When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Innerspring Mattress Consumer Reports (2025 Update)

If you’re looking for a new mattress and prefer the traditional feel of a coil-based support system, an innerspring mattress might be the right choice for you. However, with so many options on the market, it can be difficult to determine which one is truly the best. Before making a purchase, there are several factors to consider such as the level of firmness, coil count, and the quality of materials used in the construction.

One important factor to take into account when shopping for an innerspring mattress is the level of firmness. This can greatly affect the quality of your sleep and overall comfort. Additionally, you may want to look for one with a high coil count and quality materials such as natural latex and organic cotton to ensure durability and a good night’s rest.

If you’re still unsure about which innerspring mattress would be the best fit for your needs, consider asking yourself some of the following questions. Do you prefer a firm or softer mattress? Do you have any specific sleeping needs, such as back pain or sleep apnea? What is your budget for a new mattress? By answering these questions, you can narrow down your options and choose an innerspring mattress that will provide you with the best night’s sleep possible. And for more guidance, be sure to check out Consumer Reports to find the latest reviews and recommendations for the best innerspring mattresses on the market.

10 Best Innerspring Mattress Consumer Reports

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
This product is ideal for those seeking a comfortable and supportive mattress with individually wrapped pocketed coils.
2
This product is ideal for those in need of a high-quality, firm King-sized mattress with pillow top and memory foam layers.
3
This product is ideal for those looking for an affordable twin-sized innerspring mattress with a comfortable foam top.
4
The product is ideal for those looking for a plush and comfortable queen-sized mattress.
5
The product is ideal for those seeking medium-firm support and breathability in a queen-size memory foam mattress.
6
This product is ideal for comfortable and supportive sleep with a combination of gel memory foam and innerspring technology.
7
This mattress is ideal for comfortable sleep, with independently encased coils providing support and a reversible design for versatility.
8
This product is ideal for someone who wants a comfortable and affordable innerspring mattress that is easy to transport and set up.
9
The product is ideal for those seeking a comfortable and supportive mattress with a combination of memory foam and pocket springs.
10
Ideal for those who prefer a firm feel, need a twin-sized mattress, and want the convenience of a mattress in a box.
This product is ideal for those seeking a comfortable and supportive mattress with individually wrapped pocketed coils.
This product is ideal for those in need of a high-quality, firm King-sized mattress with pillow top and memory foam layers.
This product is ideal for those looking for an affordable twin-sized innerspring mattress with a comfortable foam top.
The product is ideal for those looking for a plush and comfortable queen-sized mattress.
The product is ideal for those seeking medium-firm support and breathability in a queen-size memory foam mattress.
This product is ideal for comfortable and supportive sleep with a combination of gel memory foam and innerspring technology.
This mattress is ideal for comfortable sleep, with independently encased coils providing support and a reversible design for versatility.
This product is ideal for someone who wants a comfortable and affordable innerspring mattress that is easy to transport and set up.
The product is ideal for those seeking a comfortable and supportive mattress with a combination of memory foam and pocket springs.
Ideal for those who prefer a firm feel, need a twin-sized mattress, and want the convenience of a mattress in a box.

1. Swiss Ortho Sleep Queen Plush Bamboo Mattress

Introducing a hassle-free mattress that will elevate your sleeping experience. The process of setting up this mattress is incredibly simple – just unbox it and watch it decompress. While the mattress decompresses on its own, it can be sped up by jumping, walking, and even sleeping on it. This allows you to enjoy a good night's sleep sooner rather than later.

The mattress is designed to provide optimal comfort and support, allowing you to wake up feeling refreshed and rejuvenated. It is made with high-quality materials that are both durable and long-lasting. The mattress is also available in various sizes, making it easy to find the perfect fit for your bed frame.

Additionally, this mattress is designed with your health in mind. It is hypoallergenic and made without harmful chemicals, ensuring that you can sleep soundly without any worries. The mattress is also easy to clean and maintain, making it a great investment for anyone looking for a comfortable and hygienic sleeping solution.

