When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Liquor For Pina Colada (2024 Updated)

If you're looking for a refreshing summer drink, you can't go wrong with a classic pina colada. But what makes a great pina colada? It all comes down to the ingredients, which include rum, coconut cream, and pineapples. While the pineapple and coconut cream are critical, it's the type of rum you use that can make or break your cocktail. That's why choosing the right liquor for pina colada is essential.

When considering what type of rum to use for your pina colada, several factors come into play. Firstly, consider the alcohol content of the rum. Traditional pina coladas use light rum, which has a lower alcohol percentage, but you can also experiment with using a darker, fuller-bodied rum for a deeper flavor. You'll also want to think about the sweetness level of your rum. Ultimately, the rum you select should complement the sweetness of the other ingredients in your cocktail.

So, how do you know which liquors are the best fit for your pina colada? Here are some essential questions to keep in mind:

Have you experimented with different types of rum before?

What flavors are you looking to bring out in your cocktail?

Do you prefer your cocktail to be sweet or more balanced?

By taking the time to weigh these factors and explore different liquors, you're sure to get the perfect pina colada that matches your preferences.

10 Best Liquor For Pina Colada

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
This product is ideal for those who enjoy making a variety of cocktails and want to try different mixers.
2
This product is ideal for making all-natural frozen Pina Colada slushies at home.
3
It is ideal for making a delicious and refreshing Pina Colada drink at home or in a bar/restaurant setting.
4
Ideal for adding flavor to cocktails, mocktails, frozen drinks and other beverages without the added sugar.
5
Ideal for those looking for zero calorie, sugar-free drink mix options with a tropical flavor. Great for nutrition clubs & loaded teas.
6
Ideal for creating refreshing and delicious Pina Colada smoothies at home or in a commercial setting.
7
It is ideal for making tropical cocktails at home or in a bar setting.
8
Ideal for making delicious and refreshing piña coladas at home, parties or events in large quantities.
9
This product is ideal for individuals seeking a sugar-free alternative to traditional root beer.
10
The product is ideal for making refreshing and flavorful gelatin shots for parties or gatherings.
This product is ideal for those who enjoy making a variety of cocktails and want to try different mixers.
This product is ideal for making all-natural frozen Pina Colada slushies at home.
It is ideal for making a delicious and refreshing Pina Colada drink at home or in a bar/restaurant setting.
Ideal for adding flavor to cocktails, mocktails, frozen drinks and other beverages without the added sugar.
Ideal for those looking for zero calorie, sugar-free drink mix options with a tropical flavor. Great for nutrition clubs & loaded teas.
Ideal for creating refreshing and delicious Pina Colada smoothies at home or in a commercial setting.
It is ideal for making tropical cocktails at home or in a bar setting.
Ideal for making delicious and refreshing piña coladas at home, parties or events in large quantities.
This product is ideal for individuals seeking a sugar-free alternative to traditional root beer.
The product is ideal for making refreshing and flavorful gelatin shots for parties or gatherings.

1. Mixologist's Delight: 12 Cocktail Mixers

The Ten Acre Gifts cocktail mix gift set is the perfect addition to any party or social gathering. This set includes 12 different flavors of 3 ounce bottles such as lemon drop, pina colada, Moscow Mule, classic margarita, blood orange margarita, strawberry margarita, mango margarita, pineapple mai tai, peach bellini, cosmopolitan, mojito, and old fashioned syrup mixes. Each bottle is filled with high-quality ingredients that will add a touch of class and fun to any mixed drink or mocktail.

This alcohol mixer set is versatile and great for any occasion including birthday celebrations, Christmas parties, weddings, Father's Day, Mother's Day, or housewarming gatherings. It also makes a perfect gift for bachelor and bachelorette parties. With this cocktail mix set, you can create a wide variety of drinks that will keep your guests entertained throughout the night.

