20 Best Eyeliner Pencil For Beginners (2023 Updated)

I absolutely love the NYX Retractable Eye Liner in Black. I have tried many different brands and none compare to this one. It’s very creamy and doesn’t smear like most brands. It lasts all day and the color is very pigmented.

For less than $5. 00 you really can’t beat the price. I will continue to purchase this product and highly recommend if you haven’t already. They have many different colors to choose from.

I absolutely love the black one!!!! It glides on so smooth, one swipe on the waterline and I’m done. It comes off easily with micellar water too. I have had a couple of issues with different colors, they have gone on chunky and broke several times, but I swear up and down about the black one.

It must have been bad batches with the different colored ones (I had the light purple one that was awful, the bronze one is decent but a little chunky). They just need to come out with a DARK GREEN (the olive one is atrocious).

But the black one is my holy grail.

This is my HOLY GRAIL eyeliner. I’m always surprised that it doesn’t get that much buzz. Believe me when I say I’ve tried every eyeliner known to man. This beats all the competition away. It truly lasts my entire day.

I NEVER have to reapply. It’s silky smooth and glides on. It’s very pigmented. It’s super easy to blend and smudge. It has a smudge brush/sponge at the other end that works great. Add in the affordable price and this easily gets 10/10.

I’ve been using this for at least eight years I have yet to find a better one!.

Unfortunately I cannot sharpen this without losing mass product. I always say that companies should foot the coin to include a sharpener for eyeliners that are like this. Chanel does and rightly so as other sharpeners don’t perform.

So I take my eyeliner brush and dip into the liner that comes out of the sharpener (it’s the size of a pea) and use it like that but I buy it for my waterline. I loathe stay put waterproof liner that transfers and this one does.

I’ve bought 10 of these and now I’m back to Urban Decay and Stila. Until I can find a Black waterproof long wearing liner from the drugstore. Milani has been disappointing me and this liner is just not worth it PERIOD This liner is IMPOSSIBLE to sharpen.

I lose a pea size amount each time so I have to dip my eyeliner brush in. I buy it for my upper waterline and it transfers to the bottom which makes me nuts. initially it was bomb but as I used it more it seemed like the quality went way down.

I’m noticing it with the entire line.

Sapphire. Beautiful vibrant, waterproof color. Eye pencil goes on very smoothly. Very long lasting and touch up can go be done right over top of your existing eye liner. The only thing this pencil is lacking is: it should be self sharpening or they should enclose a little disposable sharpener with it.

But with that being said, it is definitely worth the money and I will buy this item again. Thank you.

I was using the intense line which was phenomenal. This new line is terrible. Brittle, breaks with barely any tip exposed. There really is no other way to describe it then it’s just a really bad product.

The intense i-color was so so so so much better. I used to buy it all the time in multiple colors. Now I have to find a new product line that is truly hypoallergenic because I won’t buy anything from Almay again until they go back to the original formula.

Even the mascara has gone down hill with the formula change. so very disappointed. They were great products before.

Hello my Beauties!! I have found a must-have eyeliner that I must share with you!! Almay Gel Smooth Liner really is so very nice and smooth!! Glides on velvety soft and has such beautiful a color, I chose Navy.

Im about to go shopping and try to find some more colors!! I can’t say enough about how super smooth this Almay Gel Smooth Liner really is!! My absolute new fav eye liner!! I highly recommend Almay Gel Smooth Liner.

My skin and especially my eye areas are super-sensitive and allergic to nearly everything!! I have had not even a hint of allergic reaction to this awesome liner!! I highly recommend this Almay Gel Smooth Liner!! Happy Lining 🌸.

I have been using the all-day eyeliner pencil, Black Raisin, for YEARS! Ran out because I could not find it for a while & was so excited when I found it again. I recommended it to several friends and they loved it too.