2. Ultimate Comfort King Hybrid Mattress With Pillow Top

Introducing the Jacia House 11.4 Inch Hybrid Mattress, the perfect combination of comfort, support, and durability. This king-size mattress measures 76'' W x 80''L x 11.4''H/193CM x 203CM x29CM and is made with a variety of high-quality materials to ensure a good night's sleep.

This hybrid mattress features a 1-inch pillow top layer, a 2.6-inch layer of memory foam plus high-density foam, and a 7.8-inch individually wrapped coil innerspring layer. The individually wrapped coil innerspring layer delivers enhanced comfort, outstanding support and provides equal weight distribution by contouring to the curves of your body, relieving pressure points and restlessness through motion isolation.

The pillow top is a combination of Belgian premium soft breathable knitted fabric cover, fireproof cotton felt, and high-density memory foam, providing a comfortable feel, natural touch, and high-quality sleep experience. The memory foam mattress is made of low VOC foam, free of PBDEs, TDCPP or TCEP ("Tris") flame retardants, ozone depletes, mercury, formaldehyde, lead, and heavy metals.

This pillow top mattress meets federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633 and is shipped compressed, rolled, and sealed in oxford cloth to arrive at your doorstep. Please allow up to 48-72 hours for the mattress to fully expand and for any potential odor to dissipate. Some other factors, such as cold weather, will affect the decompression time. It may take up to a week to expand under these circumstances. Please pull the ends of the mattress and clap it to let the air easily get in.

The Jacia House 11.4 Inch Hybrid Mattress comes with a 15-year limited warranty. If you have any problems with the mattress, please contact the manufacturer first, and they will try to solve the issue for you. The manufacturer is also willing to accept returns or exchanges if needed.

Invest in your sleep with the Jacia House 11.4 Inch Hybrid Mattress. It is a reliable and long-lasting choice that will provide you with the comfort and support you need for a good night's rest.

3. Bonnell Spring Twin Mattress With Comfort Foam Top

Introducing the Medium Firm Mattress, a perfect blend of comfort and support. This mattress is designed to cater to all your sleeping needs, providing you with a peaceful and restful sleep every night.

The top layer of the mattress is made up of high-density foam, providing a soft and comfortable sleeping surface. The foam conforms to your body shape, ensuring that every part of your body is supported equally. The layer is also designed to keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night.

The innerspring layer of the mattress provides excellent support and durability. The heavy-duty bonnell spring base ensures even and consistent support, preventing any sagging or sinking. This layer is also designed to reduce motion transfer, ensuring that you won't be disturbed by your partner's movements during the night.

The smooth woven jacquard fabric cover is not only stylish but also adds to the comfort of the mattress. The microfiber padding adds an extra layer of softness, making this mattress a dream to sleep on.

The CertiPUR-US certified foam used in this mattress meets the highest standards of content, performance, and durability. The foam is free from harmful chemicals and is safe for you and your family.

This mattress is also incredibly easy to set up. It comes in a bed-in-a-box package, delivered straight to your door. Simply unbox it, and it will expand to its full size within minutes.

The manufacturer provides a 10-year warranty, ensuring that you can enjoy this mattress for many years to come. With its premium quality materials and construction, you can rest easy knowing that you have made a sound investment.

4. Beautyrest Br800 12 Inch Plush Euro Top Mattress, Queen, Mattress Only

The 800 Series Beautyrest Pocketed Coil Technology is the ultimate in support systems for mattresses. It is considered to be the world's premier support system, providing exceptional comfort and durability. This technology ensures that each coil is individually wrapped, providing a higher level of support and reducing motion transfer. This means that you can enjoy a peaceful night's sleep without being disturbed by your partner's movements.

The Dual Control Technology of this mattress ensures that it remains fresh and cool, even on hot summer nights. It utilizes a combination of materials and design to create a cooling effect that helps regulate your body temperature. With this technology, you can sleep comfortably without worrying about overheating.

The Gel Memory Foam Lumbar Support adds an extra layer of support where you need it the most. This technology provides targeted support to your lower back, helping to reduce pain and discomfort. It also helps to align your spine, ensuring that you wake up feeling refreshed and energized.

