20 Best Leather Sandals For Women (2023 Updated)

I have collapsing arches and now refuse to buy shoes that don’t have proper arch support. I had two weddings to go to, as well as other wedding-related events and got this one pair of shoes for all of them.

They not only match everything I could think to wear but are extremely comfortable and have arch support?!?? something I never thought I’d find in a heel. They are expensive – I had originally gotten a cheaper version from Naturalizer but they didn’t come in in time so had to rush order these- wouldn’t have been my first choice due to the price but I’m happy none the less.

I wore them to all the events in a row without breaking them in and found them to be perfectly comfortable. Everyone else was taking off their heels after a few hours and I was able to keep mine on to keep dancing into the early morning.

Will be wearing again. PS: I have narrow feet and these fit well.

I purchased this shoe in nude for a Spring bridal shower. I have to say this shoe is very comfortable. It runs true to size though the front strap runs narrow. It’s a little tight for your first few wears.

The leather strap breaks in well and loosens up. I recommend ordering a wide if the are of your foot (where the strap sits) is wide. The shoe has great arch support and the foot bed is very cushiony.

The heel is a great height making it very easy to walk table without feeling wobbly. I received many compliments on this shoe. It’s both sexy & comfortable. I was able to stand the entire shower without wanting to kick my shoes off.

Thank you Naturalizer for making a shoe that is so pretty and super comfortable.

I could not recommend these enough! At first I was skeptical, because I am very prone to pain along the ball of my foot. I decided to trust the reviews and I am glad I purchased these. I originally bought a medium width, but returned for the wide width.

I was able to wear these shoes for a wedding (about 7 hours total of walking and dancing). My toes had some very mild pain at the end, but that was from general foot swelling at the end of the day – nothing the shoes would be at fault for.

Overall, these were very comfortable and I did not feel pain at the end of the night. Once I took them off and was standing, the bottom of my feet didn’t feel like they were wearing heels the entire night.

Highly recommend!.

Expected these to be comfy based on reviews and CH reputation. They are not. Would not recommend for prolonged walking or standing. PROS: good quality leather. CONS: insufficient heel padding.

I love these! They are super comfortable and fit me great. I am usually a 7 in Cole Haan and that is what I got. Perfect fit, good/moderate padding, and very classic style. Can dress up or down.

These are cushioned nicely and the leather strap in the back is not rigid so it doesn’t hurt your ankle. I have narrow feet and my foot slides forward a bit when walking fast. They run a tiny bit large so i think a half size down would be a tighter fit.

Overall i still like them and don’t think it’ll bother me.

The quality of these shoes has taken a nosedive. I had purchased these shoes on multiple occasions over the years, and I had nothing but good things to say. The first thing I noticed when I repurchased the black pair in June was that the black dye bled all over my foot every time I wore the shoes.

My toes would be stained black for days after wearing. Even if I could overlook this flaw, the strap had completely come unglue by August (3 months). I contacted Steve Madden to alert them of their product’s defect, and their customer service was equally as trash.

I was told twice that there was nothing they could do because it was outside of their 60-day return policy. When I pointed out they had breached its implied warranty of merchantability (essentially a seller promises that the good it sells is fit for the ordinary purposes for which it is originally intended to be used).

They refused to do anything. So, FYI–Steve Madden intends its shoes only intending them to last for 60 days–which tracks with the quality of these particular shoes. If I could give these zero stars, I would.

I ordered these sandals online because I had a previous good experience with this model but could not find it in stores. I am disappointed for two reasons. First, this pair seems less well mad than my previous pair.

The sandals are not well finished; they have rough edges and mediocre stitching. Second, the online purchase experience was awful. The company said that they had shipped the black sandals I ordered–even showed a picture of them–but in fact shipped brown sandals.

I had to get my daughter to intervene in order to get a prepaid shipping label for returning the brown sandals and in order to make sure that I got credit for the previous purchase (so that I would not be charged again when the correct sandals were finally shipped).

