Seasoning for mahi mahi can include any number of herbs and spices, depending on the desired flavor profile. Common seasonings for mahi mahi include salt, pepper, garlic, onion, and lemon. For a more bold flavor, mahi mahi can also be seasoned with cumin, chili powder, or paprika.
20 Best Seasoning For Mahi Mahi
Product Image | Product Name | Features | Price |
---|---|---|---|
Zatarain's Blackened Fish Seasoning – Shaker, 3 oz (Pack – 4) |
|
||
Chef Paul Prudhommes Magic Seasoning Blends, Seafood Magic – 2 oz |
|
||
Badia Sazon Tropical, Meats – 1.75 lbs (793.8 g) |
|
||
Chef Paul Prudhommes Seasoning Blends, Blackened Redfish Magic – 2 oz |
|
||
Auntie Nono's Seafood Seasoning |
|
||
Old Bay Seasoning – 6 oz |
|
||
Mccormick Golden Dipt Seafood Batter Mix, Tempura – 8 oz |
|
||
Olde Thompson Seasoning, Fish & Seafood – 5.5 oz |
|
||
Johnnys Lemon Dill Seasoning – 4.75 oz |
|
||
Johnny's Lemon Dill (Original Seafood Seasoning) 4.75oz Bottle |
|
||
Dash Seasoning Blend, Fiesta Lime – 2.4 oz |
|
||
Primal Palate Organic Spices Seafood Seasoning 2.1 oz |
|
||
Simply Organic Seasoning Mix, Fish Taco – 1.13 oz |
|
||
Noh Foods Of Hawaii Seasoning Mix, Chinese Barbeque Char Siu – 2.5 oz |
|
||
Schwartz Fish Seasoning Jar Delivered to USA |
|
||
Good & Gather Skinless, Boneless Wild Caught Mahi Mahi Fillets |
|
||
Cabela's Open Season Spice Blends Maple Jalapeno Seasoning |
|
- New Orleans classic Blackened Seasoning
- Unique blend of spices like red pepper, paprika and garlic
- Perfect to jazz up pork, chicken, fish or steak
- Easy to use in gumbos, soups, sauces & dressing.
- Substitute for normal use of salt, pepper and other herbs & spices called for in a recipe.
- Product of USA
- No Preservatives
- Gluten Free
- Crabs, Shrimp, Chicken
- Same Great Taste for over 70 Years
- Kosher
- GOLDEN DIPT, Breading, Tempura Mix
- A unique blend of high quality flour and spices
- Fries to a crispy golden brown. Use 1/2 tsp in roasted vegetables, pasta sauce or poultry stuffing
- Disposable
- Medium Coarse Grind
- Sealed for Freshness
- Update: Johnny’s Fine Foods recently changed the label and name to SEAFOOD SEASONING Lemon Dill..
- Gluten Free.
- Use as Dill Sauce with sour cream or yogurt.
- Contains: Does Not Contain Any of the 8 Major Allergens
- State of Readiness: Ingredient
- Form: Ground
- Certified USDA-organic, Certified gluten-free, Certified Kosher
- Non-GMO, Non-irradiated, no preservatives, no MSG, no fillers
- Delicious organic fish tacos.
- Includes three, 1.13 ounce packets.
- Made in Hawaii
- Just add water
- Authentic Chinese marinate for pork or chicken
- Dried Onion, Sea Salt, Sugar, Maltodextrin, Flavouring (contains Barley, Wheat), Parsley (6%), Dried Lemon Peel (5%), Dried Orange Peel, Acid (Citric
- Contains: Mahi Mahi
- State of Readiness: Needs to Be Fully Cooked
- Form: Filleted
1. Zatarain’s Blackened Fish Seasoning – Shaker, 3 oz (Pack – 4)
- New Orleans classic Blackened Seasoning
- Unique blend of spices like red pepper, paprika and garlic
- Perfect to jazz up pork, chicken, fish or steak
- Use just 1/4 teaspoon per serving to create bold blackened flavor
- For best results, cook meat in the broiler or on the grill
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com – Seller | |
Walmart – Cajun Supermarket | |
ibspot.com | |
homeemo |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer | No |
Product Dimensions | 9 x 3 x 9 inches; 0.8 Ounces |
2. Chef Paul Prudhommes Magic Seasoning Blends, Seafood Magic – 2 oz
- Easy to use in gumbos, soups, sauces & dressing.
