn’t for the consumer. :-((. It would be in your best interest, and improve your reputation for delectable dessert creations, if you selected another supplier for your truffle pieces.

I suggest you find a chocolate supplier who actually makes REAL Dark Chocolate. Consider checking out “Buchard Belgium Dark Chocolate” or a similar chocolatier for your ingredient. Those little chocolate bars (70% Cacao) chopped up into tiny pieces, then added to your ice cream, would definitely increase sales of this item and put a lot of smiles on the faces of ALL chocolate lovers.

You could learn a great deal about how your ice cream SHOULD taste by sampling “SO Delicious Dairy Free Dark Chocolate Truffle Cashewmilk Frozen Dessert”. NOW THAT IS A GREAT TASTING DESSERT!! There is no bad aftertaste, it’s creamy and FULL of dark chocolate flavor and it tastes like Nirvana!.

You don’t have to be a copycat, but it would be nice if you could strive for that kind of frozen dessert experience. If it costs a little more to source a better chocolatier, then so be it. I’m sure consumers would not mind paying an additional $1 for a great tasting ice cream.

It might be helpful to put together a “Chocolate Lovers Focus Group” and have them participate in a blind taste test of different ice creams in the dark chocolate category inclusive of dark chocolate pieces as part of the recipe.

They don’t have to know the brand, but it would be helpful if they could state whether they like the desert or don’t like it and why. Comments could also include thoughts on the texture and what specific details affected their rating of that particular product.

All this information would help Breyers develop a better tasting dark chocolate ice cream recipe. As for me, I am sorry to say, but Breyers will be permanently OFF THE TABLE for my future shopping trips.

:-((. I wish I could get a refund of this purchase ($5. 99 x 2). ONE MORE SUGGESTION. TRANSPARENCY. INCLUDE INGREDIENTS ON YOUR WEBSITES FOR THESE PRODUCTS. I HAD TO DO A LOT OF SEARCHING ONLINE TO FIND IT.

MAKES ME THINK YOU HAVE SOMETHING TO HIDE. :-((. SAD. Good Luck guys!!!.

To be fair, i dont purchase a lot of ice cream, maybe a quart a month. As you get older you (try) to consume less sugar. So i am unlikely to be your target customer. I want to believe that the loss of chocolatey covered almonds is due to customers complaints.

I can understand how food preferences change over time and Breyers is simply adjusting with the times. However, the original/classic formula appeals to folks who were kids the first time they had RR ice cream.

Based on Breyers market penetration in the 80s and 90s i would argue, statistically, a kids first RR experience was probably Breyers original recipe/formula. By changing the formula Breyers is denying the nostalgic affinity for a really great ice cream.

The new flavor isn’t bad, but it definitely does not remind anyone of childhood or bygone days of eating chocolatey covered almonds. Unfortunately, my kids will also be denied the opportunity to taste the original product and they wont have the fond memories i do, nor the slightly negative opinion of the brand generally, for taking away my favorite and replacing it “with more almonds”.

As stated earlier, i get the need to move more product and adapt to changing consumer preferences. I just hope that the decision was not based on the cost of covering almond bits in “chocolatey” goodness, because I, like my cohort, am not a kid anymore.

We can afford a little extra to experience fond memories and everyone likes to create those for their kids. Strangely, i have never met a kid who preferred “more almonds” to “chocolatey covered” ones.

We usually stick with the old favorites; Natural Vanilla, Strawberry, or Chocolate Ice Cream, but a dinner guest suggested we serve Butter Pecan. Even though we had only eaten that flavor on infrequent occasions over the past several decades we had fond memories of the rich buttery flavor and tasty pecans so we readily agreed it was a good suggestion.

After everyone was finished with the Breyers Butter Pecan dessert, I mustered the courage to ask our guests “did you think that ice cream tasted good?”. We quickly realized that we all agreed the product was essentially flavorless, lacking in a creamy sensation, and the pecans were remarkably rotten.

The conversation led me to this site to see what other people thought. Another reviewer at this site described the pecans as tasting rancid, which stuck in my head because more than a few of the examples that I had just eaten left me with the same distasteful impression.

This incident led me to learn about the path Breyers has taken in converting some of its iconic flavors from true “Ice Cream” to “Frozen Desserts”. All I can say is why bother putting the Breyers name on this stuff.

Thank you for the opportunity to provide feedback.

I think Black Raspberry is good. My memory of eating it isn’t as strong as the other flavors. I think part of why is that there’s not much that makes black raspberry flavors really stand out apart from each other in my opinion.