Mixing and serving these drink mix sampler flavors is easy and hassle-free. Simply add the mix to your favorite ingredients, mix, and serve. The flavors are designed to complement any drink and will provide a refreshing and sumptuous taste to your mixed drinks. Whether you are a professional bartender or a home mixologist, this cocktail and mocktail mixer gift set is perfect for you.

The cocktail flavoring sets are perfect for creating a festive display on your mini bar or liquor desk. They look perfect when paired with glasses or alcohol bottles. These mixers are perfect for happy hour at home or for impressing your guests at a party. The possibilities are endless with this versatile cocktail mixer set.

This craft cocktail kit comes in a sleek, stylish craft box embellished with an eye-catching red and gold aesthetic. The box is thoughtfully designed and no wrapping is necessary, making it the perfect gift for any occasion. With this gift set, you can feel good about giving a gift without any of the hassle.

Pros

  • Includes 12 different flavors of 3 ounce bottles
  • High-quality ingredients that will add a touch of class and fun to any mixed drink or mocktail
  • Versatile and great for any occasion including birthday celebrations, Christmas parties, weddings, Father's Day, Mother's Day, or housewarming gatherings
  • Easy and hassle-free to mix and serve
  • Perfect for creating a festive display on your mini bar or liquor desk
  • Complements any drink and will provide a refreshing and sumptuous taste to your mixed drinks
  • Sleek, stylish craft box embellished with an eye-catching red and gold aesthetic

2. Pre-Mixed Pina Colada Slushies By Lt. Blender

With Lt. Blender's Pina Colada mix, you can now make the perfect delicious frozen pina colada every time with ease. Whether you are a professional bartender or an amateur mixologist, this pina colada slushie mix is the easiest to make. The best part is that you don't even need a blender, pina colada machine or even ice to make it!

To get started, all you need to do is add rum straight into the bag, top it off with water, then shake, freeze and squeeze it for a frozen slushie cocktail. If you can't wait, you can serve it straight away over ice. Made with real dehydrated fruits, this mix is free from any artificial colors, flavors, syrups or preservatives. You get to enjoy a real pina colada juice with the taste of fresh coconut and pineapple in every sip!

This mix is perfect for entertaining as Lt. Blender's cocktail mixers are portable and resealable. You can take our mixes to your next book club, the beach, swimming pool or to a party. Each bag of our simple pina colada drink mix makes a 1/2 gallon of piña coladas, which is sixteen servings. Whether you want to make Pina Colada with liquor or make it non-alcoholic, this mix is gluten-free, nut-free and vegan, making it perfect for everyone to enjoy!

Pros

  • Easy to make
  • No blender or ice needed
  • Made with real dehydrated fruits
  • Free from artificial colors, flavors, syrups or preservatives
  • Portable and resealable
  • Gluten-free, nut-free and vegan

3. Finest Call Premium Pina Colada Drink Mix, 1 Liter Bottle (33.8 Fl Oz), Individually Boxed

For cocktail enthusiasts, the search for the perfect mixer can be a daunting task. Look no further than Finest Call Cocktail Mixes, the highest quality and most bartender-friendly mixer in the world. The mix is made from real coconut and pineapple juice, which provides full flavor, aroma, and consistency, making it perfect for cocktails that are shaken, stirred, built, or blended. It is packaged in a 1-liter bottle, which is individually boxed for safe shipping.

Finest Call Cocktail Mixes are made with patented packaging, including a new dispensing closure that is bartender-designed for precise, high-speed pour applications. This feature ensures that the mix is poured at a consistent rate, making it easy to create cocktails with perfect consistency every time.

The mix is 100% consistent in flavor and yield, making it a must-have for professional bartenders and home mixologists alike. The mix is also stable, ensuring that it retains its flavor and quality over time. With Finest Call Cocktail Mixes, you can create cocktails that are as delicious as they are beautiful.