Steve Madden is one of my favorite brands. Especially his Freebird by Steven line. These boots and shoes have become an illness, and it’s not good for my marriage or my bank account. The Freebirds are beautiful! Each pair has been handmade in Mexico, in a small factory that has been making high quality boots for nearly a hundred years.

I have several pair of Freebirds and many more Steve Maddens. Did you know he got started selling shoes out of the trunk of his car? He also did 5 years on prison for tax evasion. So I know he’s my kinda guy lol #freebirdbysteven #boots #autumnfatale #vocbox.

I was positive these would be perfect, as all previous TB purchases have been, and the look, style, color, and quality of materials did not disappoint. I had ordered these for a trip so I barely tried them on, packed them, and went to the airport.

After excitedly putting them on for a day at an art museum, by the end of the morning my feet were sliding out constantly because they were too large (significantly), and I am consistently a 9 in TB and every other brand.

Additionally there is some kind of sharp stitching or edges on the underside of the logo that was cutting into the tops of my feet. It was so disappointing! They are a gorgeous gold! And very comfortable otherwise! But since I had now worn them it was not going to be possible to return.

After the trip I sold the size 9s (at a loss) and bought 8. 5, which fit great. They also have the sharp underside, but I was able to file the edges down and now they are comfortable. I totally love them as I love all things TB, so it was a surprise to have any issue ever.

Sad that I lost $120 in the sale of size 9, but I don’t live anywhere near a store and I should have worn them around the house longer before the trip. The Miller is still a lover. Truly, I would buy them in every color! :).

The new style with extra padding is way more comfortable. I also love that the leather has a bit more protection (hence the shine). I think it’s awesome that reviews are actually read, data collected, and adjustments made to the new styles based on customer feedback.

My first pair of Tory sandals were a gift. The OG style in a nude color. But the first week of wearing them my mailroom flooded, and my shoes were just done after that. I didn’t get to enjoy them for very long and there was nothing I could do to fix them.

So, I went out a bought these new style sandals, and while I love them, they’re super comfortable and cute, they’re just too wide. I know the padding and width adjustments were made based on feedback, but I feel like they went just a little too wide.

I would exchange if they had the new style is a narrow size, but sadly they don’t. I also though about getting the OGs, because those were my absolute fav, but they just don’t last or hold up again weather.

And I live in Florida, so it’s just always a struggle to keep them dry.

I was just about to give up on Tory Burch shoes because I’ve bought several pairs and not one pair is comfortable and they’re painful to walk in and leave blisters. I’ve bought the Bombé heels, Bombé slippers, Miller Jewels sandals, Rope heels, Rope slides and Basket Weave Clogs.

PAINFUL SHOES! I was done after having thousands of dollars of TB shoes that hurt to walk in but then I seen the Miller Clouds in black/natural that’s in my favorites list was on sale and they looked like they may be comfortable and the reviews said they was comfortable so I bit the bullet and ordered them.

Glad I did! I finally found a pair I can actually wear and not have to soak my feet afterwards and apply bandaids. They mold to my feet. The sides come up just slightly and enough to like cradle my foot.

The logo doesn’t rub and hurt my feet. I can HONESTLY say, they’re COMFORTABLE! I’ve read a lot of reviews for shoes I’ve bought that say comfortable and they’re not but the Clouds are! First pair of TB shoes that I recommend.

:).

I wanted a new pair of simple and cute heels for my company’s party. I have a hard time finding heels that fit me and I am able to walk in. I spent probably two hours at the store trying on the same handful of shoes multiple times to look for durability and comfort.

I noticed that these shoes came in a wide size. Most heels are made for narrow feet and that’s caused a lot of discomfort for me. Didn’t seem like a big difference but I felt the difference trying on the regular size versus the wide size.

My feet were killing me at the end of the night but this was due to the party people forcing me to keep dancing. Overall, I loved how cute and elegant these shoes were and they fit my foot very well.