I was soon disappointed. Ok so you changed the outside look but did you really need to change the color & formula?? Who had that bright idea? It’s now darker in color and does not apply the same. It used to glide on & was very easy to get a smudged look.

Now it’s not as creamy & doesn’t apply the same way. Gives a hearse look. PLEASE bring back the old color & formula. Very very disappointed.

I have a couple of “line-ups” for my make-up. Urban Decay, Too Faced, Physician’s Formula, NARS, they make-up my go-to make-ups when I’m going out, meeting up with friends, taking my kiddos, out. However, I “grew up” on Cover Girl, Maybelline, and Revlon.

These “drug store” make-ups are my go-tos. for when I’m staying home, or running a quick errand. No need to bust out the $30 eyeliner for a day at home with my babies! That’s where this eyeliner comes in! I have used this particular eyeliner for, well, over 20 years! Since I first started wearing eyeliner! Wow, that makes me feel old, haha.

This eyeliner gets the job done, goes on easily, and best of all, is affordable, while maintaining it’s decent quality! A tried and true eyeliner!.

I love using a black eyeliner to accentuate my lower lash line to make my face look more lively without having to put on a ton of make-up. I use the Maybelline Unstoppable eyeliner in Onyx religiously.

It is long lasting (stays on all day) yet wipes off easily at the end of the day when I’m ready for bed. I also like that the tip is thick enough to give sort of a smoldering effect, rather than being very pointy and drawing defined thin lines.

THIS EYE LINER NAMED COVER GIRL PERFECT BLEND IS THE VERY, VERY BEST EYE LINER EVER MADE IN THIS ENTIRE PLANET!!! I HAVE BEEN USING THIS SINCE 1993 I CAN’T FIND ANY OTHER EYE LINER TO COMPARE OR TO WORK AT ALL! I WANT THE WORLD TO KNOW THAT IT IS THE VERY BEST FOR TIGHT LINING IN THE INSIDE OF EYES NEAR LOWER LASHES, IT WILL NOT BUDGE OR SMEAR WHEN WORN THIS WAY! DO TRY THIS PRODUCT IF YOUR LOOKING FOR AN EYE LINER TO TIGHT LINE! I HAVE BEEN USING THIS ONLY THIS EYE LINER SINCE 1993! NOTHING CAN COMPARE TO THIS AMAZING EYE LINER.

NOT ONE! TRUST ME, I HAVE TRIED WHEN I THOUGHT THIS WAS UNAVAILABLE. I bought 10 of them today when I first found the product again. This is the BEST eye LINER known to man. This doesn’t run or smear, not even after swimming!! Please don’t EVER stop making this unbeatable eye liner.

To die for~.

I bought this in the shade “Smoky Taupe”. I bought this pretty much with the intent to use this as an eyeliner for ‘no makeup makeup days’ and I figured if I did not like this as an eyeliner, I would use this for brows.

First off, this does not seem to apply easily. Secondly, this does seem soft and creamy, yet does not apply very well nor easily. I have to go over and over my line to get any pigmentation to show up.

Same when using this for brows, I have to apply-apply-apply and apply-some-more-product, otherwise it looks like I ‘did nothing,’ not in a no makeup look kind of a way, but literally as nothing done.

For reference, I am currently around NC15. If you don’t mind fussing a lot with this, or this may very well be easy to use for you, this might be fine for you. But for me, this is ‘too fussy,’ for very little end result.

There is a smudger on the end, but I think that is better for some of the other shades. Finally, there is not much product in this. I bought this at Target for around $4. 00USD (the pencil itself is rather short, when taking the smudger and caps into consideration), which does seem/is rather inexpensive, but for me, I find I have to use a LOT of product per use, so if I did love this product, I would go through one of these in a hot minute.

so in that regard, the price per ounce or whatever actually is not that ‘cheap’ as it seems. if I liked this a lot and used this regularly, I would probably go through one of these in 2 or 3 weeks, because I need to apply so much of this product in order to get it to even remotely show up.

