Sauces for mahi mahi can include a variety of things, depending on what you are looking for. A simple sauce could be made with lemon juice, butter, and garlic. A more complex sauce could include ingredients such as diced tomatoes, onion, white wine, and herbs.
Ultimately, it depends on your personal preference as to what goes into your sauce. The important thing is that the sauce compliments the fish, rather than overpowering it.
20 Best Sauces For Mahi Mahi
Product Image | Product Name | Features | Price |
---|---|---|---|
Red Boat Fish Sauce – 8.45 fl oz bottle |
|
||
Maya Kaimal Indian Simmer Sauce, Kashmiri Curry, Mild – 12.5 oz |
|
||
Louisiana Remoulade Sauce – 10.5 oz |
|
||
Rao's Homemade Marinara – 24 oz |
|
||
Mr. Yoshida's Marinade & Cooking Sauce, Sweet Teriyaki, Original Gourmet – 17 fl oz |
|
||
Mccormick Cocktail Sauce, Extra Hot – 8 fl oz |
|
||
San-J Stir-Fry & Marinade, Gluten Free, Teriyaki – 10 fl oz |
|
||
Dawson's Shawarma Sauce |
|
||
Soy Vay Marinade & Sauce, Less Sodium, Veri Veri Teriyaki – 21 oz |
|
||
World Harbors Sauce & Marinade, Teriyaki, Maui Mountain – 16 fl oz |
|
||
Mezzetta Sauce, Marinara – 24.5 oz |
|
||
Mr. Yoshida's Original Gourmet Sauce 1 Pack (86 Ounce) |
|
||
Daddies Brown Sauce 14.11 Ounce |
|
||
Frontera Enchilada Sauce, Green Chile, Medium – 8 oz |
|
||
A.1. Sauce, Original – 2 pack, 15 oz bottles |
|
||
Peach BBQ Sauce, 12 oz. |
|
||
Thai Kitchen Fish Sauce, Premium – 6.76 fl oz |
|
||
Alpha Chef Sauce Fish Recipe Dog & Cat Food Topper, 8-oz Bottle |
|
||
Caribbean Jerk Sauce, Island Spices and Peppers – 12 oz |
|
- Made from wild-caught black anchovy and sea salt
- Barrel-aged using a centuries-old fermentation tradition
- Premium fish sauce is a secret ingredient used by professional chefs and home cooks around the world
- Rich tomato with nutmeg
- All Natural,No Preservatives
- Gluten Free,No Starch Thickeners
- Six jars of 24oz pasta sauce (144 oz total)
- Famous homemade recipe from New York restaurant
- Made from all natural ingredients
- Soy sauce based sauce
- Yoshida’s mirin added to enhance the flavors
- Great for beef, pork, chicken, fish or vegetables
- Product Dimensions : 2.47 x 2.47 x 5.11 inches; 15.89 Ounces.
- UPC : .
- Extra hot cocktail dipping sauce made with real horseradish and hint of lemon.
- A perfect sweet & savory blend with ginger, garlic and San-J’s popular, umami-rich Tamari Soy Sauce.
- Certified gluten free, Non-GMO, Fodmap Friendly, Kosher.
- The perfect sauce for grilled meat
- Bottle Size: 148ml
- Heat Meater: 3/10
- A pack of six, 16-Ounce (total of 96-Ounces)
- Staple ingredient in Japanese cooking
- An irresistible splash of pineapple brings life to the traditional savory soy flavor of teriyaki
- brought together to create a truly one-of-a-kind pasta sauce HANDPICKED INGREDIENTS
- Sweet plum tomatoes, fresh onions, garlic and basil SLOW COOKED
- Great for grilling, baking, and saute
- Great for beef, pork, chicken, fish, or vegetables
- NO artificial perservatives
- Rich sauce for meats and fish, sandwiches, burgers, eggs, fries, vegetables
- Made with molases, malt vinegar, dates and spices
- Great tasting.
- Excellent for restaurants.
- High quality.
