When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Homemade Rolls For Thanksgiving (2024 Updated)

If you're looking for a homemade touch to your Thanksgiving dinner, consider making homemade rolls. They are a great addition to any meal and are sure to impress your guests with their fresh-from-the-oven smell and taste. But before you start baking, it's important to consider a few factors to ensure your rolls turn out perfectly.

First, be sure to choose a recipe that is tested and proven. Look for recipes from reputable sources or from experienced bakers who can provide step-by-step instructions. Consider the type of flour, yeast, and other ingredients needed to make the perfect roll. Also, take into consideration the amount of time needed to prep and bake the rolls. Homemade rolls require time and attention, but the payoff is worth it.

Questions to ask yourself before baking homemade rolls for Thanksgiving include: What type of rolls would complement the Thanksgiving meal the best? Are there any dietary restrictions among your guests? How can you adjust the recipe to make it your own? Baking homemade rolls can be a fun and rewarding experience, but it's important to consider all aspects beforehand to ensure a successful outcome.

In conclusion, homemade rolls for Thanksgiving are a wonderful addition to any dinner table. Remember to carefully choose a recipe, consider ingredients and time, and ask yourself important questions before embarking on this baking adventure. With a little bit of planning and patience, you'll be able to wow your guests with delicious homemade rolls.

10 Best Homemade Rolls For Thanksgiving

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
The product is ideal for cooking large meals and roasts.
2
The product is ideal for packaging homemade bread, rolls, and cookies for home bakers and bakeries during the Christmas season.
3
The product is ideal for serving homemade sourdough bread, storing bread, and organizing pantry or fruit items.
4
The product is ideal for expressing sympathy and condolences to someone in a thoughtful and comforting way.
5
The product is ideal for farmhouse-themed mini rolling pin tiered tray decorations during the Thanksgiving season.
6
It is ideal for those who want a delicious pumpkin roll dessert for Thanksgiving or autumn occasions.
7
Ideal for gifting on various occasions such as Easter, birthdays, expressing sympathy, and cheering up loved ones.
8
This product is ideal for making fresh pasta at home using a KitchenAid stand mixer.
9
The product is ideal for Thanksgiving parties and as a sweet treat for guests.
10
Ideal for gifting to families, men, and women who appreciate gourmet food, cakes, brownies, crumb cakes, rugelah, and muffins.
The product is ideal for cooking large meals and roasts.
The product is ideal for packaging homemade bread, rolls, and cookies for home bakers and bakeries during the Christmas season.
The product is ideal for serving homemade sourdough bread, storing bread, and organizing pantry or fruit items.
The product is ideal for expressing sympathy and condolences to someone in a thoughtful and comforting way.
The product is ideal for farmhouse-themed mini rolling pin tiered tray decorations during the Thanksgiving season.
It is ideal for those who want a delicious pumpkin roll dessert for Thanksgiving or autumn occasions.
Ideal for gifting on various occasions such as Easter, birthdays, expressing sympathy, and cheering up loved ones.
This product is ideal for making fresh pasta at home using a KitchenAid stand mixer.
The product is ideal for Thanksgiving parties and as a sweet treat for guests.
Ideal for gifting to families, men, and women who appreciate gourmet food, cakes, brownies, crumb cakes, rugelah, and muffins.

1. Nesco Mwr18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White

Introducing the 18 quart capacity electric roaster oven, a versatile cooking appliance that can handle large quantities of food effortlessly. With its large capacity, it is perfect for cooking a turkey, ham, or roast for family gatherings or special occasions. The removable enamel cook well ensures easy cleaning and maintenance, making it a convenient addition to any kitchen.

The electric roaster oven features cool touch handles that provide safe and comfortable handling, even when the appliance is hot. The adjustable thermostat from 200 to 450 degrees allows for precise temperature control, ensuring that your food is cooked to perfection every time. Whether you're roasting, baking, or cooking, this electric roaster oven is equipped to handle all your culinary needs.

