When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Italian Bakery New Jersey (2024 Updated)

If you're looking for some of the best Italian bakeries in New Jersey, then you're in the right place! There are plenty of delicious bakeries throughout the state, each offering their own unique specialties, from traditional cannoli to modern twists on classic sweets. Whether you're in the mood for something sweet or savory, there's sure to be an Italian bakery in New Jersey that will satisfy your cravings.

Before you make your final purchase decision, it's important to consider a few factors. First, think about your budget and the types of products you're interested in. Some bakeries may offer high-end or specialty items that come at a higher price point, while others may focus on more budget-friendly options. Additionally, be sure to take note of any dietary restrictions or preferences you may have, as not all bakeries offer gluten-free or vegan options.

Are you worried about missing out on your favorite Italian bakery treats during the pandemic? Many bakeries are now offering online ordering and delivery, so you can still indulge in your favorite sweets from the comfort of your own home. Plus, with so many bakeries to choose from throughout New Jersey, there's always something new to try. So, whether you're a longtime fan of Italian bakery treats, or just looking to explore some new flavors, be sure to check out the many amazing options available throughout the state.

10 Best Italian Bakery New Jersey

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
The product is ideal for sharing at gatherings, snacking, or as a gift.
2
This product is ideal as a holiday gift basket containing Italian biscotti cookies.
3
The Italian Cookies 2 LB Cookie Tray is ideal for sharing at parties, events, or as a gift.
4
The product is ideal for those wanting to display a unique and visually appealing map of the state of New Jersey.
5
Ideal for serving and cutting food while displaying state pride, with a convenient hanging option for wall display.
6
The product is ideal for making homemade pasta sauce with all natural ingredients and an authentic recipe.
7
The product is ideal for conveying a message of love, thoughtfulness, and care to someone located in New Jersey.
8
Ideal for adding rustic décor to any room with a coastal theme, featuring a unique metal and reclaimed wood design.
9
Ideal for serving and cutting food, especially for those who have a connection to or love for New Jersey.
10
Ideal for cutting dough into crescent shapes with precision and ease.
The product is ideal for sharing at gatherings, snacking, or as a gift.
This product is ideal as a holiday gift basket containing Italian biscotti cookies.
The Italian Cookies 2 LB Cookie Tray is ideal for sharing at parties, events, or as a gift.
The product is ideal for those wanting to display a unique and visually appealing map of the state of New Jersey.
Ideal for serving and cutting food while displaying state pride, with a convenient hanging option for wall display.
The product is ideal for making homemade pasta sauce with all natural ingredients and an authentic recipe.
The product is ideal for conveying a message of love, thoughtfulness, and care to someone located in New Jersey.
Ideal for adding rustic décor to any room with a coastal theme, featuring a unique metal and reclaimed wood design.
Ideal for serving and cutting food, especially for those who have a connection to or love for New Jersey.
Ideal for cutting dough into crescent shapes with precision and ease.

1. Italian Cookies 5 Lb Tray

Looking for a perfect gift for Christmas? Look no further than these delicious Italian butter cookies. These cookies are perfect for any occasion, but they make an especially great gift for the holiday season. The cookie tray is filled with an assortment of mouth-watering treats that are sure to please anyone's taste buds.

These Italian butter cookies are made with only the finest ingredients, ensuring that each bite is full of flavor. The cookies are baked to perfection, with a light and crispy texture that melts in your mouth. The assortment of cookies includes a variety of shapes and flavors, from classic sugar cookies to chocolate chip and more.

The cookie tray is beautifully presented, making it a great gift for friends, family, or coworkers. The tray is perfect for sharing at holiday parties or for enjoying with a cup of coffee or tea. No matter how you choose to enjoy them, these Italian butter cookies are sure to become a holiday favorite.

Pros

  • Made with only the finest ingredients
  • Assortment of shapes and flavors
  • Perfect for sharing at holiday parties
  • Beautifully presented

2. Italian Biscotti Gift Basket: Best Cookies Ever!

Indulge in the irresistible flavor and fragrance of anise with Cookies Outlet's Anisette Biscotti Cookies. These Italian cookies are carefully handmade with premium and natural ingredients to ensure the perfect crispiness and freshness that your taste buds will surely love. The 1lb Organic Biscotti Gift Basket contains approximately 17 cookies that are beautifully packed and ready to be delivered as a gift.

Cookies Outlet takes pride in their passion for baking and guarantees safe delivery of their products to your doorstep. These Anisette Biscotti Cookies are perfect for anytime snacking, whether as a treat to yourself or as a gift to your loved ones. Additionally, they are Kosher Certified/Dairy, making them an excellent choice for those with religious dietary restrictions.

If for any reason you are not satisfied with the freshness and taste of Cookies Outlet's Anisette Biscotti Cookies, the company offers a no-questions-asked refund to ensure your satisfaction.