- Substitute for normal use of salt, pepper and other herbs & spices called for in a recipe.
- Magic Seasonings are versatile in their application and pack incredible depth of flavor.
- All natural, contains no MSG or preservatives and is Kosher approved.
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com – Seller | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
Supermarketitaly.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 0.7g |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 81 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
3. Badia Sazon Tropical, Meats – 1.75 lbs (793.8 g)
- 28 oz
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com – Seller | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
eBluejay online marketplace – allseasoning’s store |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 1.25g |
Food Servings Per Container | 635.0 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
4. Chef Paul Prudhommes Seasoning Blends, Blackened Redfish Magic – 2 oz
- Product of USA
- No Preservatives
- Gluten Free
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com – Seller | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
Vitacost.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 0.7g |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 81 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
5. Auntie Nono’s Seafood Seasoning
- All Natural
- Gluten-Free
- Vegetarian- and vegan-friendly
- Great for the Paleo diet
- Made in America
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com – Seller |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
for | 1 |
item(s) | edit |
Package Dimensions | 5.2 x 2.09 x 2.05 inches; 6.74 Ounces |
Country of Origin | USA |
Reviews From Real Customers
6. Old Bay Seasoning – 6 oz
- Crabs, Shrimp, Chicken
- Same Great Taste for over 70 Years
- Kosher
- Made with Natural Flavors, No MSG
- Pour marinade over chicken, pork, ribs and seafood and let sit for 30 minutes for delicious flavor
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
Target |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 0.6g |
Food Servings Per Container | about 283 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
7. Andy’s Seasoning Golden Fish Batter 5
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Rural King |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 9g |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 252 |
Allergens | CONTAINS: WHEAT. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
8. Mccormick Golden Dipt Seafood Batter Mix, Tempura – 8 oz
- GOLDEN DIPT, Breading, Tempura Mix
- A unique blend of high quality flour and spices
- Fries to a crispy golden brown. Use 1/2 tsp in roasted vegetables, pasta sauce or poultry stuffing
- Certified Kosher pareve by the Orthodox Union
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
SoupsOnline.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | MIX |
Food Serving Size Measure | 28g |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 8 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Salt Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
9. Olde Thompson Seasoning, Fish & Seafood – 5.5 oz
- Disposable
- Medium Coarse Grind
- Sealed for Freshness
- Filled in USA in FDA registered food processing facility
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Function Junction | |
DK Hardware |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Units in Package | 1 |
Unit Size | 5.5 oz |
Directions | Remove cap. Turn mill upside down and turn clear base clockwise. To Adjust Grind: Turn white grinding mechanism clockwise for finer grind and counter clockwise for a coarser grind. |
Ingredients | Sea Salt, Spices (Chili Pepper, Celery, Red Pepper, Black Pepper, White Pepper, Bay, Thyme, Oregano, Basil), Dehydrated Garlic and Onion, Paprika, and Calcium Silicate Added to Prevent Caking. |
Serving Size | 0.25 tsp |
Reviews From Real Customers
10. Johnnys Lemon Dill Seasoning – 4.75 oz
- Update: Johnny’s Fine Foods recently changed the label and name to SEAFOOD SEASONING Lemon Dill..
- Gluten Free.
- Use as Dill Sauce with sour cream or yogurt.
- Great on seafood or any fish.
- Add to soups, chowders and melted butter for a Dill Butter Sauce to dip crab or prawns.
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Walmart – Sportco Warehouse Sporting Goods | |
Fred Meyer |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 1g |
Food Servings Per Container | 135 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
11. Johnny’s Lemon Dill (Original Seafood Seasoning) 4.75oz Bottle
- Pack Of 1
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Grocery.com Store |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Dimensions | 4.5x2x3 inches |
12. Dash Seasoning Blend, Fiesta Lime – 2.4 oz
- Contains: Does Not Contain Any of the 8 Major Allergens
- State of Readiness: Ingredient
- Form: Ground
- Package Quantity: 1
- Pre-package preparation: Dried
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
ShopFoodEx.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | ABOUT |
Food Serving Size Measure | 0.7g |
Food Servings Per Container | 97.0 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Salt Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
13. Primal Palate Organic Spices Seafood Seasoning 2.1 oz
- Certified USDA-organic, Certified gluten-free, Certified Kosher
- Non-GMO, Non-irradiated, no preservatives, no MSG, no fillers
- Paleo friendly, Whole30 Approved
- Always fresh – made in small batches
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Thrive Market | |
Primal Palate | |
Grocery.com Store |
Product Details
Reviews From Real Customers
14. Simply Organic Seasoning Mix, Fish Taco – 1.13 oz
- Delicious organic fish tacos.
