When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Dark Rum For Eggnog (2024 Updated)

If you’re looking for a way to spice up your eggnog this holiday season, why not try adding some dark rum? Not only will it add a unique and delicious flavor to your drink, but it will also give it a little extra kick. But before diving in and purchasing any old dark rum, there are a few factors to consider.

First, consider the flavor profile of the rum. Dark rums can range from sweet and caramel-like to smoky and spicy. Depending on your personal taste preferences, you may want to opt for a rum with a more complex flavor profile or one that is more subtle. Additionally, consider what other ingredients you may be adding to your eggnog and choose a rum that will complement them.

Next, think about the quality of the rum. While you don’t necessarily need to break the bank on a high-end bottle, it’s important to choose a rum that is of decent quality. Look for rum that has been aged for at least a few years and has a smooth, rich taste.

Are you curious about how different brands of dark rum will affect the flavor of your eggnog? How do you know if a rum is high-quality or not? What are some other ways you can use dark rum in your holiday cocktails? Keep reading to find out!

10 Best Dark Rum For Eggnog

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
Ideal for making zero proof cocktails with a rum flavor, without the calories and sugar.
2
It is an ideal substitute for vanilla extract in cooking and baking, with a water-based and alcohol-free formula.
3
This product is ideal for flavoring baked goods and beverages with the natural taste of rum.
4
It is ideal for adding a rich and authentic rum flavor to baked goods, desserts, and beverages.
5
The product is ideal for adding a rich, rum flavor to baked goods, desserts and drinks.
6
It is an ideal ingredient for adding a rich and complex flavor to baked goods, drinks, and desserts.
7
Ideal as a sugar-free syrup for adding butter rum flavor to beverages and desserts.
8
Ideal for adding a rich buttery and rum flavor to various drinks, desserts, and baked goods.
9
This product is ideal for adding a rum flavor to baked goods, desserts, fruit-based dishes, sauces, and more.
10
Ideal for those who want to enjoy alcohol-free cocktails with an award-winning, sustainably made spirit that has only 5 calories.
Ideal for making zero proof cocktails with a rum flavor, without the calories and sugar.
It is an ideal substitute for vanilla extract in cooking and baking, with a water-based and alcohol-free formula.
This product is ideal for flavoring baked goods and beverages with the natural taste of rum.
It is ideal for adding a rich and authentic rum flavor to baked goods, desserts, and beverages.
The product is ideal for adding a rich, rum flavor to baked goods, desserts and drinks.
It is an ideal ingredient for adding a rich and complex flavor to baked goods, drinks, and desserts.
Ideal as a sugar-free syrup for adding butter rum flavor to beverages and desserts.
Ideal for adding a rich buttery and rum flavor to various drinks, desserts, and baked goods.
This product is ideal for adding a rum flavor to baked goods, desserts, fruit-based dishes, sauces, and more.
Ideal for those who want to enjoy alcohol-free cocktails with an award-winning, sustainably made spirit that has only 5 calories.

1. Arkay Dark Rum: Zero Calorie Alcohol Alternative

ArKay Alcohol-Free RUM is a great option for those who want to enjoy a cocktail without having alcohol. It is a Halal beverage that is suitable for those who are on medication or have compromised immune systems. Nowadays, it is common for guests to prefer non-alcoholic drinks, and ArKay offers the perfect solution for them. You can create amazing zero-proof cocktails with ArKay, which has the same flavor, mouthfeel, heat, and aroma as its alcoholic counterparts. ArKay swaps 1 to 1 with any of your favorite cocktails. ArKay is not suitable for children, and it is a sophisticated alternative for those who want complexity without alcohol. ArKay is crafted, not distilled, which means it is 100% alcohol-free. It has all-natural flavors and ingredients with no allergens, sugar, fat, carbs, sweeteners or alcohol. ArKay Alcohol-Free RUM has won the Award winner by Scottish Spirits Association. ArKay is more than a ritual; it is a spirit alternative that provides the same flavor and experience as the original, without the alcohol.