- Fish sauce provides the essential savory flavor found in traditional Thai cuisine
- Made only from the careful first pressing of salted anchovies
- Marinade and brush on meat before and during grilling
- Top off burgers, chicken, pork or fish
- Serve as a dipping sauce for meats and veggies
1. Red Boat Fish Sauce – 8.45 fl oz bottle
- Made from wild-caught black anchovy and sea salt
- Barrel-aged using a centuries-old fermentation tradition
- Premium fish sauce is a secret ingredient used by professional chefs and home cooks around the world
- First Press Extra Virgin
- Easy and convenient to use
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com – Seller | |
Walmart | |
Walmart – KWIEK LLC | |
Thrive Market |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Units in Package | 1 |
Unit Size | 8.45 fl oz |
Directions | Refrigerate after opening. |
Ingredients | Anchovy, Sea Salt. |
Nutrition Facts | |
Serving Size | 1 tbsp |
Servings Per Container | 17 |
Calories | 15 |
Calories from Fat | 0 |
Total Fat | 0 g (0 %) |
Saturated Fat | 0 g (0 %) |
Cholesterol | 0 mg (0 %) |
Sodium | 1490 mg (62 %) |
Total Carbohydrate | 0 g (0 %) |
Dietary Fiber | 0 g (0 %) |
Sugars | 0 g |
Protein | 4 g |
Vitamin A | 0 % |
Vitamin C | 0 % |
Calcium | 0 % |
Iron | 0 % |
Trans Fat | 0 g |
Reviews From Real Customers
2. Maya Kaimal Indian Simmer Sauce, Kashmiri Curry, Mild – 12.5 oz
- Rich tomato with nutmeg
- All Natural,No Preservatives
- Gluten Free,No Starch Thickeners
- Vegan
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon.com | |
Walmart – KOOL4EVER | |
Thrive Market | |
iHerb |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 125g |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 3 |
Allergens | CONTAINS: TREE NUTS (COCONUT); MADE IN A FACILITY WITH A CONTROLLED ALLERGEN PROGRAM. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
3. Louisiana Remoulade Sauce – 10.5 oz
- 10.5 oz
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
CajunGrocer.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 28g |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 11 |
Allergens | CONTAINS EGG |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Contains Egg |
Reviews From Real Customers
4. Rao’s Homemade Marinara – 24 oz
- Six jars of 24oz pasta sauce (144 oz total)
- Famous homemade recipe from New York restaurant
- Made from all natural ingredients
- Gluten Free
- A good source of Vitamin C
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay – tatlas-83 | |
Thrive Market | |
Target |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 125g |
Food Servings Per Container | about 5 |
Grocery Info | |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Paleo |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Atkins |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Vegan |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Dairy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrate Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Vegetarian |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Caffeine Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Wheat Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Grain Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Ketogenic |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nut Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | High Fructose Corn Syrup Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Artificial Color Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Whole30 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Diabetic Support |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Lactose Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Artificial Preservative Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Plant Based |
Derived Nutrition Claim | No Artificial Ingredients |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Peanut Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | No Added Sugar |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Gluten Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Tree Nut Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Egg Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Shell Fish Free |
Rich Ingredients | Italian Whole Peeled Tomatoes, Olive Oil, Onions, Salt, Garlic, Basil, Black Pepper, Oregano. |
Ingredients | Italian Whole Peeled Tomatoes, Olive Oil, Onions, Salt, Garlic, Basil, Black Pepper, Oregano. |
Nutrition Claim | Natural |
Nutrition Fact | |
Added Sugars | 0g |
Added Sugars Daily Percentage | 0 |
Calcium | 20mg |
Calcium Daily Percentage | 0 |
Cholesterol | 0mg |
Cholesterol Daily Percentage | 0 |
Dietary Fiber | 1g |
Dietary Fiber Daily Percentage | 5 |
Energy | 100kcal |
Iron | 0.2mg |
Iron Daily Percentage | 0 |
Potassium | 370mg |
Potassium Daily Percentage | 8 |
Protein | 2g |
Saturated Fat | 1g |
Saturated Fat Daily Percentage | 5 |
Sodium | 420mg |
Sodium Daily Percentage | 18 |
Total Carbohydrate | 6g |
Total Carbohydrate Daily Percentage | 2 |
Total Fat | 7g |
Total Fat Daily Percentage | 9 |
Total Sugars | 4g |
Trans Fat | 0g |
Vitamin D | 0mcg |
Vitamin D Daily Percentage | 0 |
Reviews From Real Customers
5. Mr. Yoshida’s Marinade & Cooking Sauce, Sweet Teriyaki, Original Gourmet – 17 fl oz
- Soy sauce based sauce
- Yoshida’s mirin added to enhance the flavors
- Great for beef, pork, chicken, fish or vegetables
- Resealable bottle to avoid spillage
- Product of USA
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Albertsons | |
Fred Meyer |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 15ml |
Food Servings Per Container | About 33 |
Allergens | CONTAINS WHEAT, SOYBEANS. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Dairy Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
6. Mccormick Cocktail Sauce, Extra Hot – 8 fl oz
- Product Dimensions : 2.47 x 2.47 x 5.11 inches; 15.89 Ounces.