This electric roaster oven is UL approved, ensuring that it meets the highest safety standards. It is easy to use, easy to clean, and an excellent addition to any kitchen. Whether you're a novice cook or an experienced chef, this electric roaster oven is the perfect solution for all your cooking needs.

Pros

  • Large 18 quart capacity can handle large quantities of food
  • Removable enamel cook well ensures easy cleaning and maintenance
  • Cool touch handles provide safe and comfortable handling even when hot
  • Adjustable thermostat from 200 to 450 degrees allows for precise temperature control
  • UL approved ensures highest safety standards

2. Christmas Plaid Bread Bags For Fresh Homemade Bread

The Exquisite Design clear plastic bread bags are a must-have item for bakers who want to keep their homemade bread and baked goods fresh for longer periods. Each package contains 50 bags with delicate custom-made black and white buffalo plaid pattern and twist ties, making them a thoughtful gift for friends and colleagues.

Measuring 8 x 18 x 3 inches, these Christmas baked bread bags are suitable for most types and sizes of homemade bread and bakery items such as rolls, cookies, bagels, muffins, croissants, and buns. They also hold a standard bread from the grocery store up to 1.5 pounds, preventing tearing and improving durability by providing more space.

Our homemade bread storage bags use sturdy plastic and silver kinks to keep the bag airtight, keeping out water, dust, and refrigerator odors. With thicker material, these bread packing bags keep your bread fresh and tasty for longer periods.

These clear plastic bread bags are not only functional but also add a touch of elegance to your baked goods. They are fancy enough for gifts and casual enough for everyday use, making them a good choice for home bakers, bread enthusiasts, and bakery owners alike.

Pros

  • Each package comes with 50 bags and twist ties, making them a great value for money
  • Suitable for most types and sizes of homemade bread and bakery items
  • Sturdy plastic and silver kinks keep the bag airtight, keeping out water, dust, and refrigerator odors
  • Thicker material keeps your bread fresh and tasty for longer periods
  • Add a touch of elegance to your baked goods

Cons

  • – None

3. Artizanka Wicker Bread Basket Set

Upgrade your bread storage and serving game with this handmade wicker basket that features thick canvas material and stylish lace for an elegant design. This basket is perfect for serving artisan sourdough bread, pastries, muffins, rolls, or bagels, and will impress your guests with its modern touch. Designed in Canada, this basket is an eco-friendly alternative to plastic and is great for keeping your bread fresh and warm for longer thanks to its thick double wall material that ensures heat stays inside the basket. Additionally, the liner and elastic top make it easy to cover your bread and keep it fresh until you're ready to serve. The 12"L x 9"W x 5.3"H wicker basket easily fits large-sized loaves, bread rolls, pastries or fruits, and the canvas lid can extend over the top of your bread rolls, allowing for more room if you wish to use a bread warming stone. This basket is also easy to use and care for, as you can hand wash or machine wash the liner and cover in a cold water delicate cycle and hang to dry. The wicker bread basket is strong, steady and durable, with high-quality combined cotton material that will not shrink after washing and will keep messy bread crumbs inside. It is perfect for a home or outdoor picnics and can also be used as a fruit basket or pantry basket. Lastly, this basket makes a perfect housewarming gift for any occasion, such as weddings, birthdays, Mother's Day, Easter, Christmas, or a romantic dinner. Your loved ones will be stunned by the stylish basket for bread keeper and bread storage experience.

Pros

  • Stylish and elegant design that brings a modern touch to your table
  • Thick double wall material that ensures heat from your bread does not escape the basket
  • Liner and elastic top keep your bread fresh and warm for longer
  • Eco-friendly alternative to plastic
  • Perfect size for multipurpose use
  • Easy to use and care for
  • Strong, steady, and durable wicker bread basket
  • Can be used as a fruit basket or pantry basket
  • Perfect housewarming gift for any occasion

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for larger loaves of bread
  • – Hand washing or delicate cycle machine washing is required for the liner and cover

4. Wine Country Gift Baskets Sympathy Gift Basket

Looking for a gift that will surely delight your loved ones or friends? Look no further than this Beautiful Basket Filled with Wine Country Favorites! This basket is filled with an assortment of crackers, dips, and sweets that are sure to cheer anyone up. Whether it's for a special occasion or just to show someone you care, this gift is perfect for any occasion.