They’re a lot alike to me between brands. I like this more than the Cherry Chip, and I’d always want some of this int he freezer. But I could see the day when something better comes out and I replace my consumption of this with something else.

But that something else isn’t there, and who knows if it ever will be. But, well, I guess it comes down to this. When I think of a delicious berry based ice cream my mind says ‘ya lets mix in some raspberries, then have chunks of blackberry, and lets top it all with some blueberry sauce.

And as anyone on keto knows if you do this your net carbs is going to be high. So I should say this; this is a keto ice cream that likely can’t become what I ‘really want to enjoy’, but it is nevertheless Quite Enjoyable, and I intend to enjoy it many more times in the future.

Loved this flavor, tastes legit like birthday cake! One of the best flavors and brands I’ve tried – I really enjoyed the texture too – which is hard to find when eating keto ice creams! Thanks for an amazing flavor!.

Really loved the half of it I did get to try. I purchased one for me and one for my husband. Guess who enjoyed theirs and then some. Will definitely purchase again. Will just have to hide it from my husband.

Oh yes, I do love their butter pecan. I love the soft crunch of the nuts. Edy’s is one of the best ice cream I have eaten. I love the smooth creaminess of this ice cream. It is delicious. You can’t go wrong with any of its flavors.

If you want a good tasting ice cream let me suggest Edy’s.

Butter pecan ice cream is mine and my husbands absolute favorite ice cream of all time this is our go to ice cream all the time either this or vanilla and I would prefer this!!! The taste is just fabulous and I can actually taste it as I’m telling you how wonderful it is!!! That opinion will never change and I will continue to get butter pecan forever and always.

Yummy and taste so good, sugarry taste with pecan, thats the only thing i eat pecan on an ice cream, good value not so pricey

I think this product is very good because it has yougurt. I like its flavor. This product is delicious and creamy. I don’t know how to improve this product. This product has milk, yogurt, sugar, salt.

I would recommend to others.

This ice cream is super creamy. They have unique flavors that I can’t get with other brands. I would only improve the packaging make it available in smaller packages. I definitely recommend or bring this to parties.

Blue bunny frozen yogurt is really good! The vanilla has a real vanilla flavor, nice creamy, smooth texture and perfect amount of Sweetness! The container is a bit bulky, but I’ve definitely managed to get it in my freezer! I’ve always loved the blue bunny brand because all their ice creams and yogurts taste great and are worth the price! Quality of this brand leaves all the other competition tasting quite bland and boring! I would definitely recommend blue bunny yogurt to all my friends and family!.

Wasnt quite sure what to expect when I saw sugar free. It really tastes good and like Butter Pecan ice cream. I would definitely buy again even though Butter Pecan is not my number one choice of flavors.

Cant wait to try the Strawberry and the Chocolate flavors.

I am reviewing Rebel peanut butter caramel chip. The peanut butter flavor is very nice and reminds me of a reese cup. The caramel swirl is my favorite but there is barely any in the pint. My least favorite is the chocolate chips which is shocking because I love chocolate chips in ice cream.

These are very bitter and leave an unpleasant aftertaste. I won’t be trying this flavor again. Also I had read reviews about Rebel ice cream and some people are a bit confused as to what the carb count means.

This is a very tiny container, it says on the front in big bold letters that there are 7g carbs in this container. Except they have that listed as per serving. Serving size for the tiny container has 3 servings.

So it is actually 21g of carbs per container. Not to mention that $6 for a little mini container is ridiculously expensive. To add on to my review, I did not mean to rate this at 4 stars. It’s more of a 3 star ice cream.

Since the new influenster app update you can no longer change your rating later. #rebelicecream #ketolife #influenster #voxbox.

Sadly I was disappointed in this ice cream. The best part of cookie dough ice cream should be the cookie dough. The cookie dough in this ice cream doesn’t have any of the flavor that you would expect.

Worse than the lack of flavor is the weird texture. It honestly tastes like you have eaten a ball of protein powder. It has an odd aftertaste and it just disintegrates in your mouth to a sandy, powdery form.

I am giving this two stars because the base of the ice cream and the chocolate chips are good. I will pick all of the cookie dough out and try and at least salvage that. $5 for a tiny pint of keto ice cream is ridiculously expensive.

I don’t feel like I can throw it all out. This is not a flavor that I will ever get again. I recommend Rebel Hill salted caramel or peanut butter caramel chip ice cream.