- UPC : .
- Extra hot cocktail dipping sauce made with real horseradish and hint of lemon.
- Certified Kosher pareve by the Orthodox Union.
- Perfect spicy complement to shrimp, oysters, and clams.
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Walmart – FANZYMART, LLC | |
Lucky Supermarkets | |
ShopFoodEx.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 60ml |
Food Servings Per Container | About 4 |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Dairy Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
7. San-J Stir-Fry & Marinade, Gluten Free, Teriyaki – 10 fl oz
- A perfect sweet & savory blend with ginger, garlic and San-J’s popular, umami-rich Tamari Soy Sauce.
- Certified gluten free, Non-GMO, Fodmap Friendly, Kosher.
- No artificial preservatives, flavors, or colors added.
- Use this versatile sauce to marinate, glaze or season any meat, fish, tofu, plant protein, or vegetable for great flavor.
- Works great for stir-fry, grilled dishes, and fried rice or noodles.
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart – Jadas Hats | |
Azure Standard |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 15ml |
Food Servings Per Container | ABOUT 20 |
Allergens | ALLERGEN INFORMATION: THIS PRODUCT CONTAINS SOY INGREDIENTS. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Dairy Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
8. Dawson’s Shawarma Sauce
- The perfect sauce for grilled meat
- Bottle Size: 148ml
- Heat Meater: 3/10
- Made in Canada
- Try it with roasted vegetables, hummus or falafel
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Heatonist |
Product Details
Reviews From Real Customers
9. Soy Vay Marinade & Sauce, Less Sodium, Veri Veri Teriyaki – 21 oz
- 21 oz
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Target | |
Fred Meyer | |
Snackathon Foods |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 19g |
Food Servings Per Container | about 32 |
Allergens | Contains: Wheat, Soy. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Dairy Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
10. World Harbors Sauce & Marinade, Teriyaki, Maui Mountain – 16 fl oz
- A pack of six, 16-Ounce (total of 96-Ounces)
- Staple ingredient in Japanese cooking
- An irresistible splash of pineapple brings life to the traditional savory soy flavor of teriyaki
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
Target |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Units in Package | 1 |
Unit Size | 16 fl oz |
Directions | Refrigerate after opening. Minute Ready Ideas: Maui Grill: Simply brush on meat, chicken or fish and barbeque to taste, basting frequently. Maui Extras: Gently mix Teriyaki sauce with cooked noodles, vegetables or tofu for a special side dish or light meal. Discard used marinade. |
Ingredients | High Fructose Corn Syrup, Water, Molasses, Soy Sauce (Water, Soybeans, Wheat and Salt), Citric Acid, Pineapple Juice Concentrate, Garlic (Dried), Xanthan Gum, Natural Flavors, Caramel Color, Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate (as Preservatives). |
Warnings | Contains soy and wheat. |
Reviews From Real Customers
11. Johnny’s Salmon Finishing Sauce, 12 fl oz, (Pack of 6)
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Walmart |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Assembled Product Dimensions (L x W x H) | 5.44 x 8.00 x 8.13 Inches |
Reviews From Real Customers
12. Mezzetta Sauce, Marinara – 24.5 oz
- brought together to create a truly one-of-a-kind pasta sauce HANDPICKED INGREDIENTS
- Sweet plum tomatoes, fresh onions, garlic and basil SLOW COOKED
- Simmered and served with love—and a side of garlic bread TRADITIONAL TASTE
- Part of our Mezzetta Napa Valley homemade products MEZZETTA
- Great things come in glass jars
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Instacart | |
Fred Meyer | |
ShopFoodEx.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Units in Package | 1 |
Unit Size | 25 oz |
Directions | This is an all-natural product some separation may occur. Please shake well before using. Refrigerate after opening. |