Pros

  • Handmade with premium and natural ingredients
  • Beautifully packed and ready to be delivered as a gift
  • Kosher Certified/Dairy, suitable for those with religious dietary restrictions
  • Perfect for anytime snacking

3. Hand-Drawn Typography Map: New Jersey Print

Looking for a perfect gift for a New Jersey lover? Look no further than this customizable product! With the 'CUSTOMIZE' button above, you can select the SIZE and COLOR that suits your preference. This product is made with high-quality materials, specifically printed on Bright White 192gsm 10.3mil Enhanced Print Paper, with a Matte Finish. The print quality is top-notch, ensuring that the design looks crisp and vibrant. You can choose from a variety of sizes and colors to fit your decor or personal preference. If New Jersey is not your state, don't worry! This product is available for many other states in the joebstudio Amazon shop. With this unique and personalized product, you can show off your love for the Garden State in style!

Pros

  • Customizable size and color options
  • High-quality printing materials
  • Available for many other states

4. Bamboo Nj Cutting Board With Wall Mount

Celebrate the beauty of The Garden State with this stunning bamboo cutting board. The board is uniquely crafted into the shape of New Jersey, making it a fun and exciting addition to your kitchen. Measuring 8-5/8" x 16-5/8" x 5/8", this board features laser-engraved artwork that showcases the top towns and attractions in the state.

The included hang tie makes it easy to use this board as a decorative item. Hang it in your kitchen, dining room, den or office to show your love for New Jersey. When used as a serving board, it becomes a great conversation piece that your guests will surely admire. Flip the board over to the blank side and use it as a high-quality, knife-friendly bamboo cutting board.

This board is also an excellent gift for anyone who loves New Jersey. Perfect for birthdays, housewarmings, weddings or any holiday occasion, it is a thoughtful and unique present that will be cherished for years to come.

Pros

  • Unique New Jersey shape adds a fun and exciting touch to your kitchen
  • Laser-engraved artwork highlights the top towns and attractions in the state
  • Included hang tie allows you to use it as wall decor
  • Can be used as a conversation starter when used as a serving board
  • High-quality, knife-friendly bamboo cutting board

5. Classic Vegan Italian Tomato Sauce – 12 Pack

Experience the authentic Nona taste with The Original Jersey Italian Gravy. This simple, rustic tomato sauce is made with the finest ingredients available and will elevate any pasta dish into the equivalent of a fond childhood memory. With only five ingredients, including vine-ripened tomatoes, oil blend, onions, cane sugar, and salt, this pasta sauce is made in small, limited batches for total quality control.

All Jersey Italian Gravy sauces are slow-cooked in order to achieve their full, earthy flavor. Combine our tomato gravy with your favorite pasta dish or pizza and create iconic dishes for you and your family. Call them old-fashioned, but nothing compares to cooking like in the old times with ingredients that grow right in your garden, and our sauce abides by those rules-everything needs to be fresh. For our Italian gravy, we use exclusively fresh Tomatoes, with no tomato concentrate, puree, paste, preservatives, artificial flavors or spices-100% All-Natural, Organic & Vegan-Friendly.

Trust the tradition of Jersey Italian Gravy, sold in over 11,000 stores nationwide. In addition to the original gravy, Jersey Italian Gravy develops, manufactures, and distributes exclusive sauces for other major retailers and food companies such as Whole Foods, Stew Leonard’s, Food Town, Bed Bath and Beyond, and the La Fede food brands.

Pros

  • Made with the finest ingredients available
  • Uses only fresh tomatoes, with no artificial flavors or spices
  • Slow-cooked for full and earthy flavor
  • 100% All-Natural, Organic & Vegan-Friendly
  • Sold in over 11,000 stores nationwide

6. Someone In New Jersey Loves Me Thinking Of You Gift Moving Gift Ldr Gift Heart In New Jersey Gift

Experience the refreshing scent of the ocean with this Salt and Sea scented candle. Handmade in Astoria, Oregon, this 9 oz candle is the perfect holiday gift or anytime gift for your loved ones.

Crafted with care, this candle has an approximate burn time of 50 hours, ensuring that you can enjoy the soothing scent for a long time. Its size is perfect for any room, making it a versatile addition to your home decor.

Let the soft glow and calming aroma of this candle transport you to the serene shores of the sea. Order now and indulge in the ultimate relaxation experience.

Pros

  • Handmade with care in Astoria, Oregon
  • Refreshing scent of salt and sea
  • Approximate burn time of 50 hours
  • Versatile size perfect for any room
  • Ideal as a holiday or anytime gift

7. Jersey Shore Map Metal Print On Reclaimed Wood.

Add a rustic charm to your wall with this 11.5" x 17.5" metal print mounted on 13.5" x 19.5" eco-friendly reclaimed American barn wood. This metal art print is from an original work of art by an award-winning artist, ensuring that you are not buying a mass-produced product. By purchasing this print, you are supporting an independent working artist.