Pros

  • Made from real coconut and pineapple juice for full flavor and aroma
  • Patented packaging with a bartender-designed dispensing closure for precise, high-speed pour applications
  • 100% consistent flavor and yield
  • Stable and retains flavor and quality over time

4. Skinny Pina Colada Mix For Guilt-Free Drinks.

Jordan's Skinny Mixes Pina Colada Mix is the perfect blend of pineapple and creamy coconut flavoring, designed to bring a tropical twist to your favorite drinks and foods. This guilt-free flavor mix is made with 0 sugar, 0 calories, and 0 carbs, so you can indulge in the taste of paradise anytime without any guilt!

Jordan's Skinny Mixes are made for everyone, as they are gluten-free, kosher, keto-friendly, non-GMO, and crafted in the USA, ensuring high-quality and safe products. This mix is versatile, and a little goes a long way. Simply stir 2 tablespoons into your beverage or adjust to find the perfect flavor and sweetness for you.

This mix is designed for drinks but can be used in a variety of ways, including coffee, espresso, cold brew, smoothies, oatmeal, yogurt, baking, and more. Jordan's Skinny Mixes Pina Colada Mix is a must-have for those who want to add a tropical twist to their daily routine without compromising on flavor and health benefits.

Pros

  • 0 sugar, 0 calorie, and 0 carbs for guilt-free indulgence
  • Gluten-free, kosher, keto-friendly, non-GMO, and crafted in the USA
  • Versatile mix for various drinks, foods, and recipes

5. Stevia-Sweetened Pina Colada Drink Mix

The Zero Calorie Drink Mix is a perfect solution for those who are looking for a healthy alternative to sugary drinks. This drink mix is completely free from calories, sugar, and artificial sweeteners, and is instead sweetened solely with organic stevia. It is a popular choice among nutrition clubs and is often used in loaded tea recipes. Moreover, this drink mix is keto-friendly, kosher, and low carb, making it an ideal choice for those who are following a specific diet.

The Master Pouch contains three inner pouches, each weighing 4.5 ounces, making the total weight of the pouch 13.5 ounces. The product can make a total of 240 servings of 8 fluid ounces prepared zero-calorie drink. It is important to note that for the best flavor, the drink mix must be blended as directed. Adding more mix than instructed will not enhance the flavor but may add bitterness, as organic stevia is highly concentrated.

Pros

  • Zero Calories
  • Zero Sugar
  • Zero Artificial Sweeteners
  • Sweetened with Organic Stevia Only
  • Keto-Friendly
  • Kosher
  • Low Carb
  • 240 Servings as 8 Fluid Ounce Prepared Zero Calorie Drink

Cons

  • – Overdosing on the product may lead to bitterness

6. Torani Real Fruit Smoothie Mixes, Pina Colada, 64 Ounce

Experience a tropical escape with the Pina Colada Smoothie Mix, which combines tangy, sweet pineapple with creamy coconut for a craveable and delicious smoothie that you can enjoy year-round. This mix is perfect for those who love real fruit, as it contains no preservatives, artificial colors, or flavors. Simply pour the mix over ice, blend and serve for a refreshing and satisfying drink.

For those looking to embrace their inner flavorista, Torani offers a wide array of syrups and sauces in tantalizing flavors. Use these products to create your own homemade coffeehouse favorites, fruity delights, and custom soda creations. With Torani, you can mix up some magic and create truly creative flavored teas, lemonades, smoothies, Italian sodas, coffees, cocktails, mocktails, snow cones, sparkling waters, and more.

Get an authentic coffeehouse flavor with Torani's syrups and sauces. Choose from classic flavors like caramel, French vanilla, and hazelnut, or try something new and exciting. With Torani, you can create tantalizing lattes, cappuccinos, cold brews, and frappes that are sure to delight your taste buds.

