When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Grocery Store Birthday Cakes (2024 Updated)

If you’re looking for a delicious and affordable cake for your next birthday celebration, look no further than your local grocery store's bakery department! Grocery store birthday cakes are a convenient and budget-friendly option for those who don't want to spend a lot of money on a custom cake.

Before you make your purchase, there are a few factors to consider. Start by deciding on the size and shape of the cake you need, as well as any dietary restrictions you or your guests may have. You'll also want to look at the different decorating options available, such as icing colors and design choices. Lastly, make sure to place your order well in advance to ensure that the bakery has enough time to prepare your cake.

Are you on a tight budget but still want to impress your guests with a delicious cake? Grocery store birthday cakes are the perfect solution. With options ranging from traditional chocolate and vanilla to unique flavors like red velvet and carrot cake, there's something for everyone. Plus, with affordable pricing and customizable decorations, you can have a beautiful cake without breaking the bank.

Have you ever tried a grocery store birthday cake? Did the bakery department meet your expectations in terms of taste and design? What factors did you consider before making your purchase? Join the conversation and share your experience with us!

10 Best Grocery Store Birthday Cakes

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
The product is ideal for gifting, serving 6-8 people, and being delivered frozen in dry ice.
2
The product is ideal for surprising friends and family with a delicious vanilla and raspberry flavor birthday cake dessert.
3
The product is ideal for those looking for a delicious and unique cake to serve at birthday parties or as a gift.
4
The product is ideal for gifting as party food and contains individually wrapped fresh cupcakes with rainbow or chocolate sprinkles.
5
The product is ideal for gifting or enjoying as a dessert or breakfast pastry.
6
This product is ideal for decorating cakes and cupcakes at various events including weddings, birthdays, and baby showers.
7
This gift basket is ideal for anyone who enjoys sweet and savory snacks, including adults, college students, and children.
8
It is ideal for making a healthy and sweet cake without adding sugar or artificial ingredients, perfect for first birthdays.
9
It is an ideal gift for someone celebrating their birthday, featuring delicious chocolate-covered cookies and gourmet food items.
10
The product is ideal for decorating personalized birthday cakes with an edible image topper.
The product is ideal for gifting, serving 6-8 people, and being delivered frozen in dry ice.
The product is ideal for surprising friends and family with a delicious vanilla and raspberry flavor birthday cake dessert.
The product is ideal for those looking for a delicious and unique cake to serve at birthday parties or as a gift.
The product is ideal for gifting as party food and contains individually wrapped fresh cupcakes with rainbow or chocolate sprinkles.
The product is ideal for gifting or enjoying as a dessert or breakfast pastry.
This product is ideal for decorating cakes and cupcakes at various events including weddings, birthdays, and baby showers.
This gift basket is ideal for anyone who enjoys sweet and savory snacks, including adults, college students, and children.
It is ideal for making a healthy and sweet cake without adding sugar or artificial ingredients, perfect for first birthdays.
It is an ideal gift for someone celebrating their birthday, featuring delicious chocolate-covered cookies and gourmet food items.
The product is ideal for decorating personalized birthday cakes with an edible image topper.

1. Rainbow Fudge Cake – Baked Fresh & Delivered

Indulge in the world-renowned Cake Boss's mouthwatering chocolate fudge rainbow cake, recognized globally from the hit TLC series. The premium cake is handcrafted with love by artisan master bakers in Hoboken, NJ, dedicated to bringing you some of the finest rainbow birthday cakes. Each bite is a heavenly combination of rich chocolate fudge frosting and six layers of soft vanilla cake, making it an ideal birthday cake for people of all ages.

When you need birthday food to make your celebration memorable, trust Carlo's Bakery. This cake is sure to add an unforgettable flair to any celebration with its incredible taste and attention-grabbing appearance. The Italian rainbow cake measures 6” and serves between 6 to 8 people, making it perfect for small gatherings and intimate celebrations.