- Includes three, 1.13 ounce packets.
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay – foodeconcepts | |
Fred Meyer | |
SoupsOnline.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | PER CONTAINER |
Food Serving Size Measure | 8g |
Food Servings Per Container | 4.0 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
15. Noh Foods Of Hawaii Seasoning Mix, Chinese Barbeque Char Siu – 2.5 oz
- Made in Hawaii
- Just add water
- Authentic Chinese marinate for pork or chicken
- 2 calories from fat; No MSG
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
NOH Foods of Hawaii |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | 1 SERVING, MIX |
Food Serving Size Measure | 12g |
Food Servings Per Container | 6 |
Allergens | CONTAINS: WHEAT AND SOY. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
16. Schwartz Fish Seasoning Jar Delivered to USA
- Dried Onion, Sea Salt, Sugar, Maltodextrin, Flavouring (contains Barley, Wheat), Parsley (6%), Dried Lemon Peel (5%), Dried Orange Peel, Acid (Citric
- Acid), Dill Seed, Dried Lemon Juice Concentrate (2%), Black Pepper, Dill (2%), Sunflower Oil, AntiCaking Agent (Silicon Dioxide) Contains Barley
- Contains Wheat Suitable for Vegetarians
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Britishonlinesupermarket.com | |
BritishCornerShop.co.uk |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Allergy Advice | Contains Barley. Contains Wheat |
Environment | Store in a cool. dry place out of direct sunlight. |
Storage Type | Ambient |
17. Sam’s Choice Frozen Wild Caught Mahi-mahi Fillets, 12 oz
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Walmart |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | ABOUT 2-3 FILLETS |
Food Serving Size Measure | 113g |
Food Servings Per Container | 3 |
Allergens | CONTAINS FISH (MAHI-MAHI). MAY CONTAIN TRACES OF CRUSTACEAN SHELLFISH (CRAB, LOBSTER, AND SHRIMP). |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Salt Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
18. Good & Gather Skinless, Boneless Wild Caught Mahi Mahi Fillets
- Contains: Mahi Mahi
- State of Readiness: Needs to Be Fully Cooked
- Form: Filleted
- Dietary Needs: Non-GMO Project Verified
- Package Quantity: 1
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Target |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | about 1 fillet |
Food Serving Size Measure | 113g |
Food Servings Per Container | About 4 |
Allergens | CONTAINS MAHI MAHI PROCESSED IN A FACILITY THAT ALSO HANDLES OTHER FISH INGREDIENTS MAY CONTAIN BONES |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Salt Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
19. Cabela’s Open Season Spice Blends Maple Jalapeno Seasoning
- Maple Jalapeno
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Cabela’s | |
Bass Pro Shops |
Product Details
20. Member’s Mark Wild Caught Mahi Mahi – 32 oz
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Sam’s Club |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Description | RAW (ABOUT 4″ BY 2″ PIECE) |
Food Serving Size Measure | 113g |
Food Servings Per Container | 8 |
Allergens | CONTAINS: MAHI-MAHI. MAY CONTAIN BONES. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Salt Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
Conclusion
After trying a few different methods, we’ve found that the best way to season mahi mahi is to use a simple rub of olive oil, salt, and pepper. This allows the natural flavor of the fish to shine through, while the salt and pepper add a bit of zest.
Another method that we’ve found to be successful is to marinate the mahi mahi in a mixture of lime juice, garlic, and cilantro for about 30 minutes before cooking. This gives the fish a bright, fresh flavor that is perfect for summertime grilling.
Whichever method you choose, be sure to cook the mahi mahi over medium-high heat so that it remains moist and flakey. Mahi mahi is best served with a light, citrusy dressing or salsa. Enjoy!