Not sure if the other shades are the same, but this is my findings with Smoky Taupe. Would not repurchase.

This is a simple product that saves the environment a bit – it has a smudge tip built in on one side. Once you line your eye, you use the other side, a soft dense spongelike material to smudge the line a bit – works perfectly.

I even use it for my other eyeliner products. Great idea the eyeliner works well – doesn’t seem to last as long as a liquid, but has a different look, so it’s whatever look you are going for. I have purchased more than once.

This eyeliner is absolute perfection! I was a little weary about spending so much on an eyeliner, but I’d seen so many people raving about it so decided to bite the bullet and purchase one. I chose the shade Eros as it was different to others I have, and loved the idea of a burgundy eyeliner (although this pulls more aubergine on me which I have no clue how!), and the colour is stunning! It lasts all day, doesn’t smudge, can use it on your waterline as well as on the lid.

The texture is super smooth so doesn’t tug at all, and glides on like a dream! You also have a sharpener in the end of the liner to sharpen the tip if you’re creating a nice flick. I’m on my 3rd tube of the shade Eros because it’s just so beautiful and it’s my holy grail! I did also purchase Rose Gold and unfortunately doesn’t seem to last as long as Eros, but it could just be because it’s not as deep a colour.

If you go to get one shade, Eros won’t disappoint you AT ALL! Nothing compares to this, and I’m a proper drugstore makeup lover!.

This smooth, gliding eyeliner is truly worth it. Once I apply, it stays in place and lasts a long time, especially if you have concealer and primer in place. I like to use it for a special night or a night out.

I have the Noir Intense and it truly is the darkest color (black) available. It makes my eyes pop! It’s also waterproof. Even with sweat, sebum, etc. it stays in place. Yes, it’s expected to be pricey since it’s Chanel but it’s Made in Italy and you can feel the quality.

I have no complaints and it’s just a perfect add-on to all your makeup essentials.

The MAC color excess pencil the name of the color is glide or die as rich black color. It has the consistency of a gel. Feels like a crayon when you glided over your lid. The black color is the richest I have seen and it’s very bold.

This is a twist type of pencil that you can twist to give you more pencil or twist to put away. So far I have worn the pencil for 24 hours without any smudges. I have also worried for 24 hours into my waterline without having any trips to my skin area.

It glides very easily to my lid without transferring to the upper top of my under-brow area. Personally, I’m always looking for a pencil that I can place in my lid area without having it a few hours later transfer to the top of the lid area.

Also is really hard to find a pencil that can cover completely my waterline and not transfer to the bottom skin area and this pencil does a great job of staying in place and not transferring and making me look like a raccoon.

For the sake of testing the product I did wear it throughout my sleep and I was surprised that it did not transfer to my sheets or my pillowcase. I did a comparison between my L’oreal pencil and this MAC pencil and it was a big difference when it comes to durability and how long it stays on my lid and my waterline, this MAC pencil did stay longer.

I did go to the KEYs a very humid and sunny beach area in Florida and despite all that, the makeup did stay in place all day. The benefit of owning this pencil it’s that you really don’t have to deal with a brush to apply the eyeliner you just grab the pencil push it out and slide it really easily with just this one product, no need for a separate brush.

Is very easy to use and convenient. I would buy this product as I use a lot of eyeliner more than eyeshadow. My sister recommended me to use L’oreal for the long-lasting and I’m being waterproof, but this one is definitely a better choice when it comes to durability, long-lasting effect and water proof.

Will recommend to her and her friends.

This gel pencil was very beautiful on the eyes. It did drag and tug and pull a little while trying to make a wing on the outer corner of my eyes, I messed up the first time I tried and I had to wipe it off and start over.

It felt hard to control at first because of that, which is the reason I’m not giving it 5 stars. After a while of testing out ways to use it without tugging my skin too bad, I was able to make fairly even and nice winged eyeliner.