Pros

  • Pina Colada Smoothie Mix offers a tropical escape with its blend of tangy, sweet pineapple and creamy coconut.
  • Torani syrups and sauces come in a wide array of tantalizing flavors, making it easy to create homemade coffeehouse favorites and custom soda creations.
  • Torani's syrups and sauces are perfect for those looking to add a creative twist to their drinks, whether it's flavored teas, lemonades, smoothies, Italian sodas, coffees, cocktails, mocktails, snow cones, sparkling waters, and more.

Cons

  • – None

7. Mr & Mrs T Pina Colada Mix, 1 L Bottles (Pack Of 6)

Mr & Mrs T's Mixers Piña Colada Mix is a high-quality drink mixer made with cane sugar and premium ingredients. Every sip delivers a fresh island taste with a blend of rich pineapple and smooth coconut flavors. The made-from-scratch taste makes it perfect for traditional Piña Coladas or tasty virgin cocktails. The mixer is ready to be mixed with your favorite spirits right out of the bottle, making it an excellent option for parties and gatherings. Mr & Mrs T has been making quality drink mixers since 1960 and is a trusted brand that has become a staple in American homes.

Experience the tropical flavors of Mr & Mrs T's Mixers Piña Colada Mix and elevate your cocktail game to the next level. The blend of pineapple and coconut flavors is sure to transport you to a tropical paradise with every sip. The made-from-scratch taste ensures that you get the authentic Piña Colada experience every time. The mixer is versatile and can be used to create both alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks, making it perfect for any occasion.

Pros

  • Made with high-quality ingredients
  • Fresh island taste with a blend of rich pineapple and smooth coconut flavors
  • Ready to mix with your favorite spirits
  • Can be used to create both alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks

8. Goya Foods Piña Colada Mix, 12 Fl Oz (Pack Of 24)

Transport your taste buds to the tropics with GOYA Pina Colada Mix, the sweetest and creamiest mix hailing from the Dominican Republic. Whether you prefer a traditional alcoholic blend or a non-alcoholic version, this versatile and convenient mix makes it easy to create the perfect Pina Colada in just a few simple steps. Simply mix with your preferred rum or enjoy it without alcohol for a delicious and refreshing beverage.

This pack of 24 12.0 oz cans is perfect for hosting parties, stocking up your bar, or enjoying with friends and family. For added convenience, single unit cans are also available on Prime Pantry.

As a brand committed to quality, you can trust that GOYA Pina Colada Mix will deliver the best taste experience possible. If it's Goya, it has to be good! ¡Si es Goya… tiene que ser bueno!

Pros

  • Sweet and creamy mix for the best Pina Colada experience
  • Versatile and convenient, perfect for both alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks
  • Pack of 24 cans for hosting parties or stocking up your bar
  • Single unit cans available on Prime Pantry for added convenience
  • Committed to quality, ensuring the best taste experience possible

9. Barq's Zero Sugar Root Beer 12 Ounce Cans Bundle Pack By Louisiana Pantry (12)

Satisfy your craving for a delicious and refreshing root beer with Barq's Zero Root Beer Bundle. This bundle includes 12 packs of Barq's Zero Sugar Root Beer, which is perfect for those who want to keep their calorie intake low without compromising on taste. Barq's Zero Sugar Root Beer has the same great taste and bite as regular Barq's, but without the sugar and caffeine. It's the perfect beverage to enjoy by itself or with your favorite meal.

Barq's has been a trusted brand since 1898, and their simple slogan, DRINK BARQ'S. IT'S GOOD, still holds true today. Whether you're looking for a refreshing drink on a hot summer day or a perfect accompaniment to your favorite dessert, Barq's Zero Sugar Root Beer is the perfect choice. The bundle is bundled by Louisiana Pantry, ensuring that you receive the best quality products.

Barq's Zero Sugar Root Beer is also an excellent ingredient to make the perfect float. Just add ice cream and enjoy the perfect mixture of creamy and fizzy flavors. So, try Barq's Zero Sugar Root Beer today and experience the same great taste without the added sugar and caffeine.