I was able to walk around with no issues and dance in them relatively well. I do wish that they made wide sizes in other colors, the black shoes were a great choice but I had my heart on the iridescent color.

Either way, the shoe was a great choice!.

I bought this shoe a month ago for a wedding – super last minute. I got my standard size and they seemed to fit perfectly when I first tried them on. After about hour 1 on my feet I noticed the problem.

The first strap hits at a weird point on me, painfully cramping up my pinky toes, so I spent the next few hours occasionally leaving them hanging out of the strap (weird, I know, but it got the job done).

By hour 4 I was almost in tears, and ended up taking them off. I don’t consider myself as having a wide foot by any means, so these definitely run a bit narrow. Overall they’re dummy cute, just not something you’d want to wear if you’re going to be on your feet more than a few hours.

I’ll be looking for another pair that are hopefully just as hot and not as painful.

I absolutely LOVE this pair of heels. By far, one of the most comfortable pairs of heels that I’ve ever worn. I needed them for a wedding that I was in, so you can imagine the amount of running around I was doing in them all day.

I was able to wear these for almost 8 hours before succumbing to bare feet. I had to walk down a grass aisle, and the width of these provided solid support on the ground. These are very true to size.

The only comment about the fit I can provide is that because of the middle strap they do seem to fit slightly more narrow than usual. The only reason I gave these shoes a 4-star is because I noticed that the material that your foot goes on top of (where the brand is) is starting to peel away slightly from the heel, and this is only after wearing one time.

I typically wear an 8. 5 and ordered an 8. 5. The sandals fit perfectly, and the color was a true cognac color, vs. brown like some of the earlier reviews had complained about (I wonder if they adjusted the color with later design releases?).

They felt comfortable with some cushioning. For me, however, I could not get past the clacking sound they made as I walked, and the feeling of having to slow down my walking because they’re obviously mules-type sandals vs.

strappy sandals. It was louder and more pronounced than my Reef flip flops. So while it’s a gorgeous shoe and I think would go with SO much, I decided to send them back because I knew I would not end up wearing them.

If you’re debating buying them, I say go for it! I’ll give a huge shoutout here to Tuckernuck’s shipping & return policy, and how seamless it was from order to refund. I’d never purchased from Tnuck before, and I will *definitely* be buying again, because of how fantastic an experience it was.

I ordered these shoes 10 am 3/20; they shipped 3/21 12 pm; I received them 3/24 (earlier than expected); I returned them 3/24 (dropped them off for shipping in my apartment mailing center); received the refund confirmation email on 3/25; the funds posted to my credit card on 3/26.

So, in less than a week, I ordered, tried on, returned, & received a refund. This was hands-down the best online shopping experience I’ve had, and I’ve been doing a lot of online shopping recently!! So, Tuckernuck experience: 5 star (more stars if I could!).

Shoes themselves: 3 star. Total rating: 4 star.

I am a huge fan of the cotton modal line. I have a bubble butt and the regular Knix stretch out too much over time and give me a wedgie, but the cotton modal line does not. I was very excited to see this new full coverage version added to the line! Compared to the regular super leakproof cotton modal, I find the rise is a bit higher, the fit is overall a tad looser (not enough for me to want to size down from my regular size), and the butt coverage is a bit skimpier.

The gusset appears to be a bit longer on these, which means there’s less fabric along the bottom of the cheeks. They borderline wedgie me while walking, but don’t (and trust me. almost EVERYTHING becomes a wedgie on me due to my booty and major anterior pelvic tilt).

Next, I would love to see Knix come out with a lighter protection version in the cotton modal line. like a step between the super leakproof and everyday versions that could replace a panty liner.

Love these shoes! Good quality leather and glad to replace my old slides that I had. I will say definitely size up half a size. I would say I have medium width feet and usually am an 8-8. 5 depending on the shoe width.