Pros

  • Halal beverage suitable for those who are on medication or have compromised immune systems
  • Perfect for guests who prefer non-alcoholic drinks
  • Offers the same flavor, mouthfeel, heat, and aroma as its alcoholic counterparts
  • Can be used to create amazing zero-proof cocktails
  • Crafted, not distilled, meaning it is 100% alcohol-free
  • All-natural flavors and ingredients with no allergens, sugar, fat, carbs, sweeteners or alcohol
  • ArKay Alcohol-Free RUM has won the Award winner by Scottish Spirits Association

Cons

  • – Not suitable for children
  • – May not be preferred by those who want an alcoholic beverage

2. Watkins Rum Extract With Other Natural Flavors, 2 Oz. Bottles, Pack Of 6 (Packaging May Vary)

Introducing the perfect addition to your baking and beverage needs, this product is a must-have for anyone who loves to experiment with flavors. Made with all-natural ingredients, it is free from any artificial colors or flavors, ensuring that you are getting only the best. This product is non-GMO, gluten-free, and corn syrup-free, making it a great choice for anyone with dietary restrictions. It is also certified kosher, making it suitable for those who follow a kosher diet. Crafted with care in the USA, this product is of the highest quality.

This product also comes with safe handling instructions. It is recommended to store it in a cool, dry place to ensure that it remains fresh and flavorful for as long as possible.

Pros

  • Made with all-natural ingredients
  • Free from artificial colors and flavors
  • Non-GMO, gluten-free, and corn syrup-free
  • Certified kosher
  • Crafted in the USA
  • Safe handling instructions included

3. Olivenation Pure Rum Flavor – 4 Ounces – Premium Quality Pure Baking Extract With Finest Rum Flavor

If you're looking to add a rich, deep, and authentic rum flavor to your baked goods, then OliveNation Rum Flavor is the perfect choice. Extracted from Myer's White and other fine rums, this clear flavoring extract is ideal for use in cakes, cookies, fillings, frostings, sauces, puddings, and more. It's also versatile enough to be used in both hot and cold beverages, such as eggnog, coffee, cocoa, and smoothies.

This rum extract is made with high-quality, natural ingredients and is Non-GMO, Certified Kosher, Vegan, and Gluten-Free. Its water-soluble, clear formulation makes it easy to use and blend into any recipe without altering the color or texture of the finished product. With OliveNation Rum Flavor, you can enjoy the true taste of rum without any alcohol content.

Pros

  • Extracted from Myer's White and other fine rums for authentic flavor
  • Ideal for use in baking and cooking recipes such as cakes, cookies, fillings, frostings, sauces, and puddings
  • Can be used in both hot and cold beverages such as eggnog, coffee, cocoa, and smoothies
  • Non-GMO, Certified Kosher, Vegan, and Gluten-Free
  • Water-soluble, clear formulation that blends easily into any recipe

4. Mccormick Rum Extract With Other Natural Flavors, 2 Fl Oz

This rum extract from McCormick comes in a 2 fl. oz. bottle, which is 2x more than their 1 fl. oz. option, and has a bold rum flavor that is perfect for baking and cooking. It contains no corn syrup, is non-GMO, and gluten-free, making it a great choice for those with dietary restrictions. Additionally, it contains no artificial flavors or colors, ensuring a natural taste every time.

This extract is versatile and can be used for mocktails by adding a few drops into frozen, blended piña coladas for a tasty non-alcoholic drink. It can also be used as a substitution for light or dark rum in recipes, with ½ tsp of extract being equal to 1 tbsp of light rum, and 1 ½ tsp being equal to 1 tbsp of dark rum. McCormick has been a trusted brand for over 125 years, so you can be confident in the quality of this product.

Pros

  • 2x more rum extract than the 1 fl. oz. bottle
  • Bold rum flavor
  • No corn syrup
  • Non-GMO
  • Gluten-free
  • No artificial flavors or colors
  • Versatile for use in mocktails and as a substitution for rum
  • Trusted brand for over 125 years

5. Cook's, Choice Pure Rum Extract, 4 Oz

Experience the rich and alluring flavor of Fine Meyer's Rum with this specially crafted flavoring. The 4oz. resealable amber glass bottle ensures safe and convenient storage, while providing a premium look to the product. Made from all-natural and gluten-free ingredients, this flavoring is also vegan and kosher certified, making it accessible to a wider audience. Whether you prefer to use it sparingly or generously, this flavoring is available in a range of sizes from 2oz. to 32oz., perfect for all your culinary needs.

Pros

  • Made from all-natural, gluten-free, vegan and kosher ingredients
  • Conveniently packaged in a resealable amber glass bottle for safe storage
  • Available in multiple sizes to meet all culinary needs
  • Crafted using Fine Meyer's Rum for an authentic and rich flavor

6. Davinci Gourmet Butter Rum Sugar Free Syrup 25.4 Fl Oz.

Indulge in the rich and creamy flavor of rum-infused butter without the guilt with DaVinci Sugar Free Butter Rum Syrup. This non-alcoholic syrup is perfect for adding a delicious twist to your favorite beverages without adding any extra calories, fat, sugar, or carbs. Each 25.4 oz bottle is packed with sweet, buttery goodness that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you feeling satisfied.