This mattress is available in a Mattress Only style, making it easy to integrate into your existing bed frame. Its sleek and modern design will complement any decor, while its advanced technologies will provide you with a great night's sleep. Whether you are looking for comfort, support, or both, the 800 Series Beautyrest Pocketed Coil Technology mattress is the perfect choice for you. With its superior quality and advanced features, you can rest easy knowing that you are investing in the best possible sleep experience.

5. Ventilated Queen Memory Foam Bed: Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Introducing the Queen Size Soft Memory Foam Mattress, a premium quality mattress designed to provide exceptional comfort and support for a restful night's sleep. This 12-inch memory foam mattress is engineered with ventilated Suretemp memory foam, a soft knit cover, and a durable base layer to deliver pressure-relieving medium-firm support in any sleep position.

Experience cradling comfort like never before with this queen memory foam mattress. It offers cloud-like comfort for all sleep positions, providing complete support for your back and body, while maintaining proper alignment and a comfortable sleep temperature. Whether you are a stomach, back or side sleeper, you can find motion isolation, edge support, and breathable comfort with this eco-conscious Sleep Innovations memory foam bed.

All our memory foam mattresses, mattress toppers, and pillows are made in the USA and are hypoallergenic and CertiPUR-US certified. We use high-quality materials to deliver high-quality sleep to our customers. Our commitment to providing sound sleep is unwavering, and we continue to innovate with new foams and fabrics to deliver the best possible sleep experience.

At Sleep Innovations, we are committed to great sleep, and we take pride in the fact that we invented the memory foam bed in a box. We continue to deliver sleep restoration today with our innovative products. This queen bed mattress comes with a 10-year warranty, giving you peace of mind that your investment is protected for years to come.

Upgrade your sleep experience with the Queen Size Soft Memory Foam Mattress. It offers exceptional comfort and support for every sleeper and is designed to provide you with a restful night's sleep.

6. Vibe Hybrid Pillow Top Memory Foam Mattress.

Introducing the stunning sapphire blue euro pillow top mattress – a luxurious addition to any bedroom. Measuring 54 inches in width, 75 inches in length, and boasting a height of 12 inches, this mattress is not only beautiful but also functional.

The mattress has a medium-plush feel that provides superior comfort and support for a restful night's sleep. It is also adjustable base friendly, making it a versatile choice for those who require this feature. The 10-year warranty further ensures that the mattress is a long-term investment in comfort.

The gorgeous sapphire blue euro pillow top is a statement piece that adds an elegant touch to any bedroom decor. The beautifully detailed stretch knit quilted cover optimizes conforming properties, providing a soft and comfortable sleeping surface.

The individually wrapped innerspring coils are designed to provide orthopedic support, keeping the spine aligned while also preventing motion disturbance. This feature is especially beneficial for light sleepers who are easily awakened by movements during the night.

7. Signature Sleep Contour 8" Reversible Mattress, Independently Encased Coils, Bed-In-A-Box, Queen

Experience a peaceful and restful sleep with the 8-inch independently encased coil queen mattress, made in Italy and designed to provide comfort and support to your body. This mattress is perfect for those who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.

The mattress features a layer of high-density foam at the top and bottom, which offers a comfortable and embracing feel. The foam is made without harmful chemicals like PBDEs, TDCPP, or TCEP flame retardants, ozone depleters, mercury, lead, and heavy metals, making it safe for you and the environment. The foam is also low in VOC emissions for indoor air quality, ensuring that you breathe clean air while you sleep.

The 7-inch 15-gauge independently encased coils in the mattress provide excellent weight distribution by contouring to the curves of your body and relieving pressure points. This feature ensures that you have a restful and pain-free sleep, no matter what sleeping position you choose.

The mattress is reversible, giving you extra versatility. You can flip and rotate the mattress to even out the wear and extend its lifespan for years to come. This feature also ensures that you have a fresh sleeping surface every time you use it.

The queen mattress dimensions are 80"L x 60"W x 8"H, with a net weight of 69.5 lbs. The mattress ships rolled, compressed, and vacuum-sealed in an easy-to-handle box with shipping dimensions of 63"L x 13"W x 13"H and a gross weight of 82 lbs.

Please allow 24-72 hours for the mattress to regain its full shape after unpacking. The expansion time of the mattress may vary depending on the temperature of the room during unpacking. In colder temperatures, the mattress may take a bit longer to return to its full size from its compressed state.