If you're in search of birthday cakes for delivery, Carlo's Bakery has the answer. Spend more time doing the things you love with birthday cakes delivered to your door. The cakes for delivery are snap-frozen and shipped in dry ice, ensuring freshness and quality. They can be defrosted in 2 to 3 hours in advance or thawed and stored in the fridge for up to 72 hours before serving.

For scroll-stopping social media pictures, rinse your knife with hot water between cutting the slices to maintain the cake's stunning appearance. Processed on equipment that also processes peanuts and tree nuts.

Pros

  • Handcrafted with love by artisan master bakers in Hoboken, NJ
  • A delectable combination of rich chocolate fudge frosting and six layers of vanilla cake
  • Ideal birthday cake for people of all ages
  • Perfect for small gatherings and intimate celebrations
  • Cakes for delivery are snap-frozen and shipped in dry ice, ensuring freshness and quality
  • Can be defrosted in 2 to 3 hours in advance or thawed and stored in the fridge for up to 72 hours before serving

Cons

  • – Processed on equipment that also processes peanuts and tree nuts

2. Vanilla Raspberry Birthday Cake – Fresh & Delicious

Indulge in the homemade taste of this premium quality cake made with only the finest ingredients, including sugar, eggs, and butter. Every bite is a delicious treat for your taste buds. Perfect for those who follow a Kosher diet, as it is certified Kosher. The symphony of flavors will burst in your mouth, making it a one-of-a-kind dessert that is sure to impress your guests. This 7-inch birthday cake is the perfect present for your loved ones, with 6-8 servings of rich and delicious flavor that will keep their taste buds tingling with delight.

Take a bite of this beautifully crafted white cake, and you'll be pleasantly surprised by its unparalleled taste. It's not just a feast for the eyes, but also for the palate. You won't find another cake that tastes as good as this one!

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just indulging in a sweet treat, this cake is the perfect choice. Its homemade taste and delicious flavor are sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting more. So go ahead and treat yourself to this mouth-watering dessert today!

Pros

  • Made with premium quality ingredients for a homemade taste
  • Certified Kosher
  • Delicious and rich flavor that bursts in your mouth
  • Beautifully crafted white cake that tastes unparalleled
  • Perfect for celebrating special occasions or as a sweet treat

3. Rainbow Strawberry Cake: Small & Delicious – Delivered!

Indulge in the world-famous Carlo's Bakery strawberry rainbow cake, known for its appearance on the hit TLC series Cake Boss. This mouthwatering cake is handcrafted with love by artisan master bakers in Hoboken, NJ. Each cake is a delectable combination of rich strawberry buttercream frosting and six layers of vanilla cake. This premium cake is a crowd pleaser, sure to add an unforgettable flair to any celebration.

If you're looking for a cake that can be delivered to your doorstep, Carlo's Bakery has got you covered. The cakes are snap-frozen and shipped in dry ice, ensuring that they arrive fresh and ready to thaw. It takes 2 to 3 hours to defrost the cake in advance or thaw and store it in the fridge for up to 72 hours before serving. The cake is 6" in size and serves between 6 to 8 people, making it perfect for small celebrations.

Not only does this Italian rainbow cake taste incredible, but it also looks amazing. Its vibrant colors make it an attention-grabbing centerpiece for any table. To get the perfect slice, rinse the knife with hot water between cutting the slices. Please note that this cake is processed on equipment that also processes peanuts and tree nuts.

Pros

  • Handcrafted by artisan master bakers
  • Delectable combination of rich strawberry buttercream frosting and six layers of vanilla cake
  • Snap-frozen and shipped in dry ice for delivery
  • Vibrant colors make it an attention-grabbing centerpiece
  • Perfect size for small celebrations