And it lasted from morning to night! It didn’t last overnight, but I suspect I had watery eyes and my face in my pillows too much, which made it smudge slightly. But the overall shape stayed, and would only need touch ups to fix and wear out! Compared to other products I’ve tried, this product has a really nice and pigmented formula that lasts a lot longer than most others.

I always test gel pencils or eyeliners on the back of my hand too, and try and smudge them, but this one didn’t smudge, even right after applying it! If it wasn’t for the tugging and messing up in the beginning, I would have given 5 stars.

But maybe that’s user error, so that could be my fault. This product is great though and I definitely recommend it and would consider purchasing again in the future when I need a new one.

I loved this eyeliner. And I especially loved this color. Serial Monogamist is a very dark army green color. At first glance it’s almost gray. But when the light hits right, you can see those dark green tones.

It’s the perfect way to add something interesting to a look while still keeping it an “every day” look. I just really loved the versatility of this color. On top of that. The gel pencil formula in itself is pretty great.

Once it sets it stay put really well, it is realy long wearing. I don’t tend to smudge my eyeliner that often, but if you do, I recommend going in straight away and doing so right after applying. This gel pencil will smudge, but it gives you a small window of opportunity to work with, if you let it set, that’s it.

Besides that, this is a retractable pencil. So keep in mind that keeping it sharp will be an issue. It doesn’t come with one of those tiny pencil sharpeners hidden at the end of the pencil or in the cap.

So you have to figure it out yourself. In my opinion that’s the biggest inconvenience. Still, the positives outweigh this one negative. I really do enjoy this pencil and I highly recommend it!.

I had never purchased many Pixi products before, but since I’m a fan of Hello Kitty, and this brand recently came out with some limited Hello Kitty items, I dove in. The liner I have is in the shade Fog.

I really love the easy way this glides over your eye. It’s very smooth and the color is subtle but it still very pigmented. The only thing I really don’t like is that it comes as a pencil that needs to be sharpened.

I have sharpened it twice and have found that I lose quite a lot of the product. The pencil doesn’t sharpen cleanly, and there are areas that have jagged pieces. Also, since the crayon itself is creamy it has broken off as I am lining, and I do not use a lot of pressure when lining my eyes.

I feel like this is not worth the money I spent simply because I’m losing half the product when I sharpen.

This is very nice, very soft gel pencil. I have them in two shades: Sage Gold and Copper Glow. Copper Glow is absolutely stunning shade. It’s highly pigmented with a lot of sparkles in it. It’s perfect for waterline and to create wings.

Sage Gold has less pigment, I can’t use it on my waterline. But it’s okay if I want to create subtle wings. These pencils are long-lasting and waterproof, they don’t irritate my eyes. But they are very soft and I have to be careful when I sharpen them.

I went to go put this on and the whole tip broke off. I was super gentle (so gentle there was barely any color on my lid – see picture, totally not kidding) but my hand got a ton of pigment when I went to fish the broken tip out of my eyelashes BECAUSE it’s so silky (yay?) I’m glad I wasn’t trying to lashine or do my waterline.

Overall, not off to a great start and I can’t image this thing is going to sharpen well. If you’re going to make a pencil THIS soft, make it a twist so it has some support. 😐 probably not even going to attempt to sharpen it at this point.

Not stoked about the idea of trying this again. Plus it’s chonky. No level of precision is possible between the size and sheer smooshiness of this thing. If it smudged nicely so you could blend it out, I’d get it, but it doesn’t blend so much as.

flake? Particle? Idk. Not a fan and not what I was hoping for. But I’ll give it one star for the color range and one for the overall feel. It does glide nicely and has a solid pigmentation to it. on my hand, anyway.

It just also crumbles, apparantly.

I was so excited when this arrived. I’d heard such great things about this liner, and when I heard it was used by some of my favorite drag stars, I ordered it immediately. I should let you know that I am an older woman with some- but not much- minor age issues with my eyelid skin.