Printed and produced in the USA, this framed metal wall art uses 100% real steel and solid wood. No tin or cut-rate metal is ever used in its production. It is the absolute best you can get in terms of quality.

The materials used in the production of this rustic metal print are of the highest quality, including premium archival ink and heavy, 18-gauge aluminum. This ensures that the colors are intense, rich, and fade-free, staying true to the artist's vision and original artwork.

This first-class art and photography wall decor curates and provides art that honors and reflects the magnificent, beautiful, and distinctive locations that inspired it. When a place is special and worth celebrating, the art should be too.

Pros

  • Made from high-quality, eco-friendly materials
  • Printed and produced in the USA
  • Supports an independent working artist
  • Intense, rich, and fade-free colors

8. Totally Bamboo New Jersey State Shaped Bamboo Serving & Cutting Board

The Totally Bamboo New Jersey-shaped serving and cutting board is a fun addition to any kitchen. Measuring 15-1/4" x 10-1/4" x 5/8", this board is perfect for smaller food prep tasks and serving appetizers. The flat grain bamboo is not only beautiful, but also durable and easy on knives. Hand wash only and occasionally treat with Totally Bamboo's Revitalizing Mineral Oil to maintain its beauty and prolong its lifespan. The board comes with a hanging hole and tie, making it a great option for wall art and a perfect gift for anyone who loves New Jersey. Bamboo is an eco-friendly choice as it is a renewable resource that grows quickly and doesn't require clear cutting, artificial irrigation or replanting.

The Totally Bamboo New Jersey-shaped board is a versatile kitchen tool that can be used for both food prep and serving. Its eco-friendly bamboo construction and durable nature make it a great choice for those looking to reduce their environmental impact. The included hanging hole and tie make it a fun piece of wall art that can show off your state pride.

The Totally Bamboo New Jersey-shaped board is a must-have for any New Jersey resident or enthusiast. Its unique shape and eco-friendly bamboo construction make it a great conversation starter while its durability and versatility make it a useful kitchen tool. With proper care, this board will last for years to come.

Pros

  • Eco-friendly bamboo construction
  • Durable and easy on knives
  • Comes with a hanging hole and tie for wall art
  • Versatile for food prep and serving
  • Unique shape and conversation starter
  • A great gift for New Jersey residents or enthusiasts

Cons

  • – Hand wash only
  • – Requires occasional treatment with Revitalizing Mineral Oil

9. Ateco Stainless Steel Croissant Roller Cutter 15-Inches Long X 5-Inches Diameter

Baking croissants at home is now easier with the Rolling Croissant Cutter. This tool is designed to manually cut dough into consistent triangles to make perfect croissants. It features a stainless steel cutting area that revolves independently of a polypropylene handle. The cutter is efficient and effective, cutting six croissants per revolution. It cuts triangles with a 3.75-inch wide base and 8.25-inch height, ensuring uniformity in size and shape. This cutter is easy to use and clean, and hand washing is suggested to maintain its quality. The Rolling Croissant Cutter is manufactured by Ateco, a family-owned and operated company since 1905, known for producing professional quality and well-designed baking tools.

Making croissants from scratch can be a time-consuming process, but with the Rolling Croissant Cutter, the task becomes much simpler. This cutting tool allows bakers to produce uniform triangles of dough, ensuring that every croissant is the same size and shape. The stainless steel cutting area rotates independently of the handle, allowing for smooth and efficient cutting. It cuts six croissants per revolution, making it a quick and effective tool for large batches of croissants. The cutter produces triangles with a 3.75-inch wide base and 8.25-inch height, providing the perfect size for croissants. The polypropylene handle is comfortable to hold and easy to use, making it accessible for bakers of all levels. With the Rolling Croissant Cutter, bakers can achieve professional quality croissants in the comfort of their own kitchen.

The Rolling Croissant Cutter is a must-have tool for any baker who wants to make perfect croissants. It is designed to cut dough into triangles with a 3.75-inch wide base and 8.25-inch height, ensuring consistency in every croissant. The stainless steel cutting area rotates independently of the polypropylene handle, making it easy to use and efficient. It cuts six croissants per revolution, making it ideal for large batches. The cutter is easy to clean and maintain, and hand washing is suggested to ensure its quality. The Rolling Croissant Cutter is manufactured by Ateco, a family-owned and operated company since 1905, known for producing professional quality and well-designed baking tools. With this cutter, bakers can create perfect croissants every time, and impress their friends and family with their baking skills.