Cons

  • – Processed on equipment that also processes peanuts and tree nuts

4. Rainbow Cupcake Party Basket – Birthday Bliss!

Indulge in the delicious taste of these 7 large cupcakes, each approximately 3 oz and 3.5 inches across. These cupcakes are made with white cake and have delectable chocolate chips inside, making them a treat for any chocolate lover. They are individually wrapped to ensure safety and are perfect for school, parties, lunches, or gifts. These cupcakes are versatile and can be used as party cupcakes or birthday gifts for anyone. Men, women, children, boys or girls alike will enjoy these delicious, fun set of cupcakes. They are made locally in the USA and are Kosher Pareve. Additionally, they are made in a nut-free, lactose-free facility, making them a safe option for people with food sensitivities. The cupcakes are made with high-quality ingredients such as enriched bleached wheat flour, sugar, eggs, soybean & palm oil, modified food starch, vital wheat gluten, glycerol, propylene glycol monostearate, sodium stearoyl lactylate, salt, sodium bicarbonate, sodium aluminum phosphate, isolated soya protein, natural & artificial flavors, citric acid, water, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, sunflower lecithin, and artificial preservatives (to maintain freshness). The cupcakes are also decorated with FD&C colors such as red #40, red #3, blue #1, yellow #5 & yellow #6.

Pros

  • Individually wrapped for safety and convenience.
  • Versatile and perfect for school, parties, lunches, or gifts.
  • Made in a nut-free, lactose-free facility.
  • High-quality ingredients used.
  • Kosher Pareve.
  • Decorated with FD&C colors.

5. Blue Butterfly Cake Toppers – Celebrate In Style

Make your birthday party look even more special with this pack of cake toppers. It includes 4 pieces of 'Happy Birthday' letter cake toppers with different styles and 20 butterfly cake toppers. The butterfly cake toppers have a 3D effect and can be gently folded for added dimension. The 'Happy Birthday' cake toppers are made of high-quality acrylic, which makes them more durable than paper toppers. They can be reused and easily stored for future use. The cake toppers come in various sizes, with the largest measuring 4.33" x 6.30" and the smallest measuring 4.53" x 5.12". The blue butterfly cake toppers are available in 4 different sizes, ranging from 1.4" to 2.5" wide and 2" to 3.4" high (including the stick).

These cake toppers are double-sided and have a sparkling, mirror gold front and a mirror silver back. Before use, make sure to tear off the protective film on both sides. They are available in different sizes and colors to suit various types of cakes and celebrations. These cake decorations will make your birthday cake look stunning and stand out. Simply add them to the top of your cake and transform it instantly. You can also use them as delicate accessories for cupcakes, ice cream, cheese, fruit, or other dishes that you want to decorate. They are perfect for birthday parties, baby showers, and other events.

Please note that these happy birthday cake toppers are fragile goods. If they arrive broken or do not meet your needs, please contact the seller for assistance.

Pros

  • High-quality acrylic material makes the cake toppers more durable than paper toppers
  • Double-sided with a sparkling, mirror gold front and mirror silver back
  • Various sizes and colors available to suit different types of cakes and celebrations
  • Can be reused and easily stored for future use

Cons

  • – The cake toppers are fragile and may arrive broken

6. Crave Food's Easter Snack Variety Pack!

Looking for a snack variety pack that contains all of America's favorite snacks and candies? Look no further than Gift-a-snack Snack Variety Pack! This pack includes a wide range of popular snacks including Airheads Candy Gravity Feed, Austin Animal Crackers, Cheez It, Famous Amos Chocolate Chip, Lances Crackers, Mott's fruit snacks Assorted, Nature Valley Oats and Honey, Oreos, Planters Peanuts, Popchips, Rice Krispies, and more. Each snack is packed in individual servings, making it easy to grab and go.

Not only does Gift-a-snack offer a delicious assortment of snacks, but it also comes with a beautifully designed mailer gift box that is sure to impress your gift recipient. The high-end packaging adds an extra touch of luxury to this already amazing gift.

This snack variety pack also includes a heartwarming greeting card to make your gift even more special. It's the perfect gift for adults, teens, college students, or anyone you would like to spread some joy to. Just remember to sign your name at checkout so your recipient knows who the gift is from.

Please note that due to supply chain issues, some of the snacks in this box may need to be replaced with snacks of similar or greater value. However, Gift-a-snack values honesty above all and will always strive to provide the best snacking experience possible.