I don’t have crow’s feet or extensive wrinkling. But there are some tiny lines (vertical) on my upper eyelid. You need a 20x magnifying mirror to see them, but they are there. I tend to have quite watery eyes.

I am also an MUA, and have been wearing a lot of (as in lining the entire outside of my eye) eyeliner for at least 30 years. I’ve tried many, many, many eyeliners- liquid, crime, cake, pencil; brush and felt tip.

So I’m well acquainted with eyeliner and it’s various properties. I do NOT recommend this product for anyone who does not have perfectly taut, young eyelid skin. I don’t care what your age is- if this liner encounters any texture, it’s going to instantly run into any minor line (no matter how minor) and you’ll be left with a big smudgy mess.

It was impossible, with this very watery (but nicely opaque) formula to draw on and maintain any line. It just “feathered” away. My eyes also instantly began watering. I don’t know if this liner is positioned as water-resistant or waterproof, but let me tell you- it is NOT.

I was left with a dissipated gray watery mess instead of any type of line. I was so disappointed. I really like Haus as a company, and I’m certain I would rave about other products they sell. But I absolutely cannot recommend this liner (sadly.

).

I was beyond presently surprised by this product. This is my second/third product from testoque, my first being their shadow sticks and those just didn’t really do it for me all the way. And reviews on this brand have been so mixed I just didn’t know what to expect.

But let me tell you I LOVE this product. You can get an amazing smokey eye, line you waterline confidently and it smudges amazing but once set doesn’t go anywhere. This eyeliner is just incredible and I am in love.

It’s pigmented, firm yet creamy, and is a beautiful true black. The only downside is the included sharpener is too big and breaks the liner too easily. I had to use a different, smaller sharper to successfully get the tip I desired.

But overall I 100% reccomdend this product!!.

This is a must have eyeliner. It’s my second favorite eyeliner. The formula glides on like a dream, but doesn’t tend to smudge as much as other gel liners. It’s a perfect balance between easy application and staying power.

It doesn’t skip or pull like a lot of liners do, and it stays fresh without drying up like a lot of other liners do, so you can actually use up the product and not have to replace it when it’s only half gone.

The shade Roman Bronze was recommended to me by the trestique team and I am just in love with this shade. I’ve gone through many eyeliner color phases in my life but I feel this shade helps to open up my eyes and is just gorgeous.

The color is super blend-able and while I’m not too much of a stickler for whether my eyeliner travels or not, I prefer eyeliner that is easy to wash off at the end of the day. Sadly, one of my pencils arrived to me a little too warm maybe (by no fault of trestique) and I was eager to try sharpening it it, but accidentally broke it.

I took the broken piece though and popped it back into the tube to use anyway. I’m a little hesitant to try sharpening it again, so I think it might work better if you make sure the product is cool first if you sharpen it.

The smudger being removable is AMAZING. On all of my full size trestique products, I like to remove the blenders at the same time to clean them all. Overall, I’m very happy with this product and will be repurchasing!.

is a good product if you like liquid liners with precise brush tips and also like applying retractable liners to your waterline. I recently saw this on Influenster and since I am already a fan of #Revlon, I knew I had to give this a try.

It’s basically two products for the price of one, and an affordable price at that. I purchased mine a few days ago and I used the liquid end to create a wing on my upper lids and instantly fell in love with it’s fine brush which made application fairly easy and I used the kohl end for my waterline.

The benefits for me outweigh the flaws. The liners both applied well and lasted all day. I didn’t have to apply over and over again and touch-up was minimal. The only flaw I experienced was since the liquid liner brush is shorter than the typical fullsize liquid liner brushes.

I noticed a little bit of errors when applying an elongated wing that reached to my inner corner and I noticed my knuckle getting in the way of my face and eyelid, but this can be remedied by a slight tilting of the hand.