I was so excited to try this. I went to 2 stores and drove about 15 miles to get this flavor of the plant based non dairy dessert. It was pretty much just peanut butter flavored. No chunks of brownie and no salty pretzel swirl.

There was a small round area in the center that was chocolate but thats all. I was hoping for something closer to the description – which sounded so good, and the photo – which looked great. Neither of which were like the actual pint was that I bought.

I wouldn’t buy this flavor again. But I would try something else.

I follow a 90 per cent vegan diet, but after discovering BJ Netflix n Chilld it became my biggest sin, i would eat one tub every night in the start. Do you know how excited I was when they introduced the vegan version! I thought now I could eat my favorite flavor with good conscience and also not fart the entire night! But this version is kind of bland, it completely misses the salty flavor, as well as the texture of the peanut butter swirls! I tasted them side by side, since my room mate had the original version.

I will try it again at some point in hopes that the recipe will be improved, but for now I will be going back to the dairy-based original. Netflix and Chill’d is an incredible invention, it even convinced my ice-cream hating mom, and I wish the Vegan version would offer me the same experience.

Sadly it’s really not comparable and should not have the same name.

When I discovered this ben and jerry ice cream about 6 months ago I fell in love! I had never in my life tasted such a delicious ice cream. I am not the biggest ice cream fan as I prefer frozen yogurt all the way but Netflix and chilld stole my heart 3 I am a sucker for salty and sweet combos.

The peanut butter ice cream is subtle with big chewy chunks of brownie and globs of soft salted pretzel is the perfect combo of ice cream. I eat half a pint almost everyday.

The black walnut taffy was a gift for my wife because she is a huge black walnut fan and I found it difficult to find vendors who make or sell it. While she was pleased to receive it, she was disappointed that it was mixed with chocolate taffy rather than vanilla taffy.

In our opinion, the chocolate masked the flavor of the black walnut, putting too much emphasis on the chocolate. The taffy itself was very good and we do hope to try other flavors in the future. R. Miller.

I was nostalgic for one of my favorite Halloween treats, the peanut butter kisses. However, they hardly make them any more, what a shame. These are pretty good and I have my secret stash hidden, lol.

Good product. Does what it is intended for. There’s allot out there just like it. No complaints. Recommend to everyone.

The triple chocolate ice cream should come with a warning attached! Ohh boy! If you love chocolate this might be a problem for you! Yum!

I really like this ice cream! It doesn’t taste odd due to the maltitol or sucralose but it does have a warning about a possible laxative effect. For 2/3 cup, there are only 13 net carbs which is great for me being a diabetic because I need a sweet cold treat now and again, I can’t wait to find more flavors to try!.

I am finishing my first year of serious low-carb lifestyle. During that time it was a challenge to find ice cream that was not very expensive while also meeting the low-carb criteria. And if you did find it, the taste may not be as sensational.

Having said that, I was delighted to find this offering from Bryers. Be mindful that when watching your blood sugar levels, sugar alcohol does not interact negatively in that department. When you take out the sugar alcohol count, as well as the fiber, then you’re down to a delicious low-carb option.

Enjoy!.

I don’t think I’ve ever written a review for anything, but I am over-the-moon for this ice cream. I’m so used to really bland frozen yogurt with a bad aftertaste when I want a low-calorie frozen treat (gotta maintain that svelte physique).

I saw this at the store and was like, “That will easily fit my macros. ” I expected it to be just as bad as the stuff I’ve tried before, but I was so surprised. It was soft and super easy to scoop. It isn’t overly sweet and you don’t taste the sweetener, but it still has this classic wonderful vanilla flavor and it’s CREAMY.

I think that’s the best part. The texture is spot-on. Maintaining a low-calorie diet is important to me, but being able to have treats with my family is also important. I can do both!!!! THANK YOU!!!!.

For a low sugar low carb product, this is good quality. It doesn’t taste as bad as some carb friendly foods. If you are choosing this to be healthier, I recommend it. OTOH The flavor is very mild. It doesn’t taste very strongly of vanilla.

Though to be fair, neither does their homemade vanilla. If you want the best flavor, get the natural vanilla. If you want the creamiest, get homemade. If you have to watch your sugar intake, this is not a bad replacement.

My favorite flavor is FRENCH SILK! And I love the fact that it come in NO SUGAR ADDED and 1/2 the fat. I really try to watch how much fat and sugar that I eat. But I just have to have a little Ice Cream sometimes! And DREYER’S SLOW CHURNED NO SUGAR ADDED is my choice every time!!!!!.