Pros

  • Includes a wide range of America's favorite snacks and candies
  • Convenient packaging with individual servings
  • Beautifully designed mailer gift box
  • Comes with a heartwarming greeting card
  • Perfect gift for adults, teens, college students, and loved ones
  • Gift-a-snack values honesty above all

Cons

  • – May need to replace some snacks due to supply chain issues

7. Healthy First Birthday Smashcake Mix By Ooby's

Smashcake Cake Mix is the perfect choice for parents who want to celebrate their baby's first birthday with a healthy and delicious cake. It is the first and only smash cake mix that is gluten-free, vegan, and made with simple, healthy ingredients. The mix is specially formulated for babies and toddlers, making it a great choice for baby-led weaning and as a healthy snack.

The ingredients in Smashcake Cake Mix are simple and healthy. The mix contains no added sugar, sugar alcohols, or nonnutritive sweeteners. The only ingredient that sweetens the mix is fruit. This means that you won't find anything you can't pronounce on the ingredient list. The mix is also gluten-free, making it a great choice for those with gluten sensitivities.

Smashcake Cake Mix was formulated by a mom who wanted to provide a healthy and delicious cake option for her baby's first birthday. After searching for cake mixes that were free from unhealthy ingredients, she decided to create her own. The result is a cake mix that is made with love and care, and that is perfect for celebrating your baby's first birthday.

When you buy Smashcake Cake Mix, you are supporting a small, woman-owned business. The owner and founder, Lauren, lives in Wisconsin with her family and dog. By buying this mix, you are not only getting a healthy and delicious cake for your baby, but you are also supporting a family instead of a corporation.

Pros

  • Gluten-free and vegan
  • No added sugar, sugar alcohols, or nonnutritive sweeteners
  • Healthy and delicious option for baby's first birthday
  • Made with simple and healthy ingredients

8. Birthday Bliss Box: Chocolate & Cookie Delights

Looking for an ultimate gift to give to your loved ones? Look no further than the Hazel and Creme chocolate-covered cookie gift box. The cookies are double-creamed and generously dipped into dark chocolate, then topped with mouth-watering and flavorful toppings that will surely satisfy all your chocolate cravings. Each cookie has a delicious combination of flavors and textures that will make you savor every bite into pure chocolate bliss.

Hazel and Creme's chocolates are hand-crafted and tested to ensure the best distinctive chocolate flavor. They use only the freshest premium quality ingredients to ensure your ultimate satisfaction. The cookies are tried and true, ensuring that every piece is pure bliss. Share these cookies with your loved ones and indulge yourselves in our unique blends and flavors that will surely satisfy all your chocolate cravings.

Nothing says "Happy Birthday" like a box of heavenly chocolates. Make your special someone's birthday one to remember with this box of deliciousness. Hazel and Creme's cookie gift box is the perfect thoughtful gift for any birthday occasion. There's nothing more thoughtful and exciting than a rich, luscious box of chocolate.

The Hazel and Creme cookie gift box is shrink-wrapped for ultimate freshness and professionally packaged in an enticing modern box that is guaranteed to arrive in perfect condition, making it the perfect gift to impress any recipient. The box may come in black or gold, depending on availability.

Hazel and Creme's chocolate cookie boxes are truly one of a kind, from the beautiful packaging to the delicious flavors. The Kosher and dairy-free chocolate gift boxes are loved and appreciated by all. Enjoy our guilt-free chocolate that's just a click away! Hazel and Creme guarantees your satisfaction.

Pros

  • Indulge yourself and savor every bite into pure chocolate bliss
  • Hand-crafted and tested to ensure the best distinctive chocolate flavor
  • Tried and true, ensuring every piece is pure bliss
  • Perfect thoughtful gift for any birthday occasion
  • Shrink-wrapped for ultimate freshness and professionally packaged
  • Kosher and dairy-free

9. Cakecery Plants Vs Zombies 2021 Edible Cake Image Topper Personalized Birthday Cake Banner 1/4 Sheet

These cake sheets are perfect for adding a personalized touch to your occasion cake. Measuring about 8" x 11", they can fit a quarter sheet cake or be centered on a half sheet cake. You can be assured of the best quality on the planet as these sheets are printed on frosting sheet, not rice paper.