Overall I gave this duo four stars. I would’ve given it five stars had the liquid liner brush been just a little longer. I would definitely recommend this product to friends, family, and other’s here on Influenster looking for a good and rich duo of liquid and kohl liner.

I purchased mine in the shade 151 Black, I believe, which is the shade I like best, but there are other shades available.

I have seen so many amazing reviews about this Revlon Colorstay Line Creator Double Ended Liner and I received it in 151 Blackout from BeautyCrew to review. Unfortunately, I am one of the minority who did not fall in love with this liner.

What I love? I love that the liquid liner is a dark black and is long lasting, as it claimed to be. It does not smudge very much throughout the day and I find it quite resistant to rubbing. The crayon khol side is more of a dark grey-ish black and contains some glitter, giving a subtle shine when the light hits it.

Both eyeliners are slightly waterproof. I also love the double ended concept so that I can easily carry it around with me in my pouch and update my makeup look throughout the day. What I did not like? However, I personally find that the crayon khol smudges badly on my oily and hooded eyelid, giving me panda eyes at the end of the day.

I also find the brush on the longwear liquid side hard to use, especially for those who are makeup beginners. Because the brush is so soft and long, it was really hard to draw a thin precise line (which is usually what I prefer for my daily eyeliner look).

It does work better if you are drawing a thicker liner and you can easily layer it on without caking up. In my opinion, I think this Double Ended Liner would suit those who does not have oily or hooded eyelids and anyone with more makeup experience since I find the soft brush a little hard to maneuver.

Nevertheless, I do love the double ended concept for its convenience and it is a product with good value. I also find trying to set the liner in with a little eyeshadow powder afterwards helped a little in preventing smudging for a longer period.

I totally loved eyeliner. I think it has an amazing combination of price and quality. It has a great pigmentation, easy to use and super versatile due to being both eyeliner and pencil. It stays all day without smudging and doesn’t irritate my eyes as I have very sensitive around eye area skin.

The texture is very creamy and easy to apply. I especially loved pencil side as when you apply it you can smudge it for a smoky eye type of make up. Due to having two different ends You can create many different looks with this product which is super great! I normally buy my eyeliners from a more high end make up brands but it is great to find a great product from drug store range which is very accessible.

Also for a price of one you are actually getting two products. Another Revlon product that didn’t disappoint.

I usually don’t wear a lot of eyeliner. I have small, hooded eyes so black eyeliner usually makes my eyes look smaller. I’ve tried liquid eyeliners in brown and I always struggle with them. I found this eyeliner during Ulta’s 21 days of beauty for half off and decided to try it.

It’s very thin and a dark brown color. It’s very smooth when applying and I just add it to my top eye line to define it a little bit more before mascara. I do use Nars eye primer and it stays on all day.

I highly recommend this if you are looking for something very minimal to lightly line your eyes with that will last all day. Plus it’s vegan and made from mineral pigments!.

I thought this was going to be boring to try and review but I ended up loving this product. The quality is amazing! It glides on so nice and easy. The pigmentation is definitely there! It’s such a rich, dark, matte black that goes on so even and so beautiful.

What I really love is that it is ACTUALLY waterproof! I applied it to my hand and I could smudge it for a few seconds, but after that it would not budge at all! I put my hand under running water and then rubbed my hand while it was under running water and after I pulled it out.

It still did not budge. It looked like I just applied it. I wore it all day and it still looked fresh! However, with a little makeup remover, it came right off so easily. Isn’t that all we want in an eyeliner?! Pigmentation, glides on easy, stays on all day, and easy to remove! So many other brands that claim to be water and budge proof are as long as you’re not too hard on them but with this one you could cry hard and wipe your eyes and your eyeliner will still look fresh AF! I would absolutely recommend this to family and friends.

I would defiantly purchase this, especially if black or brown eyeliner is something I use often. Actually, I want the brown one now! I received this in exchange for my honest review and my review IS 100% honest.

