20 Best Liquor For Egg Nog (2023 Updated)

This eggnog is fantastic, I start looking for it by October & stock up. It’s the only one my family drinks & we’ve tried others. I give as a gift in my holiday baskets & my receivers love it & ask for it every year some even ask if I have any left.

My daughter & I share a bottle in July to celebrate the Hallmark Christmas in July movies & programs that start early Xmas shopping.

One of my favorite holiday drink. is made with smooth Kentucky Bourbon and real dairy cream. I love that it’s already spiked, no extra work. It’s very smooth and rich with a creamy vanilla note and a Créme brúlée and nutmeg scent.

I used it when baking my bread pudding and added it to my espresso to make Espresso Nog, elevating my drink😋.

Creamy. Thick. Smooth taste. Very affordable. Last me a few hours. Wish it was year round. Needs no accompaniment. Superb. Bourbon is just enough.

Compared to other seasonable egg nog drinks, this is our best choice… Tastes fantastic & smooth. No excess liquors besides brandy which makes this an excellent drink.

I am allergic to rum. To be able to enjoy the holidays with a nice sweet holiday drink with no rum in it made my moments. There is a nice balance of brandy and eggnog. This is a must try for anyone that enjoys spiked eggnog.

Cheers!.

I would not serve this garbage to my friends, my enemies, my most hated in-laws, or even insects that I wanted to kill. Nothing should taste this bad. I’m seriously considering taking it back to the store because it is ACTUALLY THAT BAD.

Please don’t buy this product. Christian Brothers needs to understand that they have a moral obligation to stop putting it on the market.

I love egg nog more than makes sense. I believe firmly that egg nog requires alcohol. I’ve only purchased a handful of non alcoholic grocery store egg nogs, and they’re all gross. Absolutely disgusting, even when you booze them up.

PA Dutch is hands down the best pre – boozed egg nog that exists, and I usually buy 2 cases of it in January or February so I can make it to the next egg nog season. This year, because of the pandemic, the state run liquor stores of PA closed and cancelled my order leaving me without egg nog for an entire summer.

And then comes October. The stores are open again but they don’t have the boozy egg nog yet. And then, I just happened to see this during a Sam’s run. A quick Google search showed high marks, so I grabbed it.

I did not expect much. Oh, how pleasantly surprised I am. 4 parts egg nog to 1 part booze of choice = a fresh, delightful egg nog that rivals – if not surpasses!!! the best that the liquor store has to offer.

Unfortunately it doesn’t keep long enough to last until next October – but you can be danged sure that this will be the egg nog that we drink in my home until it’s unavailable. It’s thick, creamy, and perfectly spiced.

Its a little gross without the booze – almost too thick. But it’s absolutely perfect with a 4/1 dilution. The one true caveat – the ingredients are gross. Don’t read them. GMOs, corn syrup and artificially flavored.

Yuck. Seriously, don’t read them. Just drink and be merry.

This is by far the best tasting egg nog I have ever tried! It has a great texture. It is oh so smooth and creamy! Best part is it doesn’t leave you with a bad after taste! It tastes great by it self or spiked! When I buy this, I always have to buy more than just 1, because my whole family loves it! I’m so glad they decided to come out with a half gallon size!.

Nothing reminds me more of the upcoming holidays than Southern Comfort egg nog. Around this time every year i find myself getting into the holiday spirit with a tall glass of southern comfort traditional eggnog ,it’s rich and creamy taste sets the mood for a night of strategic planning my decor for the next few months.

It’s priced well below its flavor value and tastes better than other brands that have no flavor and are way more expensive. So as for me Southern comfort eggnog tastes amazing and will forever remind me of the holidays.

Ingredient list: Milk, Cream, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Sugar, Corn Syrup, and finally egg yolks. Texture is good, but doesn’t taste like the higher quality egg nogs made with better ingredients. Unfortunately Sams didn’t have the ingredient info online when I ordered for curbside pick-up.

Hope this review helps someone else to avoid my mistake.

This egg nog is very,very, extremely sweet. You are really drinking tons of sugar (36%). It is advertised that it is Vanilla & Spice but it is really just flavored with Vanilla & spice – if that. What is or are the spices that it is flavored with? You CAN NOT taste any vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, turmeric or any other spice or spices that they added or flavored it with.

Looking at the list of ingredients on the container there is NO Vanilla, No cinnamon, No nutmeg, No turmeric etc. Listed. No Vanilla. No spice or spices listed in the ingredients. There’s just a LOT of Fructose, Corn Syrup etc.

(36%), which is just another way of saying tons of sugar. FALSE FALSE FALSE ADVERTISING. What a Rip Off. Be more honest and add real Vanilla, real Cinnamon, real Nutmeg & real Turmeric to this eggnog so that a person can taste them also.

Do not just pretend that there is Vanilla &/or any spice or spices. Do not do False advertising & False labeling that it is flavored with Vanilla & spice because it is just flavored with a lot of fructose, corn syrup etc.