LOVE LOVE LOVE this ice cream. Does not leave me with an upset tummy and the low sugar is such a great plus for me. I really enjoy ice cream and not I feel I can eat it without the guilt. Very creamy! Yummo.

A great alternative to regular ice cream. The kids even love it. Refreshing, full flavor. Tastes divine with fresh fruit. It’s a must try.

I’m seeing so many reviews for this where people are asking what happened to the graham cracker swirls and to a lesser extent the strawberries and I absolutely couldn’t agree more. I’m so happy to see that others have also noticed this disturbing trend.

To me, there used to be nothing better than the graham cracker swirl, and a long time ago my gf and I used to have fun at the store each picking one out randomly and seeing who’s had the most delicious swirl in it.

Some always had more than others this is true but you always got at least a decent amount, if not a decadent amount. But nowadays, it’s like a sad joke. What happened to it? Clearly based on others reviews and my own observations they’ve for whatever reason stopped putting anything other than a small spattering here and there and one has to wonder why? Is it a cost saving measure? People who buy BnJ’s generally understand they are spending more on ice cream in exchange for better quality.

They sure haven’t passed these savings along to us consumers. Is this happening company wide with all their products? One would have to assume so. To anyone out there who is just now trying this for the 1st time, you’re actually lucky, because you don’t know what you’re missing.

I’ll speak for the rest of us when I say Hey BnJ’s, all your funny jokes and your oh-so-hip attitude isn’t covering up the fact that somewhere along the line you made a conscious decision to put profits over quality at the expense of loyal customers.

How about you stop screwing around and acting like an ice cream company should change the world and just put more darn swirl in your strawberry cheesecake ice cream. I mean really, grow up and realize that once enough people start to realize how far you’ve strayed from delivering a quality ice cream consistently, they’ll truly understand that all the rest of your “message”or whatever is also not important to you, and then they’ll stop laughing with you and start laughing at you.

Your welcome btw for the ethics lesson.

Phish Food, a chocolate flavored ice cream from the well-known brand Ben & Jerry’s, has been in production since March 18th, 1997. In just over a month, this flavor will celebrate its 25th anniversary– but is it worthy of such a long run? Perhaps the flavor has been kept in production for so long due to its sentimental origin.

The creatives behind the brand were born in Vermont, as was one of their favorite bands, Phish. They debuted Phish Food in collaboration with the rock band at a concert in their hometown Burlington. Ben & Jerry’s have detailed on their website that they and the band were united by a “real spiritual connection” and that show marked the birth of one of their most popular flavors.

So perhaps the hype is all simply due to the flavor being around so long that for most it is just a recognized household name. Furthermore, maybe it’s only been kept around so long due to the nostalgia of its creators.

The ice cream itself is a bold combination of classic chocolate ice cream, a healthy dollop of marshmallow and caramel swirls, and splash of fish shaped chocolate chunks swimming in the mix. The chocolate flavor is a well honed recipe.

Used as the base of many of their iconic flavors, there is little doubt in my mind that they have this part down. The impressive part is how the flavor is able to maintain gooey and smooth marshmallow and caramel swirls throughout the pint.

In all too many ice cream brands, freezer burn infects the molecular structure of soft substances like marshmallow or caramel. Such swirls become hardened and would just as soon break your spoon as it would your teeth.

Phish Food has the most airy and light marshmallow flavor, and decadently smooth caramel flavor, of any ice cream brand on the store shelves that I’ve tasted. I cannot forget the most pleasant part of this creation though, the fish shaped chocolate chunks.

Through my personal research (in which I felt much enjoyment) I found that the chocolate fishes were no marketing scam. They are not only fish shaped but also have a clear imprint of an eye, fins, and gills.

This would definitely be a death row meal; such a delight to eat! I cannot in good faith sing only praise to this product. There have been many times I have been betrayed by a pint of Phish Food. I have gone to scoop a small portion for myself only to find no marshmallow or caramel swirls in my bowl.

This isn’t to say that there is a lack of the flavorings, only that they tend to be in the lower 2/3rds of the pint. I would not be opposed to a more generous amount of chocolate fish either… My greatest qualm of all being, it is always out of stock at my local Rite Aid and Safeway.

All in all, I think this flavor has been around and popular for so long because it is a good product. I can make mint chip ice cream on my own and it often tastes the same to most store bought counterparts.