Wine Country Gift Baskets pours its heart into every basket, ensuring that each one is hand-crafted with care and attention to detail. Made with only the highest quality ingredients, our gift baskets are assembled in the USA and include some of the top brand names that we know you'll love. With over 30 years of experience in sending gifts, Wine Country Gift Baskets is a trusted and reliable brand that your loved one or friends will appreciate.

Personalized Messages are also available to share your customized sentiments for every situation that can arise. This heart-warming option has been included to allow you to share your custom created message with your gift recipient. So why wait? Surprise your loved ones or friends today with this Beautiful Basket Filled with Wine Country Favorites and make their day extra special!

Pros

  • Assortment of crackers, dips, and sweets that are sure to cheer anyone up
  • Hand-crafted with care and attention to detail
  • Made with only the highest quality ingredients
  • Trusted and reliable brand with over 30 years of experience
  • Personalized Messages available to share your customized sentiments

5. Farmhouse Mini Rolling Pins For Fall Baking.

The Fall Mini Rolling Pins Set is a must-have for anyone who loves to decorate their home with festive and seasonal accents. The package includes 4 pieces of mini rolling pins in 4 different styles, each with a unique fall-related design. These mini rolling pins are made of high-quality wood, making them reliable, durable, and safe to use. The clear printed patterns and exquisite workmanship ensure that they will last for a long time.

These mini rolling pins are perfect for tiered tray decoration, farmhouse decoration, tabletop core decoration, kitchen decoration, cabinet, window decoration, spring and summer photography props, and more. The yellow and orange theme colors make them eye-catching and perfect for welcoming the fall season and celebrating Halloween and Thanksgiving.

In addition to being great for decorating your own home, these mini rolling pins also make a wonderful gift for your loved ones. Whether it's for your mother, father, friend, co-worker, or colleague, the bright colors and fun designs are sure to be loved by all. Get your hands on the Fall Mini Rolling Pins Set today and bring the festive spirit to your home!

Pros

  • The package includes 4 pieces of mini rolling pins in 4 different styles, each with a unique fall-related design
  • These mini rolling pins are made of high-quality wood, making them reliable, durable, and safe to use
  • The yellow and orange theme colors make them eye-catching and perfect for welcoming the fall season and celebrating Halloween and Thanksgiving
  • These mini rolling pins are perfect for tiered tray decoration, farmhouse decoration, tabletop core decoration, kitchen decoration, cabinet, window decoration, spring and summer photography props, and more

6. Arianna's Amish Pumpkin Roll Duo

Indulge in the rich and creamy pumpkin dessert made by the skilled bakers of Arianna's Bakery, located in the heart of Pennsylvania's Amish country. This homemade dessert is a perfect blend of Lancaster County's PA Dutch and Amish-style flavors that will leave you craving for more!

Experience the delectable taste of this pumpkin cake that has a soft and delicate layer, complemented by a creamy and luscious cream cheese filling that oozes out with every bite. Satisfy your taste buds with this delightful dessert that is perfect for any occasion, be it a Thanksgiving or Christmas feast or a birthday party.

Buy in bulk and save! Stock up your freezer with this delicious dessert that will keep your taste buds entertained for days to come. Enjoy the taste of homemade goodness that is made with love and care in the USA.