(36%). Be honest, reputable, trustworthy to your customers & future customers. I & my friends will never buy this Vanilla & Spice flavored egg nog. I Do Not Recommend this egg nog to anybody unless they want to drink 36% corn syrup, fructose etc.

, which is just drinking a lot of sugar. This is GREAT if you want to get DIABETES.

This is by far my favorite brand and flavor of egg nog. The flavor is rich, sweet, and spicy. The texture is extremely creamy. I stock up on this egg nog as it goes quickly and I normally can only find it at Walmart.

I have 4 cartons in my frig currently so that I can continue to enjoy it even though Christmas is over. I recommend it to all and re-buy it every year. I refuse to buy any other egg nog unless it is this brand and flavor.

Beware, you will become hooked!.

I love love his time of year with all the different foods and drinks found around holidays. I saw this in acme and decided to try it , well it’s smooth and creamy a delicious way to serve eggnog. Would definitely recommend this and purchase again.

Evan Williams Egg Nog IS COMPLETELY ON ANOTHER LEVEL! It was worth the drive across town. Things didn’t go as I planned. However, Tom’s top professional, analytical & management skills came into play.

He’s 100% at customer service & satisfaction. His instructional interactions with an underling was seamles. Tom kept the young man calm step by step with his tone of voice. I had a delightful experience receiving his personal graciousness and gifting spirit.

Thank you EVAN WILLIAMS Egg Nog for again besetting my journey to you where I witnessed the Spirit of Christmas with EVAN WILLIAMS. P. S. it’s always in huge demand have to get it while you can. Quero Mas EWEG.

Out of all that is out there this one is far the Best !! Not to thick like others and amazing taste. Just have to be careful as it is so good you forget how much you have had to drink if it !!! Sadly it’s only around once a year.

Guess I need to stock up for all year !!!.

Evan Williams Egg Nog. I am NOT an egg nog person, but this is wonderful. I tasted it at a Thanksgiving get together last Fall. It doesn’t taste too sharp because of the alcohol. Is smooth, creamy and very tasty.

Should I say I drank a whole small bottle myself? Maybe not!.

Commet to the reviewer, Carl Pearlston, the egg nog you received is EXPIRED! The egg not SHOULD NOT CLABBERATE like that. I’ve notice in two of the Spec’s that they have expired egg not as well. The date on the case is 11/11/20! That 11 months ago.

the egg not only has a shelf life of 7 months! I hope you don’t get sick! I took my case back to Spec’s for a refund! I’ll wait on the LARGE bottles to come out at the end of October or first of November, they should be good.

I will not buy the smaller bottles again this year! F. Y. I. , I love this stuff and buy 4 or 5 cases a year to last me until May but this year seems like expired egg nog is being shipped to many different liquor stores!.

I usually love this product, and buy it every year. This year, I took a bottle from one of the purchased cases and put it in the refrigerator as usual. When I opened the bottle the next day and removed the cap and attempted to pour some of the contents into a cup, nothing came out of the bottle.

I vigorously shook the bottle; nothing. I took a long wooden rod and stirred the contents. Finally I was able to pour an unusually thick eggnog into the cup. It was tasty. Had the same experience with another bottle.

Happy Thanksgiving beautiful people, wish I had three more bottles of this stuff, it’s absolutely amazing. Been cooking since 8am and would have given up by now if it wasn’t for this awesomeness in a bottle.

Freshly ground nutmeg and whiskey are the prominent notes, do they have it in a perfume? Wanna bathe in it. Cheap and cheerful, this mum is a happy camper. Cheers.

I am a huge fan of eggnog but only just recently tried the Mr. Boston brand. I absolutely love, super taste without being overwhelming. So creamy, it’s delicious either warm or cold. I really recommend it, especially to those who think they don’t like eggnog.

You can’t get more festive than a luscious cup of eggnog with just a little kick!.

Egg Nog and I hate they only sell around Christmas. The taste is so smooth. The price is affordable. I have tried other egg nogs but the like this one the best. Recommend other to try this egg nog. My niece drinks this type because of my recommendation.

Super, super, DUPER extremely sweet. Needs more nutmeg and cinnamon. Taste only be fixed by adding lots of decent bourbon. Otherwise, don’t add any and just use it as an ice cream topping.

Saw cases of this eggnog on display and decided since I love sugarlands dark chocolate sipping cream that I needed to try their eggnog. I grabbed 1 bottle which was a mistake. I went back to the same store 2 days later to get more of this delicious concoction and left empty handed.

completely sold out. So I hopped online and found more of it at another Total Wine. Yes, I drove 20+ miles to get 2 more bottles of this amazingly satisfying sipping cream. Sugarlands eggnog does not disappoint.

I strongly prefer this Sugarlands Eggnog over others that I’ve tried. It seems to be a bit lighter and less syrupy and sweet, but still has plenty of holiday flavor to it. To me, it’s simply a more pleasant after-dinner drink and doesn’t beat you over the head with sweetness.

I was spoiled with a couple of other spiked eggnogs that I bought previously. I probably should have been suspicious when they had a lot of this left and nothing else. I’m certain somebody would love this stuff but to call it eggnog is really a stretch.