The non-removable and non-washable cover of the mattress ensures that it stays clean and hygienic. You can enjoy a comfortable and healthy sleep every night with this high-quality, affordable, and durable queen mattress.

8. Zinus Spring Mattress: Certified Comfort-In-A-Box

The supportive traditional spring mattress is a must-have for anyone looking for a comfortable and durable sleeping experience. Designed with plush microfiber quilting, high-quality Viscolatex, and comfort foam layers, as well as durable steel innersprings, this mattress offers the perfect blend of conforming comfort and support for your spine and joints.

The comfort spring mattress is made with 1.75 inches of total durable high-density foam, 2 inches of conforming Viscolatex foam, and a 6-inch base layer of heavy-duty steel innersprings. This combination provides ample support with a hint of softness, making it an ideal choice for stomach sleepers and petite to average-weight individuals.

The highest quality foam used in this mattress is CertiPUR US Certified for durability, performance, and content, ensuring you get the best quality product possible.

The mattress is expertly packaged using the latest technology, allowing it to be efficiently compressed into one box that's easily shipped and maneuvered into your bedroom. Simply unbox, unroll and the mattress does the rest, expanding to its original shape within 72 hours.

Please note that the expansion time of the mattress will vary depending on the surrounding temperature. In warmer rooms, any memory foam will expand faster, while in colder temperatures, the mattress may take a bit longer to return to its full size from its compressed state.

The twin mattress can support a maximum weight of 250 lbs, while all other sizes can support up to 500 lbs. Additionally, the worry-free 10-year limited warranty ensures that you can enjoy your mattress for many years to come.

9. Olee Sleep 10 Inch Omega Hybrid Gel Infused Memory Foam And Pocket Spring Mattress (Queen)

The mattress set up is straightforward and hassle-free. Once the mattress is removed from the packaging, it will begin to decompress on its own. To expedite the process, users can jump, walk, or sleep on the mattress. This will help the mattress reach its full size and shape quicker, allowing users to enjoy a comfortable night's sleep sooner rather than later.

10. Linenspa Firm Foam Innerspring Twin Mattress

Looking for a durable and versatile mattress that provides consistent support and exceptional comfort? Look no further than this twin size mattress.

Featuring heavy gauge tempered steel coils, this mattress offers consistent support for back and stomach sleepers alike. The quilted fabric cover and deep foam layer provide added comfort, making it easy to get a good night's sleep.

Whether you're using it as a bunk bed mattress, day bed mattress, trundle bed mattress, or RV mattress, this versatile mattress is sure to provide the comfort and support you need. And with its firm profile, it's perfect for those who prefer a little extra support while they sleep.

But that's not all – this mattress is also incredibly easy to set up. Simply remove it from the box, and watch as it decompresses before your eyes. And because it can be used with a box spring, slatted frame, platform bed, or metal grid, it's easy to pick the frame that works best for your needs.

So why wait? Treat yourself to the comfort and support you deserve with this high-quality, affordably priced twin size mattress. With its compact size and easy installation process, it's the perfect choice for anyone looking for a great night's sleep.

Best Innerspring Mattress Consumer Reports FAQs

How do I compare different innerspring mattresses to find the best one for me?

When comparing innerspring mattresses, there are a few key factors to consider to find the best one for you. First, consider the number of coils in the mattress and their gauge. The more coils, the more support and durability the mattress will offer. A lower gauge number indicates thicker coils, which can also provide more support.

Next, look at the quality of the materials used in the mattress, including the padding and upholstery layers. High-quality materials will provide better comfort and durability.

Consider your own sleeping style and preferences as well. If you prefer a firmer mattress, look for one with a higher coil count and thicker gauge coils. If you prefer a softer mattress, look for one with more padding and upholstery layers.

Finally, read reviews and compare prices to find the best value for your budget. Keep in mind that a higher price doesn't always guarantee better quality, so do your research and choose a mattress that meets all of your needs.

How do I ensure that I am getting a high-quality innerspring mattress that will last for years?