I initially bought this in Garnet and then later bought the Diamond colour, and am waiting for Copper to come back into stock. I like the Diamond as a subtle shimmer above mascara, but the Garnet is more distinctive and matches my brown eyes well, bringing out their amber tinge.

I tried the other colours in the shop, but these three were my favourite for brown eyes and pale skin. My only problem with it is that you need to hold it perpendicular to the surface you’re drawing on, because it can snap when drawn along at an angle.

It is a crayon, not a pencil, and I do like how gently it draws on my eyelids, so I understand why it’s a little bit fragile.

This liner works, but it’s not as consistent as I preferred with the old formula; which I was influenced by Mel Thompson years ago an bought multiples of these pencils For me, I use pencil liners to tightline and to line the waterline; I tend to use other types of liners for a wing, so this is specific to my preferences.

I found the first time I tried this, it was quite drying, which doesn’t work well for the areas I want to apply. But after sharpening it, I found it to be a bit more creamy. Ultimately, it worked the best for me, when the tip actually fell and it was flat.

This happened after sharpening it and then applying too much pressure. I really enjoyed their previous formula, which I think held on to my waterline and lash line better than this new formula. Although I can see myself using this, it does not surpass in quality to my Makeup Forever pencil, which I’ve been enjoying.

I am glad to have received this complementary, but unless something changes, I will not repurchase with my own money.

I am so excited about this creamy, longwear eyeliner from Milk. The INFINITY Longwear Eyeliner is very creamy and totally waterproof. The color I have been using and love is TIME. It is a beautiful royal blue.

This liner twists-up and glides on smoothly with no pulling and lasts up to 12 hours. It has been roasting hot and humid here the past week and this liner still stays on all day long without budging.

It even has a built in sharpener for more precise application. I like how this lets me create different looks including a winged, smokey or smudgy look. This color is gorgeous. I love that this is also infused with avocado oil and ceramides to help really provide a smooth application.

This has the added benefit of being completely vegan. I feel good about using it every day.

I have hooded lids and this is the ONLY eyeliner that does not smudge on my eyelid. I have tried everything – Urban Decay 24/7, Pat McGrath, Bobbie Brown gel, Marc Jacobs gel eyeliner, NARS, Benefit gel eyeliner, MAC,etc.

I have tried them all and none compare. It goes on smoothly and stays until I take it off. I can wear it when I work out and even slept with it on once and while it faded a bit but did not smudge! The only thing is you have to twist the pencil down before you put the cap on if it protrudes just a bit it may break off when you open it.

I also haven’t tried the built in sharpener yet – usually not a fan of these – the sharpener opening is so small that you cannot get the pencil in to sharpen properly. But it’s a small issue after spending so much time and money looking for the perfect eyeliner! I am actually online to buy a back-up!.

I love how dark it is, I brought the darkest color available because it works the best for brown skin. I also really love the soft point of the pencil, I’ve tried brands were it was way too pointy and made application uncomfortable.

I don’t have any negatives for this product. It’s a good product and a good price.

Being on a slightly tighter budget at times, I’m always on the hunt for a good deal, but I don’t like sacrificing quality just to save a few dollars. E. l. f brand makeup has helped me find the perfect in between.

E. l. f has some quality products, and they’re super affordable, a great value! This eyeliner saved me so much money, and it’s a deep shade of black, it doesn’t fade! The liner has a very smooth texture, making application easy and quick.

I keep the eyeliner in my clutch bag with me at all times! It even has a sharpener conveniently attached to the lid. I will most certainly be continuing to use this eyeliner pencil and other e. l. f products, and I would reccomend anyone else do the same.

I love this eyeliner pencil, one of the best I’ve found. Compact size, so easy to grab and take with you. Applies easily and stays pretty well throughout the day. Love that the cap also has a sharpener so it’s an all in one.

And the price is great!.