Pros

  • Creamy pumpkin dessert made with love and care in the USA
  • A perfect blend of Lancaster County's PA Dutch and Amish-style flavors
  • Soft and delicate layer of pumpkin cake with a creamy and luscious cream cheese filling
  • Ideal for any occasion be it Thanksgiving, Christmas or a birthday party
  • Bulk buying option available

7. Bonnie & Pop's Gourmet Nut Crate

The Great Assortment Gourmet Nuts Gift Crate is a wonderful selection of nuts that will tantalize your taste buds. Open the latch and marvel at the variety of Chili Con Lemon Pistachios, Glazed Pecans, Salted Cashews, Tamari Almonds, Cranberry Health Mix, and Sweet & Savory Mix.

This gourmet nut variety gift pack is presented in a charming, rustic wood crate that will impress and delight. The tray can be reused to store tea, coffee, chocolate, dried fruit, and other snacks.

Each section of this sampler box of nuts is individually wrapped to ensure freshness and make sharing easy this holiday season. These premium nuts are fresh, organic, and kosher-certified.

Nuts make for a perfect present for any occasion, and this Gourmet Nuts Gift Crate is the best you can find anywhere. It's an ideal gift for men, women, friends, family, and corporate gifting alike. Suitable for multiple holidays such as Easter, Mother's Day, Father's Day, birthdays, sympathy, condolence, to say thank you, the office, college care, him, her, grandma, and grandpa!

When you order this product, be sure to check the box labeled “This is a gift” at checkout and write a personalized message to make the present even more special.

Pros

  • A wide variety of gourmet nuts to satisfy different tastes
  • Presented in a charming, rustic wood crate that can be reused for storage
  • Individually wrapped to ensure freshness
  • Fresh, organic, and kosher-certified nuts
  • Suitable for multiple occasions and recipients
  • Can be personalized with a message

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for those with nut allergies

8. Kitchenaid Pasta Maker Set: 3-In-1 Attachment

The Upgrade 3-in-1 KitchenAid Pasta Attachment is a perfect addition to any KitchenAid Stand Mixer, allowing users to make fresh homemade pasta with ease. The Pasta Sheet Roller smoothly turns the dough into thin and soft pasta, while the pasta roller and cutters are in one unit, eliminating the need to change the attachment between making the pasta sheet and cutting the pasta. With 8 thickness settings, users can adjust to their desired thickness for various recipes. The attachment can produce 5.5-inch sheets of pasta and cut them into spaghetti and fettuccine, saving time and effort. The Noodle Makers are made of high-quality stainless steel food-grade materials, making them durable and sturdy for long-term use. The precise stainless steel gears inside the attachment ensure efficient and low-noise pasta sheet and noodle making. Installation is a breeze, and the attachment is easy to clean, with a protective case built-in POM and two cleaning brushes included. This 3-in-1 pasta attachment is an excellent gift choice for anyone who loves to cook and already has a KitchenAid Stand Mixer at home. The product comes with a 1-year warranty, and the customer service team is always ready to help with any quality issues that may arise.

In summary, the Upgrade 3-in-1 KitchenAid Pasta Attachment is a time-saver and convenient accessory for any KitchenAid Stand Mixer, allowing users to make fresh pasta with ease. The attachment is made of high-quality stainless steel food-grade materials, making it sturdy and durable for long-term use. Its installation is easy, and cleaning is a breeze. This product is an excellent gift choice for anyone who loves to cook and already has a KitchenAid Stand Mixer at home.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Time-saving and convenient
  • Made of high-quality stainless steel food-grade materials
  • Durable and sturdy for long-term use
  • Easy to install and clean
  • Excellent gift choice
  • Comes with a 1-year warranty

Cons

  • – May not fit other brands of stand mixers
  • – Slightly heavier than other pasta attachments
  • – May require some practice to get the desired thickness and texture of the pasta

9. Turkey Suckers For Thanksgiving (12 Pack Individually Wrapped) Party Candy And Lollipops

Make your Thanksgiving celebration more festive with these Turkey Character Suckers. These lollipops are the perfect addition to your party supplies, adding a touch of fun and color to your holiday event. Each pack comes with 12 mixed fruit flavored lollipops, each featuring a turkey design that will surely delight your guests. These lollipops are individually wrapped and weigh a total of 7 oz, making them easy to distribute as party favors or as part of your candy buffet. Each lollipop measures 1 3/4 inches and is attached to a 4-inch plastic stick.