To ensure that you are getting a high-quality innerspring mattress that will last for years, there are a few things you can look for:

1. Coil count: A higher coil count generally means a more supportive and durable mattress.

2. Gauge: The gauge of the coils (or how thick they are) also plays a role in durability. Look for a lower gauge (meaning thicker coils) for a longer-lasting mattress.

3. Quality materials: Look for a mattress with high-quality materials, such as high-density foam or latex, that will hold up over time.

4. Brand reputation: Do some research on the brand of mattress you are considering and read reviews from other customers to ensure their products have a good track record for durability.

5. Warranty: Look for a mattress with a generous warranty, as this can be an indication of the manufacturer's confidence in their product's longevity.

By considering these factors, you can ensure that you are investing in a high-quality innerspring mattress that will provide you with comfortable and supportive sleep for years to come.

How do I know if an innerspring mattress is the best option for me?

Choosing the right mattress can be a daunting task, especially with the numerous types of mattresses available in the market. Innerspring mattresses are one of the most popular types of mattresses, and they have been around for a long time. If you are wondering if an innerspring mattress is the best option for you, here are some things to consider.

Firstly, innerspring mattresses are known for their excellent support and durability. They are made with a network of coils that provide support to your body while you sleep. If you are looking for a mattress that offers great support and can last for a long time, then an innerspring mattress may be a good option for you.

Secondly, innerspring mattresses are great for people who sleep hot. The coils provide great airflow, which can help regulate your body temperature while you sleep. This is a great feature for people who tend to sweat while they sleep.

Lastly, innerspring mattresses come in a range of firmness levels, which makes them a great option for people who are looking for a specific level of support. Whether you prefer a soft, medium, or firm mattress, you can find an innerspring mattress that suits your needs.

In conclusion, if you are looking for a durable, supportive, and breathable mattress, then an innerspring mattress may be a good option for you. However, it's important to keep in mind that everyone has different needs and preferences when it comes to mattresses, so it's best to try out different types of mattresses before making a final decision.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of hybrid innerspring mattresses compared to traditional innerspring mattresses?

Hybrid innerspring mattresses are a combination of traditional innerspring mattresses and foam layers. They offer some advantages and disadvantages compared to traditional innerspring mattresses.

Advantages of hybrid innerspring mattresses include better motion isolation and pressure relief due to the foam layers. They also tend to have longer lifespans than traditional innerspring mattresses. Additionally, hybrid mattresses can offer a wider range of firmness options, making them suitable for more people.

On the other hand, hybrid innerspring mattresses can be more expensive than traditional innerspring mattresses due to the added foam layers. They may also have a different feel than traditional innerspring mattresses, which some people may not prefer. Hybrid mattresses can also be heavier and more difficult to move than traditional innerspring mattresses.

Overall, hybrid innerspring mattresses can be a good choice for those who want the support of an innerspring mattress with the added benefits of foam layers. However, it is important to consider the cost and potential disadvantages before making a final decision.

What are the benefits of choosing an innerspring mattress over other types?

Innerspring mattresses are a popular choice for many people because of their benefits. One of the main advantages of an innerspring mattress is its durability. These mattresses are constructed with a solid steel wire coil support system that helps the mattress maintain its shape and provide support for many years.

Another benefit of an innerspring mattress is its affordability. Compared to other types of mattresses, such as memory foam or latex, innerspring mattresses are often more budget-friendly. They are widely available and come in a range of prices to fit different budgets.

Innerspring mattresses also offer a cooler sleeping experience compared to foam mattresses, which can trap body heat. The coils in an innerspring mattress allow for greater air circulation, which helps keep the sleeper cool and comfortable throughout the night.

Lastly, innerspring mattresses offer a variety of firmness options to choose from. Whether you prefer a soft, medium, or firm mattress, you can find an innerspring mattress that fits your preference.

Overall, the benefits of an innerspring mattress include durability, affordability, coolness, and a range of firmness options.

What are the most common complaints or issues reported by consumers regarding innerspring mattresses, and how can I avoid these problems when choosing a mattress?

One of the most common complaints reported by consumers regarding innerspring mattresses is sagging. Over time, the coils in the mattress can lose their shape and support, causing the mattress to become uneven and uncomfortable. To avoid this problem, look for innerspring mattresses with higher coil counts, as more coils often means better support and durability.