I did order the the 8. 5 and they fit but just rubbed weird when I walked around the house. I have high arches and ordered the size 9 and the extra height was perfect for my feet. I think width size I could be comfortable in both but if you like me are not flat footed best to size up half a size.

I purchased these in three different colors in store in order to get the perfect fit. The sales associate ( Mellisa) was very professional and helpful. My usual size 6 1/2 fit perfectly. For a 4 inch high heel , it is extremely comfortable.

I wear these casually on weekends with short skirts , cute capris , as well as jeans. They really give my leg muscles great definition. I recently wore them while on a date and actually played miniature golf with no problems.

Super comfortable ! I should mention that my financial office job has a mandatory 4 inch high heel and skirt business suit dress code. I’m sure this helps with me being able to wear high heels casually.

Thank you Dillards ! You never fail me ! Lol.

These are the most uncomfortable heel I have ever owned. I bought these ahead of wedding season but there is no way I’m wearing them to another event. I wore them to a rehearsal dinner (which involves a decent amount of sitting) and two hours in, my feet were so swollen and painful that I absolutely had to leave and change into a different pair of shoes.

I changed into a well-worn, comfortable pair of heels and my feel were almost too swollen to get them on. Yes, I wore the Sam Edelman’s around the house on a couple of occasions to break them in ahead of time.

I’m 5’2” so I wear heels pretty much all of the time – often tall ones. I can walk 3 miles home in 4-5” wooden platform heels and barely blink an eye, but these shoes were absolute torture. A huge waste of money.

I have narrow, large (size 10) feet and always have trouble finding heels to wear to weddings/dressy events. I just went to a double wedding weekend and these shoes (brand new) were so comfortable I could dance the night away, two nights in a row! They aren’t too high and provide good ankle support with the strap.

I’m debating buying a second pair in another color. Highly recommend!!!.

I don’t know how it happened — I wasn’t even looking at shoes — but I ran across Elf on Etsy. I was instantly in love. ‘Are there other shoes like this? Other makers?’ No, there wasn’t, and I’m a master searcher.

If you need me to scour the inter webs for anything, I’m your girl. I decided the Elf website was my best source for information and selection. ‘Obsession’ is an understatement. This lower-middle-class school secretary had to have a beautiful pair of these sandals for the remainder of the summer.

To wear every day, with everything, for everything, eventually into the ground. But which? Once I received my beautiful sandals — so excited! so cute! so comfortable! right out of the box! – I have, indeed, worn them every day, with everything, for work, for leisure,.

I almost forget to take them off for bed. I wish I could kiss the forehead of whoever crafted these beauties with their own hands. I do truly appreciate the workmanship. Thank goodness the obsession is over, because I have, wear, enjoy my sandals, and am endlessly complimented on them.

I mean, I need move on, to think about other things. It IS almost fall in Wisconsin, though. I will have to put real shoes on my feet. I received a timely email from Elf: Oh, the gorgeous throwbacks: some classic oxford, some artfully feminine.

The loafers. The booties. In all the colors. They are a bit pricier than the sandals, obviously, due more leather and more craftsmanship. But, which?.

I was very happy to receive these well made and perfectly fitting sandals. The care that went into making these sandals really shows. They feel like they’re custom made. They did leak some stain from the dyed leather but they stop that and look great after you break them in.

I absolutely love these sandals and appreciate their comfort and hand made beauty. The packaging was very nice and all the extra bits of love with no waste accessories were so thoughtful and cool. Thank you : ).

Just received these and was so excited they fit perfectly. I’m a size 8 and ordered an 8. No extra give though so consider sizing up if you have a wider or flat foot. Very well made and comfortable, however note no cushion.

I wanted them for a vacation but they took their time and after contacting customer service they said were made to order so it will be extra time which I’m fine with. The vintage brown is not vintage.

It’s more of a burgundy brown but I read a previous review who mentioned this so I was somewhat expecting this, which is fine. Prepare to wait about 4 weeks. But all in all, love them!.