I’ve been looking for Pennsylvania Dutch (PD) in this size for the past couple years. The bottle is the same, however the name is different. So, I grabbed some of the smaller bottles of PD and one of these.

My wife and I tried this and could not tell the difference. Grated a little nutmeg over it and it was lovely! :-).

Wanted to try eggnog for the first time and rather than try to make from scratch I bought a bottle of Winterhaven-Farms. Flavors are strong but not too overwhelming and is something I like to sip on in the evenings.

Recommend sprinkling a little cinnamon on top for first time drinkers.

If you like Pennsylvania dutch egg nog, [which is very good], you’ll really like the Winterhaven Farms. It is even smoother and has a great, rich flavor, but is not overpowering at all. This is my new favorite and absolutely one to buy again.

If you try it I’ll bet you’ll like it too!.

Smooth, velvety texture. Delicious. Perfect blend of spirits for a delicious but not over strong flavor. Nice that it is just as satisfying but not as heavy as the dairy based egg nogs that you can spike yourself.

Serve chilled icy cold for best flavor, maybe a little sprinkle of nutmeg on top. We’ve found it to be the perfect holiday season nightcap!.

Historically, I haven’t been a big fan of egg nog, yet I’ve tried different kinds over the years. Some are too sweet, others too strong. But Two Stars Egg Nog is incredible! It tastes like a creamy dessert with subtle sweetness, seasonal spices that are each pronounced, and the finish is a warming sensation from the alcohol.

Each sip is an experience of morphing flavors. This is my all time favorite Egg Nog and something I will be purchasing every year going forward. Two Stars deserves five stars for this incredible egg nog.

Let me start off by saying I am not into eggnog. The whole thing kinda grosses me out. However, my mother wanted some so I decided to ask a Total Wines associate to help me out. She recommended Two Stars and everyone who has tried it has loved it… even me!!! This stuff is amazing and I can see why it sells out quickly.

BOTTLE!!!THE WHOLE DANG THING! Seriously though the egg nog over ice or chilled was delicious, I added knob creek 100 proof and drank the whole dang bottle of Nog…. it’s a definite recommendation! Buy some for when the holidays are over and you want something to mix with ice cream and bourbon during the summer….

I bought this while on a shop for ingredients to make my version of spiked egg nog, I was hesitant as I usually don’t like pre-mixed cocktails but the associate had a chilled bottle and allowed us to sample it! I didn’t even end up buying what I needed to spike my own eggnog because this was so good, nice and strong with an egg nog finish! My family loves it and it will be around at Christmas dinner! :).

I bought this nog for my boyfriend. It was reasonably priced for the amount of beverage provided. Even though I rarely consume milk or egg-based foods or beverages, I just had to taste it. It was very smooth with just the right amount of bite.

I would definitey purchase this again.

I’m trying to find a bottle that tastes just like standard egg nog, but has an alcoholic kick. This is NOT that, but it’s a great holiday drink, regardless. It tastes like my mom’s molasses cookies, liquified into a perfect, creamy drink.

I tried to down a whole glass; that was a mistake. It’s so rich and filling, you only really need a few ounces.

I literally wait every year for this stuff to come out the only thing I drink now a days besides wine. I buy them and stock up every year. My freezer usually has a shelf full.

This is a bottle of deliciousness. This drink is confirmation the holidays are around the corner.

Fantastic! Shipped quick. Was received very happily and excitedly! Most unique gift!

So glad Nocella is back in stock. My favorite liquor

It was a gift for a friend. He was thrilled .

Tried this for the first time cuz I love eggnog as a creamer/flavor for my coffer. This product worked perfectly for it. I mixed it w/a little milk and frothed it in my coffee machine, sprinkled it w/nutmeg.

AWESOME!.

I bought this for our Christmas Eve party. We lined the rim of the glasses with crushed peppermint. It really complimented the nog. Everyone loved it!

I bought this while looking for another brand, which the store did not have. It was FANTASTIC! The price was so reasonable, too. This is my new favorite alcohol egg nog!

Tuaca is very sweet. It says it’s based on a brandy, but it’s good to know that it’s classified as a cordial. It’s probably a little too sweet for most if you drink it straight, BUT, it’s a fantastic drink to mix with other brandies.

Mix this with something cheaper but unexciting and they’ll each take the edge off the other to produce a smooth sweet-but-not-too-sweet brandy drink that just slays. And saves you money. Find the balance that works for you.

Or drink it straight if you’re lucky enough to still have that sugar tolerance as an adult. If you love caramel or butterscotch candies, you will ADORE this. If not, a little splash of this can bring a cheaper brandy to life, and last you a long time for a very reasonable price.

Very tasty!! Have bought this many times over the years. I love to make mixed drinks or serve a bit of a nip up straight as an after dinner sipper. Super nice in warm, wintery drinks. This past Thanksgiving I added a bit to the pumpkin pies.

It was a bit lost after the actual cooking. I suggest adding it to the whipping cream. YUMMO! Cheers!.