These Turkey Character Suckers are also fat-free, making them a guilt-free treat for both adults and children. Whether you're hosting a large family gathering or a small intimate celebration, these lollipops are sure to bring smiles to your guests' faces. So, go ahead and add these fun and tasty Turkey Character Suckers to your Thanksgiving party supplies today!

Pros

  • Festive turkey designs add a touch of fun and color to your event
  • Mixed fruit flavor appeals to both adults and children
  • Individually wrapped for easy distribution
  • Fat-free, guilt-free treat

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for those with fruit allergies

10. Dulcet Delights Gourmet Gift Basket

The Dulcet Deluxe Package is a perfect combination of sweet treats that are sure to satisfy anyone's sweet tooth. This package includes 4 assorted brownies with flavors like Chocolate Cheese, Chocolate Fudge, Chocolate Chip Blondie, and Walnut. In addition, it has 1 Chocolate Crumb Cake, 1 Raspberry Crumb Cake, 1 Old Fashioned Crumb Cake, and 1/2 lb. assorted Rugelach with flavors like Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Sugar, Raspberry, and Apricot. Lastly, it also comes with 2 3oz Blueberry Muffins.

This premium deluxe package is beautifully wrapped with a magnificent hand-tied burgundy bow, making it an excellent gift for various occasions like Anniversary, Mother's Day, Baby Showers, Sympathy, Birthdays, Gifts for Men, Gifts for Women, and many more. The Dulcet Gift Basket is a top gift idea for all occasions that your recipient will surely love.

Dulcet is committed to providing the best quality and design. Each pastry is individually wrapped and shipped within 1-2 days to ensure freshness. All of their amazing pastries are Kosher- OU D Certified. In case a product or flavor is not available, Dulcet has the right to change it with an equal valued product. They are confident that you and your recipient will love their gift basket. However, if for any reason you or your recipient aren't fully satisfied with the products, Dulcet is always ready to assist you.

In summary, the Dulcet Deluxe Package is a perfect gift for anyone who loves sweet treats. The package is filled with an array of delicious pastries that will surely satisfy anyone's cravings. It comes beautifully wrapped with a hand-tied burgundy bow, making it an excellent gift for any occasion. Dulcet is committed to providing the best quality and design, and they are always ready to assist you in case of any issue.

Pros

  • The package includes an assortment of delectable sweet treats that are sure to satisfy anyone's sweet tooth
  • Beautifully wrapped with a magnificent hand-tied burgundy bow, making it an excellent gift for various occasions
  • The pastries are individually wrapped and shipped within 1-2 days to ensure maximum freshness
  • All of the pastries are Kosher- OU D Certified
  • The package is a top gift idea for all occasions
  • Dulcet is committed to providing the best quality and design, and they are always ready to assist you in case of any issue

Best Homemade Rolls For Thanksgiving FAQs

Can I freeze homemade rolls for Thanksgiving and reheat them later?

Yes, you can definitely freeze homemade rolls for Thanksgiving and reheat them later. In fact, it's a great way to save time and make things easier on the big day. To freeze your rolls, let them cool completely after baking, then wrap them tightly in plastic wrap or aluminum foil. You can also place them in a freezer-safe bag or container. Be sure to label and date them so you know how long they've been in the freezer.

When it's time to reheat the rolls, simply take them out of the freezer and let them thaw at room temperature for a few hours. Once they're thawed, you can either reheat them in the oven or microwave. To reheat in the oven, preheat it to 350°F, wrap the rolls in foil, and bake for 10-15 minutes. To reheat in the microwave, wrap the rolls in a damp paper towel and microwave for 30 seconds to 1 minute.