The smell of the material or leather dye on the tan shoes is pretty horrible. I put them in my closet and the entire closet smelled like a chemical for 2 days after I removed the shoes. I put them on my covered front porch for a day to air them out and in all it took a solid week for the smell to dissipate.

The fit is extremely comfortable for my wide feet, so I wanted to do what I could to make them work. Wore them for the first time yesterday and they are wonderful!.

I wear an 11 extra wide normally and have flat feet. I ordered three different styles of Propet and they were very long. With this brand I actually fit into the 10 extra wide perfectly. I love the adjustable heel strap.

Since my feet are in proper alignment, I had to adjust to the arch support which I am not accustom to having. I ordered two other styles. I placed an order had it delivered to DSW and tried them on there, hassel free returns and reordered the smaller size.

I bought these in a wide with, and have purchased wide with shoes from this company before, and been very satisfied, but not this time. the foot bed on the shoe is too narrow. It is very uncomfortable for me since I have bunions.

Otherwise the shoes live up to what I expected.

I love the overall appearance of these shoes. They look good on my foot and they are very comfortable except for the ankle strap. I put the shoe on and it fit very well and I went to buckle the strap and it immediately rubbed my ankle.

Could be just where my ankle sits but I am concerned that it could cause a blister. If I can figure out a way to protect my ankle I will keep them.

I bought this product last year in two colors and they were the perfect shoe for my feet which have a wide toe box and smaller ankle. When they started clearing out this season, I immediately ordered two new colors (anthracite and navy blue suede).

I was surprised when they rubbed on my toe box, so I checked the inside and realized that my old ones specify the lining is leather as is stated in the current listing, but the new ones only say the outer is leather.

The lining is now manmade. This makes a huge difference in the quality and feel, and I’m disappointed that they went cheaper and the description has the wrong information. I can only hope the cheap lining eventually breaks in, but it’s really too bad I have to suffer until that happens when the leather lined ones had no break in needed.

Still a pretty shoe with nice leather on the outside.

The sandals are beautiful. Soft leather and comfortable. Unfortunately they were just a little too big and I know with time the leather would stretch further. I should have ordered a half size smaller, which would have been my usual size, so I returned them.

To start, these shoes are very cute and came in good condition. However, the first pair I ordered I ordered one size down from my normal boot size, per the reviews. This proved to still be comically too big on me, as the shoe went in my foot, but there was about 1.

5 inches of footbed that went past my toes. I returned the first pair, and because I was so in love with the sandals. I ordered a second pair before I had even shipped my first pair out, in the next size down.

The second pair arrived and the length of the footbed was absolutely perfect, however this is the only positive thing I can say about the fit. The leather straps around the top (the three non adjustable ones) are dramatically too small.

I wear a normal width shoe in every other brand, and in other shoes from this brand even, but trying to get my foot past those bands was like trying to shove a square block in a circle hole. I took the shoes to be professionally stretched not once, not twice, but three times, and now they semi-fit onto my foot, but are still uncomfortable.

At this point there’s no way to return them, so it’s either keep trying to stretch them or try to sell them online. If you don’t have what would be considered a “narrow” foot, I’d recommend maybe trying a different sandal, because these are more uncomfortable and more work than they’re worth.

Upon opening, you can tell the shoe is very good quality. But unfortunately the straps and buckle constantly dig into the foot, making it incredibly uncomfortable. I went for walks to break them in before going to a festival in them.

Even after 3 1 hour walks the leather was still pretty stiff but I decided to wear them anyways because they’re pretty dang cute. After 5 hours of being at a festival, I had huge blisters on 3 areas of each foot, and the leather gashed into my ankles, heels and toes and I was bleeding/blistered so badly I couldn’t wear them the next day after leaving.

I was wearing a dress so it’s not like I was jumping around being crazy. Very disappointing. but I thought that may have finally ‘broke them in’. Pro is they did get dirt on them which completely was able to be wiped off with some water.