Another complaint is that innerspring mattresses can be too firm or too soft for some people. To avoid this issue, consider the firmness level that works best for your sleeping style and preferences. Many mattress manufacturers offer a range of firmness options, from soft to extra firm. It's also important to test out the mattress in person before making a purchase, if possible.

Finally, some consumers report that innerspring mattresses can be noisy or squeaky, particularly when they're old or worn out. To avoid this problem, look for mattresses with individually wrapped coils, which can reduce motion transfer and minimize noise. Additionally, make sure to rotate and flip your mattress regularly to prevent uneven wear and tear.

What are the most important features to look for in an innerspring mattress?

When shopping for an innerspring mattress, there are several important features to look for to ensure a comfortable and supportive sleeping experience. The first feature to consider is the coil count, which refers to the number of coils in the mattress. Generally, the higher the coil count, the better the support and durability of the mattress.

Another important feature is the gauge of the coils. The gauge refers to the thickness of the wire used in the coils, and a lower gauge typically means a firmer mattress. However, it is important to find a balance between support and comfort.

The quality and type of padding used in the mattress is also crucial. Look for mattresses with high-quality materials such as natural latex, memory foam, or wool, which can provide additional comfort and support.

Finally, consider the overall construction of the mattress, including the edge support and the quality of the cover. A well-constructed innerspring mattress with good edge support and a durable cover can provide years of comfortable sleep.

What are the top-rated innerspring mattresses according to Consumer Reports?

According to Consumer Reports, the top-rated innerspring mattresses in 2021 are the Sealy Posturepedic Plus Warrenville III Cushion Firm, the Stearns & Foster Estate Hurston Luxury Firm, and the Beautyrest Black K-Class Ultra Plush Pillowtop. These mattresses have been evaluated based on factors such as support, durability, comfort, and value for money. The Sealy Posturepedic Plus Warrenville III Cushion Firm has received high marks for its firm support and motion isolation, while the Stearns & Foster Estate Hurston Luxury Firm is known for its exceptional durability and edge support. The Beautyrest Black K-Class Ultra Plush Pillowtop has been rated highly for its plush comfort and pressure relief. Other top-rated innerspring mattresses include the Serta Perfect Sleeper Elkins II Firm, the Sealy Response Performance Briar Rose Cushion Firm, and the Simmons Beautyrest Harmony Lux Carbon Series Extra Firm. Ultimately, the best innerspring mattress for you will depend on your personal preferences and sleeping habits.

What factors should I consider when choosing an innerspring mattress?

When choosing an innerspring mattress, there are a few factors you should consider to ensure you are getting the best possible sleep experience. Firstly, you should consider the firmness of the mattress. This is a personal preference, but generally, a firmer mattress is better for people who sleep on their back or stomach, while a softer mattress is better for people who sleep on their side.

Another factor to consider is the coil count. Generally, the higher the coil count, the better the support and durability of the mattress. You should also consider the quality of the materials used in the mattress, such as the padding, foam layers, and the quality of the springs.

It is important to consider your budget as well, as innerspring mattresses can range from very affordable to very expensive. You should also consider any additional features, such as pillow tops or cooling technology, that may be important to you.

Ultimately, the best innerspring mattress for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences, so it's important to do your research and try out different mattresses before making a decision.

What is the average cost of a high-quality innerspring mattress, and are there any affordable options available?

The average cost of a high-quality innerspring mattress can vary depending on the brand, size, and materials used. Generally, you can expect to spend between $800 to $1,500 for a queen-sized innerspring mattress from a reputable manufacturer. However, there are also more affordable options available that still provide good quality and comfort.

One option is to look for innerspring mattresses that are sold directly from the manufacturer or online retailers, as they often offer lower prices than traditional brick-and-mortar stores. Another option is to consider purchasing a hybrid mattress, which combines innerspring coils with foam or latex layers. These mattresses can offer the benefits of both materials and are often more affordable than traditional innerspring mattresses.

It's important to keep in mind that the cost of a mattress shouldn't be your only consideration when making a purchase. You should also consider the quality of materials, durability, and warranty offered by the manufacturer to ensure that you are getting the best value for your money.