Whether you're looking to sweeten up your morning coffee, add a flavorful twist to your afternoon tea, or create a decadent dessert topping, DaVinci Sugar Free Butter Rum Syrup is the perfect choice. And with its convenient packaging, you can easily take it with you wherever you go.

So why settle for boring, flavorless drinks when you can enjoy the delicious taste of DaVinci Sugar Free Butter Rum Syrup? Try it today and discover a whole new world of flavor!

Pros

  • Sugar-free, fat-free, calorie-free, and carbohydrate-free
  • Rich and creamy flavor of rum-infused butter
  • Convenient packaging for on-the-go use

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for those with allergies to certain artificial sweeteners

7. Torani Butter Rum Syrup 750ml

Indulge in the rich and flavorful taste of Torani Italian Syrup, made with the finest ingredients to ensure a premium quality product. This versatile syrup is perfect for creating specialty coffee drinks, espresso drinks, iced teas, Italian sodas, and more. Its smooth texture and authentic taste will transport you to the streets of Italy with every sip.

With Torani Italian Syrup, you can experience an array of delectable flavors such as caramel, hazelnut, peppermint, vanilla and many more. Whether you are a coffee lover, tea enthusiast or just looking for a way to add some extra flavor to your drinks, Torani Italian Syrup is a perfect choice. Its easy-to-use pump bottle allows you to dispense just the right amount of syrup and the bottle's sleek design will complement any kitchen or coffee shop.

Made without any artificial flavors, preservatives, or high fructose corn syrup, Torani Italian Syrup is a healthier alternative to many other flavored syrups on the market. It is also Kosher certified which makes it suitable for a wide range of dietary needs. With its long shelf life, you can stock up on your favorite flavors and enjoy them for months to come.

Elevate your morning coffee or afternoon tea with Torani Italian Syrup and savor the authentic taste of Italy in your own home. Try it today and experience the difference.

Pros

  • Made with the finest ingredients for a premium quality product
  • Versatile syrup suitable for a variety of drinks
  • Easy-to-use pump bottle for accurate dispensing
  • Sleek design complements any kitchen or coffee shop
  • Free from artificial flavors, preservatives, and high fructose corn syrup
  • Kosher certified for a wider range of dietary needs
  • Long shelf life for extended use

8. Bake Like A Pro With Mccormick Rum!

The Imitation Rum Extract is the perfect substitute for dark or light rum that provides a subtle sugary aroma and flavor to any dish. This rum flavoring extract is crafted using premium ingredients to enhance the taste of your food. It features a pleasant orangey color that adds a lovely sweetness to your dishes. Each bottle contains 16 fluid ounces of concentrated and versatile rum flavoring that's perfect for chefs' recipes. You can use it to flavor desserts, sauces, and baked goods. The bottle comes ready to use, and you can dispense individual drops or larger amounts by unscrewing the top.

The rum flavoring is a concentrated ingredient that won't affect your dish's texture, making it ideal for all kinds of menu items that call for rum. You can substitute 2 teaspoons of this extract for 1 tablespoon of dark rum or 1 tablespoon of extract for 5 tablespoons of light rum. The kosher and gluten-free ingredients make it a feel-good rum flavoring that you can enjoy yourself or serve to your guests. Even after cooking at high temperatures, the delicious imitation flavors are retained in your dishes.

Pros

  • Subtle sugary aroma and flavor that enhances the taste of your dishes.
  • Premium ingredients used to craft the rum flavoring extract.
  • Concentrated and versatile rum flavoring that's perfect for chefs' recipes.
  • Ready-to-use bottle that dispenses individual drops or larger amounts.
  • Kosher and gluten-free ingredients make this a feel-good rum flavoring.
  • The delicious imitation flavors are retained even after cooking at high temperatures.

9. Zero Proof Spirit: Award-Winning Alcohol-Free Rum Alternative.

If you love cocktails but want to avoid alcohol or calories, then Ritual spirits have got you covered. Their non-alcoholic rum alternative is perfect for replacing traditional rum 1:1 in the drinks you already know and love. However, keep in mind that this product is specifically designed for cocktails and is not meant to be consumed straight or neat.

Ritual spirits offer all the warm vanilla, toasted spice, and velvety decadence of dark rum without the alcohol or calories, making it a healthier option for conscious drinkers. Moreover, it is an award-winning flavor, certified 88/100 Silver by the industry standard Beverage Testing Institute.