Fast forward a month later my feet are finally not peeling and healed I decide to wear this pair out for a summer date night. Again, really painful experience. I have small feet, they fit fine but the leather is just so harsh, I couldn’t wait to take them off.

Just sucks because they’re really cute.

I truly love these boots, both for the mono black color through out, and the platform. The boot feels fairly lightweight without being too heavy on the foot. Bonus is that there is both a zipper and adjustable laces for easy on and off.

I am usually between a size 6. 5-7 and based off reviews sized down to the 6, would recommend sizing down if in between sizes. Overall a great boot! One not so great thing to be aware about: I did feel that due to the vegan (synthetic) material, they are tougher to break in then the real leather.

I got these mid-September with summer temperatures and wore with thin ankle socks. Whoops, that was a mistake. The very top rim of the shoe chaffed my skin and essentially cut my lower calf (enough for scabs to end up developing).

I also think I left them a little too loose one day (with thin socks on) and got a blister on the back of my heel while walking. Biggest recommendation is wearing THICK socks and/or having the boots over pants/leggings/jeans when breaking them in! Lucky we are in the colder months so it should be easier to do so.

No matter what I’ll write now, it won’t do Botond’s work justice. These sandals are the greatest thing I ever put on my feet – even though I’ve been wearing barefoot shoes for more than 2. 5 years. They take the shoe game to the next level.

The fit, the flexibility of not only the sole but the entire sandal with all the possible adjustments, the softness of the leather, the comfort, the quality of it altogether. I’ve worn them several times now and I love them so much! \nBotond was a dream to work with and helped me figure out what I need: customised sandals and I am so satisfied with the entire process, the communication and the final result.

\nThank you so so much, Botond, I am so grateful for your time, patience and brilliant work. Can’t wait to order again. 15 out of 10 possible points.

I couldn’t be happier with these! I have extra wide, pizza slice shaped feet, and they custom made them, cutting down the pattern for a 42 to fit my size 40 foot, with the toe post perfectly placed for my foot.

It’s so hard to find shoes that fit my feet, let alone cute ones! The strap system means they also were a perfect fit for my high volume midfoot and narrow heel. I lived in these all summer. They dress up really nicely.

I live in sun dresses all summer, and a lot of barefoot shoes can end up looking a bit goofy. These were getting compliments from people who aren’t into barefoot shoes!.

The seller was in contact with me from the beginning. I was able to request color and a wider foot shape. He notified me when my package shipped, although I was unable to track it. Delivery required my signature.

Upon arrival I was very happy with the color, foot shape, and softness of the leather straps. I thought the laces would be a longer length, but maybe I had to request that? The fit of these sandals is a loose fit.

They are not tight/snug on your foot. I’ve grown to absolutely *love* these sandals and would highly recommend them!.

Listen to the poor reviews! I only read the first few “good” reviews, and completely regret this purchase. The “cork” footbed started peeling away when I removed the factory sticker for 1st use. Unfortunately, I was on a trip and didn’t have an alternate pair.

Sitting on deck at poolside for my son’s water polo tournament, the straps already started to look super dirty. Don’t know how that could happened, without actually walking near dirt. I’m too afraid to attempt to wash the straps, since other reviews say any contact with water will ruin the footbed further.

Customer service took a week to respond, and didn’t even address my complaint, only offering a return for “unworn” sandals. I haven’t purchased from Reef in a few years, and will likely avoid ordering from here ever again.

Do not buy!.

I bought a pair of basic vistas a few years ago and have basically worn them exclusively each summer. They’re so versatile, comfy and supportive, I’m completely addicted. I bought this slightly different version this year and they are nearly as perfect.

Although the cork footbed is cute and comfortable, they get dirty easily. My summer feet are definitely dirty sometimes! But still, really good shoes and worth the price.