The quality of the edible frosting sheet and edible food coloring inks used is top-notch. They are allergen-free, gluten-free, and nut-free which makes them safe for everyone to consume.

Pros

  • Ideal for adding a personalized touch to your cake
  • Best quality on the planet
  • Allergen-free, gluten-free, and nut-free
  • Printed on frosting sheet, not rice paper

Best Grocery Store Birthday Cakes FAQs

Are grocery store birthday cakes fresh and of good quality?

Grocery store birthday cakes can vary greatly in terms of freshness and quality. Some grocery stores have in-house bakeries that produce fresh cakes daily, while others may rely on pre-made cakes that are frozen or shipped to the store. It's important to check the expiration date or ask the bakery staff when the cake was made to ensure you're getting a fresh cake.

In terms of quality, it really depends on the store and their bakery. Some grocery stores have excellent bakeries with skilled bakers who can produce high-quality cakes with fresh ingredients. However, other stores may prioritize affordability over quality and use lower-quality ingredients or pre-made mixes.

Overall, it's worth doing some research and asking around to find a grocery store with a good reputation for their bakery. Additionally, if you have specific dietary needs or preferences, be sure to ask about ingredient lists and customization options.

Can I customize the design of my grocery store birthday cake?

Yes, you can absolutely customize the design of your grocery store birthday cake! Most grocery stores that have a bakery department offer the option to customize cakes for special occasions, including birthdays. You can choose from a variety of cake flavors, frosting types, and decorations to create the perfect cake for your celebration. Some stores even offer the option to print a photo or image onto the cake to make it even more personalized. When placing your order, be sure to communicate your specific design requests to the bakery department so they can create the cake exactly how you envision it. Keep in mind that customizing a cake may come with an additional cost, so be sure to inquire about pricing before placing your order. Overall, customizing a grocery store birthday cake is a great way to add a personal touch to your celebration and make it even more special.

How much does a typical grocery store birthday cake cost?

The cost of a typical grocery store birthday cake can vary depending on the size, design, and location of the store. On average, a basic 8-inch round cake with simple decoration can cost around $15 to $20. However, if you want a larger cake or a more elaborate design, the cost can increase up to $50 or more. Some stores also offer personalized cakes with custom messages or images, which can add to the cost. It's important to keep in mind that prices can also vary based on geographic location and local competition. Some grocery stores may offer discounts or promotions for cakes, especially during holidays or special occasions. It's always a good idea to check with your local grocery store to get an accurate price for the specific cake you have in mind.

What are the different types of birthday cakes available at grocery stores?

There are various types of birthday cakes available at grocery stores, ranging from classic flavors to trendy and unique options. Some of the most common varieties include chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, red velvet, and carrot cake. For those who prefer something a bit more indulgent, there are options like chocolate fudge cake, chocolate peanut butter cake, and chocolate hazelnut cake. On the other hand, if you're looking for a lighter option, you might consider a fruit-based cake, such as lemon or raspberry. Many grocery stores also offer customized cakes, where you can choose the size, flavor, and design to fit your specific needs. Additionally, there are vegan, gluten-free, and dairy-free options available to cater to various dietary restrictions. With so many options to choose from, it's easy to find the perfect cake to celebrate any birthday occasion.

What is the process for ordering a grocery store birthday cake?

Ordering a grocery store birthday cake can be a simple and convenient process. Firstly, determine the size, flavor and design of the cake you want. You can browse through the cake catalog or speak to a bakery staff member to help you make your choice. Once you have made your decision, provide the bakery with the necessary details such as the name of the person celebrating the birthday, the date and time of the party, and any special instructions. You can also customize your cake by adding a personal message, a favorite character or a theme. After finalizing your order, make a deposit or pay the full amount to secure your cake. On the day of the party, pick up your cake or have it delivered to your location. Make sure to inspect the cake for any errors or damages before leaving the store. With these simple steps, you can have a delicious and delightful birthday cake ready for your celebration.

Leave a Comment