Keep in mind that while freezing and reheating homemade rolls is a great time-saver, it can affect their texture and flavor. To preserve the best quality, try to freeze them no more than a few weeks in advance and be sure to reheat them properly.

How can I make my homemade rolls for Thanksgiving extra fluffy and buttery?

To make your homemade rolls for Thanksgiving extra fluffy and buttery, there are a few things you can do. First, use a high-quality flour that has a high protein content. This will help the rolls rise properly and create a light and fluffy texture. You can also add an extra egg or two to the dough, which will help to make the rolls richer and more buttery.

Another trick is to use warm milk instead of cold or room temperature milk when making the dough. This will help the yeast activate more quickly, which will result in a better rise and a fluffier texture.

Lastly, don't be afraid to be generous with the butter! Brush melted butter over the tops of the rolls before baking, and again as soon as they come out of the oven. This will help to create a deliciously buttery flavor and a soft, tender texture.

Overall, making homemade rolls for Thanksgiving is a labor of love, but with a few simple tricks, you can create a batch of rolls that will impress your guests and make your Thanksgiving feast even more special.

How far in advance can I make homemade rolls for Thanksgiving?

Homemade rolls are a delicious addition to any Thanksgiving meal, but planning ahead is crucial to ensure they turn out perfectly. The good news is that you can make homemade rolls well in advance of Thanksgiving day. Most recipes recommend preparing the dough a day or two before the big event, allowing it to rise in the refrigerator overnight. This method helps to develop the flavor and texture of the rolls while also making them easier to handle. Once the dough has risen, you can shape the rolls and freeze them for up to a month. On the day of Thanksgiving, simply thaw the rolls and bake them fresh for a warm and delicious addition to your holiday meal. Alternatively, you can bake the rolls ahead of time and reheat them in the oven just before serving. Either way, homemade rolls are a wonderful way to add a personal touch to your Thanksgiving feast.

What is the best recipe for homemade rolls for Thanksgiving?

For homemade rolls that are perfect for Thanksgiving, there are a few great recipes to choose from. One popular recipe is a classic buttery dinner roll recipe that uses all-purpose flour, yeast, sugar, salt, milk, eggs, and butter. This recipe creates soft and fluffy rolls that are perfect for soaking up gravy and butter.

Another great option is to make cinnamon rolls, which are a delicious and sweet addition to any Thanksgiving table. These rolls are made with a yeast dough, cinnamon sugar filling, and a creamy glaze on top. They can be made ahead of time and reheated on the day of the feast for a warm and comforting treat.

For a healthier option, you can try making whole wheat rolls that are packed with fiber and nutrients. These rolls are made with whole wheat flour, honey, yeast, salt, and water. They are perfect for those who want to enjoy the traditional taste of rolls without the added calories and refined flour.

Overall, the best recipe for homemade rolls for Thanksgiving depends on your personal taste and dietary preferences. No matter which recipe you choose, homemade rolls are a delicious and comforting addition to any Thanksgiving meal.

What type of flour is best for making homemade rolls for Thanksgiving?

When it comes to making homemade rolls for Thanksgiving, choosing the right type of flour can make a big difference in the texture and taste of the final product. The best type of flour for making rolls is all-purpose flour. This type of flour has a medium protein content, which makes it versatile enough for a variety of baked goods, including rolls. All-purpose flour is also readily available in most grocery stores, making it a convenient option for home bakers.

Another option for making rolls is bread flour, which has a higher protein content than all-purpose flour. This extra protein helps create a chewy, hearty texture in bread and rolls. However, bread flour may not be as readily available as all-purpose flour, and it may not be necessary for making rolls if you don't want an extra chewy texture.

Ultimately, the choice of flour will depend on your personal preference and the recipe you are using. But for most home bakers, all-purpose flour is the best choice for making delicious, fluffy rolls for Thanksgiving.

Leave a Comment