Maybe someone knows how to clean these but I’ve worn many pairs of reefs and these are by far the most annoying! Initially they fit weird, pushing your feet inward. Once you realize this it takes about a week to form fit them to your feet.

They hurt my feet. Once they form fit they are great however, they get dirty quick and make your feet smell. If someone knows a great way to clean cork bottom sandals please advise. It’s too bad.

This sandal is gorgeous and it goes well with so many outfits and for various occasions! However, I have a few “cons” that really do not make these sandals worth the price. First, after the first time I wore the sandals (for a total of about 8 hours–only walking/on feet for about 3 hours of those).

the front of the sandal was already scratched/color scraped off (minor but definitely noticeable). Like I said, it is not as if I was walking/running in these sandals for hours all day or for a great distance.

Second, the top of the sandal does get uncomfortable and fit tight around the top of the foot, especially after wearing it for more than an hour or two. It may be better for those with very small/narrow feet.

The rest of the sandal (footbed, cushioning and the front part between the toes) was comfortable and my heel was not hurting at all. But like I said, I would have preferred to pay this amount for a more comfortable and durable sandal.

Caveat – I think all the Naturalizers I’ve bought in recent years run a bit small; hence I size up. 5 and then they work. This review reflects said size adjustment. I love a strappy block heel sandal and live where sandals are apropos 90% of the year.

I ordered these in bronze and while a bit darker than my ideal, it is a good muted metallic. I’ve now ordered both Black and Tan to finish out my sandal wardrobe for the coming spring and anticipate being equally happy with both other colors.

This sandal will work with dress pants, shorts or spring dresses; it’s very versatile in its styling. Straps offer nice support and footbed is adequately padded for a thin-soled sandal.

I wore these to a wedding that I attended this past weekend. They are so comfortable and I danced all night! I fluctuate between a 9 and 9. 5 wide shoe size. After trying several sizes I ended up with a 9 medium in the silver (the wides were too big and falling off).

The silver color is beautiful and sparkling, perfect for an evening event. I wear custom orthotics for a Mortons neuroma and I also have a tailors bunion so shoe shopping had become more difficult but these fit the bill and I’m planning on wearing them to another event next fall.

Definitely planning on shopping naturalizer more in the future ! If you are hesitant bc you haven’t been wearing heels die to foot pain, go for it and try these, you will not be disappointed.

I spent a lot of time and effort searching for sparkly sandals for my son’s wedding. These looked great and had good reviews. After walking around on the living room carpet, I thought they would be comfortable too.

Unfortunately, they turned out to be the least comfortable shoes I have ever worn. I barely made it through the short service and had to swap out shoes early on. What a shame. I had hoped to wear these on several occasions, but will never wear them again.

(Paid $40 more than they cost now, too. ).

I gave up wearing my jack Rogers as they weren’t supportive or comfortable to wear for any length of time or walk any distance. I hesitantly ordered the Comfort Jacks knowing Jack Rogers in general can run small and narrow, but these I would say are just a “tad” narrow but comfortably fit my wide feet and a “tad” small which is actually my perfect size ! I have walked in NYC in these and they were comfortable! They are the usual Jack Rogers stylish but supportive and comfortable now!! I bought multiple pairs after my first test pair and am throwing away my last years another brand that were comfortable but not nearly as stylish.

I have recommended to numerous friends I have been so thrilled with them. Please make more COMFORT JACK styles and patterns!.

I had high hopes for these sandals. They are cute on and are molded to your feet with arch support but calling them “comfort” is misleading. Yes, they are more comfortable than Jack’s regular sandals that are flat with no support, but these are NOT padded in any way and feel hard walking in them.

I expected some padding. I cannot see how I would be able to wear these walking around all day. Also, the description says they run small. I am a 6/12 with most shoes so I ordered a 7. I wish I had ordered the 6 1/2.

They are not big, but I could have ordered my normal size. I would return them, but they are final sale so I cannot return. Very disappointed with this purchase.