Ingredients | Imported Italian Plum Tomatoes from the San Marzano Region, Imported Olive Oil, Fresh Onions, Sea Salt, Fresh Garlic, Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Wine, Fresh Basil, Black Pepper, Oregano. |
Serving Size | 0.5 cup |
Reviews From Real Customers
13. Mr. Yoshida’s Original Gourmet Sauce 1 Pack (86 Ounce)
- Great for grilling, baking, and saute
- Great for beef, pork, chicken, fish, or vegetables
- NO artificial perservatives
- NO added MSG
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
RateKitchen.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Is Discontinued By Manufacturer | No |
Package Dimensions | 9.76 x 4.49 x 4.06 inches; 5.67 Pounds |
Ingredient Type | MSG Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
14. Daddies Brown Sauce 14.11 Ounce
- Rich sauce for meats and fish, sandwiches, burgers, eggs, fries, vegetables
- Made with molases, malt vinegar, dates and spices
- Squeezy, 14.11 oz (400g) bottle
- A favorite sauce since 1904
- Suitable for vegetarians
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Paragon Essentials | |
Grocery.com Store |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Product Dimensions | 1.89 x 2.83 x 8.07 inches |
Reviews From Real Customers
15. Frontera Enchilada Sauce, Green Chile, Medium – 8 oz
- Green Chili
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay – foodeconcepts | |
Netrition.com | |
SoupsOnline.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 60g |
Food Servings Per Container | about 4 |
Allergens | CONTAINS: MILK. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Nitrite Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
16. A.1. Sauce, Original – 2 pack, 15 oz bottles
- Great tasting.
- Excellent for restaurants.
- High quality.
- Brand name.
- Use in recipes or as a dipping sauce.
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart | |
Sam’s Club |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Nutrition Claim | Kosher |
17. Peach BBQ Sauce, 12 oz.
- 12oz / 1 Gallon
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
SuckleBusters | |
TexasFood.com | |
Indigo Pool Patio BBQ |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
City | Coppell, TX |
Flavor | Peach |
Reviews From Real Customers
18. Thai Kitchen Fish Sauce, Premium – 6.76 fl oz
- Fish sauce provides the essential savory flavor found in traditional Thai cuisine
- Made only from the careful first pressing of salted anchovies
- Complex flavor blends smoothly with the sweet, tangy and spicy flavors of Thai cuisine
- Use in place of soy sauce or salt to add a savory taste to any dish
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
Walmart | |
Target | |
Farmstead Grocery Delivery |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Food Serving Size Measure | 15ml |
Food Servings Per Container | 13 |
Allergens | CONTAINS: FISH – ANCHOVY. |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Low Carb |
Derived Nutrition Claim | Soy Free |
Reviews From Real Customers
19. Alpha Chef Sauce Fish Recipe Dog & Cat Food Topper, 8-oz Bottle
- Fish
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Amazon | |
eBay | |
Walmart – Alpha Chef | |
Chewy.com |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Shop Conscious | Human-Grade, Natural |
Reviews From Real Customers
20. Caribbean Jerk Sauce, Island Spices and Peppers – 12 oz
- Marinade and brush on meat before and during grilling
- Top off burgers, chicken, pork or fish
- Serve as a dipping sauce for meats and veggies
Check Latest Price
Sold By | Price |
Big Lots |
Product Details
Specifications
Details | |
Serving Size | 12 |
Total Fat | 2.5g |
Saturated Fat | 0g |
Trans Fat | 0g |
Cholesterol | 0.00mg |
Reviews From Real Customers
Conclusion
In conclusion, the best sauces for mahi mahi are those that are light and bright, with fresh flavors that complement the fish without overpowering it. Citrus, herbs, and spice are all great options for mahi mahi, so get creative and experiment until you find a combination that you love.