Pros

  • Same great taste and bite as regular Barq's
  • Zero sugar and caffeine-free
  • Perfect to enjoy by itself or with a meal
  • Excellent ingredient to make the perfect float

Best Liquor For Pina Colada FAQs

Can you substitute rum for other types of liquor in a pina colada?

Yes, you can substitute rum for other types of liquor in a pina colada. Traditionally, rum is the main ingredient in a pina colada, but some people prefer to use other types of liquor to give the drink a unique twist. For example, you can use tequila instead of rum to make a Tequila Colada, or you can use vodka for a Vodka Colada.

However, it's important to note that using a different type of alcohol will change the flavor of the drink. Rum has a distinct flavor that is associated with pina coladas, so if you do decide to substitute it, make sure you choose a liquor that complements the other ingredients in the drink.

Ultimately, the choice to substitute rum for other types of liquor in a pina colada is up to personal preference. If you're feeling adventurous, try experimenting with different liquors to find your perfect twist on this classic tropical cocktail.

How much liquor should be used in a single serving of pina colada?

The amount of liquor in a single serving of Pina Colada varies depending on personal preference and the recipe being used. Generally, a standard recipe calls for 1 1/2 to 2 ounces of rum per serving. However, some recipes may call for more or less depending on the desired strength of the drink. It is important to remember that the sweetness of the drink can mask the taste of the alcohol, so it is important to drink responsibly and monitor your intake. It is also important to note that some variations of Pina Colada may use different types of liquor, such as tequila or vodka, in place of rum. As always, it is important to follow the recipe carefully and adjust the amount of liquor to your own personal taste.

Is there a specific brand of liquor that works best in a pina colada?

When it comes to making a pina colada, there are various types of liquor that you can use to create this refreshing drink. However, the most popular and traditional choice of liquor for a pina colada is white rum. White rum has a light and smooth taste that complements the tropical flavors of coconut and pineapple, making it an ideal choice for this cocktail. Some popular brands of white rum that work best in a pina colada include Bacardi, Malibu, and Captain Morgan. However, if you prefer a stronger and more flavorful drink, you can use dark rum or spiced rum instead of white rum. Ultimately, the choice of liquor depends on your personal preference and taste. Experiment with different brands and types of liquor to find the perfect blend for your pina colada.

What is the alcohol content of a typical pina colada made with liquor?

The alcohol content of a typical pina colada made with liquor varies depending on the recipe and the amount of alcohol used. Generally, a pina colada is made with rum, which has an alcohol content of around 40%. However, the amount of rum used in a pina colada can vary from recipe to recipe.

A standard pina colada recipe typically calls for 2 ounces of rum, which would result in an alcohol content of approximately 12%. However, some recipes may call for more or less rum, which would affect the alcohol content. Additionally, some recipes may call for the use of other types of alcohol, such as vodka or tequila, which would also affect the alcohol content.

It's important to remember that the alcohol content of a drink also depends on the size of the serving. A larger serving of a pina colada would naturally contain more alcohol than a smaller serving. As with any alcoholic beverage, it's important to drink responsibly and in moderation.

What type of liquor is traditionally used in a pina colada?

The traditional and most commonly used liquor in a pina colada is rum. The rum used in a pina colada is typically a light or white rum, which is known for its mild flavor and ability to blend well with other ingredients. The combination of rum, coconut cream or milk, and pineapple juice is what gives this tropical drink its signature taste and aroma. While some variations of the pina colada may include other liquors such as dark rum or flavored liqueurs, the classic recipe calls for white rum. The balance of sweet and tart flavors in the drink, along with the smooth texture from the coconut cream, make it a popular choice for those seeking a refreshing and satisfying cocktail. Whether enjoyed on a beach vacation or at home, the pina colada is a timeless favorite that continues to delight drinkers around the world.

Leave a Comment