This is my second review (first is on the navy), but since I now have 4 pair in two different sizes, I wanted to provide an update. I am normally a true 9W, and ordered my first two pair in a 10, based on other reviews.

They absolutely worked for my wide feet, particularly after I broke them in. I also wet the leather as a break-in method and wore them until they dried. They are super comfortable. I came back for 2 more because of the holiday sale and got a 9.

5. These are just as great. Bottom line if you have a wide foot they will absolutely work, and highly recommend wetting the leather and wearing until they dry to break them in. I also recommend only going up 1/2 size, rather than a full size.

Beautiful perfect dainty dress up or down shoe. But that strap over the toe honeeeyy. I will be taking to a shoe shop for them to stretch. I have been working on it myself, wearing them around the house and using my hands to stretch and I do notice a difference but not big enough.

I couldn’t dare imagine wearing them for an evening or an event, I wouldn’t make it! I recommend sizing a whole size up as I do with all European shoes.

The other reviews are right, the strap across the toe is very tight BUT if you can find a shoe repair store they can stretch the strap out for you. I was able to have the straps stretched for $10 and now the shoes are so much more comfortable.

It’s crazy how this shoe is called the ‘stretch sandal’ but absolutely nothing on the shoe stretches. Would’ve been a perfect shoe if the toe strap was stretchy.

Adore the look of these shoes, but unlike almost all other Bottega shoes, these were very uncomfortable. The strap across the foot is not quite wide enough – it really cuts into the foot, and I don’t have particularly wide feet.

Probably okay for narrow feet, but not sure. Had the same issue with the other similar pair of Bottega sandals. Returned right away.

These shoes are super narrow in the toe area. I ordered half size bigger and that didn’t help. The length was ok and probably runs true to size but the width makes the foot look squeezed even when with the fact that I don’t toe bunion.

Not sure how narrow the foot has to be for this shoe to look nice. Didn’t even try to stand up to see whether it’s comfortable or not.

My sandals are beautiful; I purchased them to wear on my wedding day. I love Bali ELF’s product and I love even more their mission; I could wear these shoes with confidence knowing they treated their employees fairly.

I also loved that my shoes came with two bracelets made from scrap leather; it is so nice knowing as little as possible goes to waste. I gave these bracelets to my bridesmaids and it was a perfect opportunity to give them something special.

And fit was true to size for me (sz 6). If you want something unique, I wouldn’t hesitate. They seem like they’ll last well, too. Just a very nice pair of leather sandals. They are just as described in fit, color, and quality, and arrived on time, too.

I was relieved, as they are quite a bit more than I usually spend on shoes. But I’d say it was worth it.

Very comfortable and go well with casual as well as more formal clothes, I can easily wear them to work since the toes are closed. The leather gives in a bit once you wear, they were a bit tight when first arrived but now fit perfectly so they are true to size.

Quality is amazing. True leather buttery soft. Just beautiful. Unfortunatly for me the leather straps fit were too loose and did not hold snug to my feet. My feet/foot kept lifting as I attempted to walk.

My normal size is 6 too bad they don’t come in 5 1/2 I would have tried that. Sadly had to return :(. Dont let my experience stop you from giving these sandals are try 🙂 Simply just did not work for me.

PS. Could not upload photos due to the uploading feature not functioning. Good Luck! M.

Just received and am glad I did! Really cute!! Can wear anywhere from 8-9. I normally wear 8. 5 in flats but went by the Euro size. glad I did. They just fit. Glad for the adjustable 2nd strap. I have a high in step and put it on the last hole.

I have authentic Valentino heels and the studs are very simular. May just purchase the tan!.

Hi I bought these shoes sandals two months ago they are super cute and super comfortable & seem very well-made…But unfortunately leather is pulling-away from base of shoe on the toe strap-ARGH!! I really love these sandals & they no longer have my size in stock (8) in black…(my foot is narrow/medium width so it has nothing to do w/me having a wide foot)… I don’t know what to do because I really love the sandals….