This product is perfect for those who are looking for a non-alcoholic option that is designed for their lifestyle. It is great for people who are driving, training, dieting, parenting, staying out late, getting up early, seeking the perfect third drink, or abstaining altogether. With Ritual spirits, you can enjoy your favorite cocktails without the alcohol.

Whether you prefer non-alcoholic classics like mojitos, pina coladas, daiquiris, and mai tais, or inspired mixology, or simple serves with soda or juice, Ritual spirits have got you covered. Try it today and enjoy your favorite cocktails without the alcohol.

Pros

  • A healthier alternative to traditional rum
  • Perfect for conscious drinkers
  • Award-winning flavor
  • Great for non-alcoholic cocktails
  • Suitable for different lifestyles and situations

Cons

  • – Not suitable for drinking straight or neat

Best Dark Rum For Eggnog FAQs

Can spiced dark rum be used in eggnog?

Yes, spiced dark rum can definitely be used in eggnog. In fact, it is a popular choice for those who enjoy a bit of added flavor and warmth in their holiday drink. The rich, sweet and spicy notes of spiced dark rum complement the creamy and nutmeg flavors of eggnog perfectly. However, it is important to keep in mind the amount of rum used in the eggnog, as too much alcohol can overpower the other flavors and ruin the drink. It is recommended to add a small amount of spiced dark rum and adjust according to personal preference. Additionally, it is important to use a high-quality spiced dark rum to ensure a delicious and enjoyable drink. Overall, spiced dark rum is a great choice for those looking to add a little extra holiday cheer to their eggnog.

How much dark rum should be added to eggnog?

The amount of dark rum to add to eggnog ultimately depends on personal preference and how strong you want the flavor to be. However, a general rule of thumb is to add 1-2 ounces of rum per serving of eggnog. It's important to keep in mind that rum is a strong spirit, so adding too much can overpower the flavor of the eggnog. It's also important to use a high-quality dark rum that complements the flavor of the eggnog. Some popular choices include Jamaican or spiced rum. When adding the rum, it's best to do so slowly and taste as you go to ensure you achieve the desired flavor balance. Overall, adding a splash of dark rum to eggnog can enhance the flavor and make for a delicious holiday treat.

Should the dark rum be added before or after the eggnog is chilled?

The timing of adding dark rum to eggnog depends on personal preference. Some people prefer to add the rum before chilling the eggnog, whereas others prefer to add it after the eggnog has been chilled.

If you add the rum before chilling, the flavors will have time to meld together as the mixture cools down. This can result in a more cohesive flavor profile. However, if you add the rum after chilling, the alcohol will be more pronounced since it won't have had time to blend in with the other ingredients.

Ultimately, the decision of when to add the rum comes down to personal taste. If you prefer a more mellow, integrated flavor, add the rum before chilling. If you want a stronger alcohol kick, add it after chilling. Regardless of when you add the rum, be sure to stir the mixture well to ensure that the alcohol is evenly distributed throughout the eggnog.

What are some alternative spirits that can be used instead of dark rum in eggnog?

Eggnog is a traditional festive drink that is typically made with dark rum. However, if you're not a fan of rum, or if you want to try something new, there are several alternative spirits that can be used instead. One option is brandy, which has a similar flavor profile to rum but is less sweet. Another option is bourbon, which adds a smoky, vanilla flavor to the drink. For a lighter, fruitier taste, you could try using a fruit brandy or liqueur, such as cherry or apricot. If you prefer a non-alcoholic version, you can substitute the rum with apple cider or ginger ale. Whatever alternative spirit you choose, be sure to adjust the amount accordingly to ensure a balanced flavor. Happy eggnog-making!

What is the best dark rum to use in eggnog?

When it comes to making the perfect eggnog, choosing the right dark rum is crucial. The best dark rum for this classic holiday drink is one that is rich and full-bodied, with notes of caramel, vanilla, and spice. One of the most popular choices is Gosling's Black Seal Rum. This Bermuda-based brand has been producing high-quality dark rum since 1806 and is known for its smooth, complex flavor. Another great option is Myers's Original Dark Rum, which is made from Jamaican molasses and has a bold, intense flavor that pairs well with the sweetness of eggnog. Other dark rums that are worth considering include Appleton Estate Reserve Rum, Mount Gay Eclipse Rum, and Bacardi 8 Year Old Rum. Ultimately, the best dark rum for your eggnog will depend on your personal taste preferences, so don't be afraid to experiment until you find the perfect match.

Leave a Comment