I cannot make something as good as Phish Food, believe me I have tried. For this reason, I believe it is worth the reasonable 5$ I pay to enjoy it. (5 stars).

WHAT HAPPENED! This tastes DISGUSTING and like gross overpowering YOGURT. I kept checking to make sure I didn’t get some weird frozen yogurt kind (which I’ve had in the past and liked actually) but this new “flavor” is just AWFUL.

No cherry juice in the ingredients now either. Jerry Garcia himself approved the original kind which was so cool and he would be SO MAD at this new version that he’d demand his name be taken off. It’s tangy AND NOT IN A GOOD WAY.

I couldn’t even eat it and this used to be my favorite kind! I even tried drowning it in Hershey’s chocolate syrup to make it edible and I couldn’t eat even the chips and cherries out of it without the nasty yogurty taste.

The ice cream bar version of this is still okay- WHY IS THE REGULAR ICE CREAM FORMULA DIFFERENT!? Everyone who used to love this would GLADY pay $1, $3, etc. more for the original kind that was good.

These changes you keep doing are noticeable and terrible, one version had like three chocolate chips per container, another version had just three cherries, another version had cheap red cherries lol BUT THOSE ARE ALL PREFERABLE TO THIS NASTINESS, GROSS.

I’m so mad they changed my favorite one that I’m going to boycott and so is everyone else. Jerry Garcia is turning over in his grave. I recommend Private Selection Amaretto Cherry Cordial as a replacement.

It’s usually half the price for 4x as much and it’s better chocolate chips and I like those kind of cherries just fine and it’s a better flavor anyway. I liked that BJ was sourced responsibly with good products but it’s not that way anymore and it’s just cut corner after cut corner and I’m done spending money over and over on their new versions of what used to be great flavors.

I’ve wasted my money for the last time. I had been buying this for decades and so had my mother and grandmother. P. S. Stop putting pea protein in the non-dairy stuff- it tastes nasty! Do you guys not even try the product!? Mauna Loa is the only brand non doing the gross pea protein thing and they’re going to get my $7-$8 per pint I normally would spend on BJ EVERY.

TIME.

Sadly I can’t have almonds, dairy, or soy so most ice creams including Ben n Jerry’s aren’t possible for me. Coconut based ice creams are typically the only ones I can have but coconut is overpowering so I usually avoid ice cream unless it’s the jeni’s Texas sheet cake.

Unfortunately I don’t always have access to it. Ben n Jerry’s first released the change the whirled flavor with sunflower instead of almond and I love it. Always have some in stock. It made me wish they’d switch their recipes over from almond to sunflower for all their dairy free ice creams.

But now they’ve released this sunflower one which is really similar to the change the whirled except for there’s actual cookie chunks in this one not just a cookie swirl. Tbh I love both. I rotate out between this milk n cookies one, the change the whirled one, and jenis texas sheet cake.

If you like any of the other two, you’ll like this one.

Over the past few months I’ve become more and more intolerant to lactose. I always loved ice cream before but found it hard to to deal with, even with using lactaid. My roommate who has lactose sensitivities told me a while ago that Ben & Jerry’s has really good dairy free ice cream so I decided to try it.

She didn’t tell me what flavors she liked but I grabbed this one since it sounded good. And I was very correct! I’ll admit, the chocolate chip cookie bites weren’t exactly my favorite, but I still found the entire ice cream to be very good and very comparable to the standard dairy ice cream.

It’s so good I had to check again that there was no milk or cream in it. The consistency is the exact same. If somebody gave it to me and told me it had dairy, I would definitely believe them.

Until I tried this flavor, I hadn’t found a flavor I didn’t like. I won’t be buying this one again. For some reason it has an overwhelming coconut flavor. I deeply dislike coconut based ice creams. I’ve always gone for soy or cashew based.

So I was very disappointed to find a Ben & Jerry’s flavor that I REALLY didn’t like. My spouse is finishing it, I would have dumped it straight in the trash. The two stars are in appreciation for trying to create good vegan flavors, although this one is a fail.

I live this ice cream! It’s absolutely delicious. Just the right combination of creamy ice cream with nice large cookie chunks. One of my favorite ice cream flavors, and this brand does it well. Highly recommend!.

Hoenstly this ice cream is so smooth and delicious. You could not find a better brand of cookies an dream ice cream. Not even from an ice cream parlor. It’s always perfect after a long day, just a nice bowl of this makes you feel so much better.