Pros

  • Efficient and effective way to manually cut dough into consistent triangles for croissants
  • Cuts six croissants per revolution
  • Stainless steel cutting area revolves independently of polypropylene handle
  • Produces triangles with a 3.75-inch wide base and 8.25-inch height, ensuring uniformity in size and shape
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Manufactured by Ateco, a family-owned and operated company since 1905, known for producing professional quality and well-designed baking tools

Cons

  • – Hand washing is suggested to maintain its quality

Best Italian Bakery New Jersey FAQs

Are there any Italian bakeries in New Jersey that offer gluten-free options?

Yes, there are several Italian bakeries in New Jersey that offer gluten-free options. Many of them have recognized the increasing demand for gluten-free products due to dietary restrictions or preferences. These bakeries have made efforts to cater to their customers by offering a variety of gluten-free options such as bread, cakes, pastries, and cookies. Some famous Italian bakeries that offer gluten-free options in New Jersey are Calandra's Bakery, Carlo's Bakery, and Vaccaro's Bakery. These bakeries are renowned for their traditional Italian baked goods and have expanded their offerings to include gluten-free products as well. They use high-quality ingredients and ensure that their gluten-free products are made in a separate kitchen to prevent cross-contamination. So, if you are in New Jersey and looking for some delicious Italian baked goods without gluten, you can visit any of these bakeries and enjoy a guilt-free treat.

What are the best Italian bakeries in New Jersey?

Italian bakeries are a staple in New Jersey's food scene, known for their delicious pastries, bread, and cakes. If you're looking for the best Italian bakeries in the state, there are a few that stand out from the rest.

One of the top Italian bakeries in New Jersey is Carlo's Bakery, located in Hoboken. This bakery gained national fame thanks to the TLC reality show "Cake Boss," and it's easy to see why. The bakery's cannoli, lobster tails, and cakes are all delicious, and the bakery's atmosphere is always buzzing with customers.

Another great Italian bakery in New Jersey is Vaccaro's Bakery in Clark. This family-owned bakery has been serving up authentic Italian baked goods since 1956, and their fresh bread, pastries, and cakes are all made from scratch daily.

A third option is Palazzone 1960 Bakery in Montclair. This bakery has been around for over 50 years and is known for its traditional Italian pastries and cakes, as well as their famous "pizza rustica" – a savory pie filled with prosciutto, cheese, and eggs.

No matter which Italian bakery you choose in New Jersey, you're sure to be treated to some of the best baked goods in the state.

What types of Italian breads are popular in New Jersey bakeries?

Italian bread is a staple in New Jersey bakeries, with a wide variety of options available to satisfy any craving. One of the most popular types of Italian bread in New Jersey is the classic crusty Italian bread, often used for sandwiches or dipped in olive oil. Another popular option is focaccia bread, which is typically topped with herbs and olive oil and is perfect for sandwiches or as a side to a meal. Ciabatta bread, with its soft and chewy texture, is another favorite among New Jersey residents, often used for paninis or toasted with butter. Additionally, semolina bread, made with a combination of wheat flour and semolina flour, is a popular option with a slightly sweet taste and a soft crumb. No matter what type of Italian bread you prefer, you're sure to find it at a New Jersey bakery, where fresh and delicious bread is always readily available.

Where can I find authentic Italian pastries in New Jersey?

If you're looking for authentic Italian pastries in New Jersey, you're in luck! The Garden State is home to a plethora of Italian bakeries that offer an array of delectable treats ranging from cannolis and sfogliatelle to tiramisu and biscotti. Some of the top Italian bakeries in New Jersey include Carlo's Bakery in Hoboken, operated by the famous "Cake Boss" Buddy Valastro, and Calandra's Bakery with locations in Newark, Fairfield, and Caldwell. Another great option is Pasticceria Bruno in Staten Island, just across the bridge from New Jersey. They offer a wide range of authentic Italian pastries and cakes that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Other notable bakeries include Giorgio's Pasticceria in Hoboken and Cafe Chameleon in Bloomingdale. So, whether you're in North Jersey or South Jersey, you're sure to find a delicious Italian pastry at one of these bakeries.

Which Italian bakery in New Jersey is known for its cannolis?

One of the most famous Italian bakeries in New Jersey that is renowned for its delicious cannolis is Carlo's Bakery. Established in 1910, Carlo's Bakery has been serving its customers with traditional Italian desserts and pastries for over a century. The bakery is located in Hoboken, New Jersey, and has expanded its business to other locations as well, including New York City and Las Vegas.

What sets Carlo's Bakery apart from other bakeries is their commitment to using quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques. Their cannolis, in particular, are made with a crispy shell and filled with a rich and creamy ricotta cheese filling, which is the perfect balance of sweet and savory flavors.

In addition to cannolis, Carlo's Bakery offers a wide range of other Italian pastries and desserts, including tiramisu, sfogliatelle, and biscotti, all of which are baked fresh daily. With its delectable treats and charming ambiance, Carlo's Bakery has become a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth in New Jersey.

Leave a Comment