If you’re looking for something to add a little extra holiday cheer to your cookie exchange party, you might want to consider bringing some specialty cookies. There are a wide variety of cookie options available, so it’s important to consider a few factors before making your purchase.
First, think about the size of your cookie exchange. If it’s a small group, you may only need to bring a dozen cookies. For larger gatherings, you might need to bring multiple batches. Additionally, consider dietary restrictions and preferences of your guests. Do you need gluten-free or nut-free options? Are there any common flavor profiles that are particularly well-loved?
When it comes to selecting the perfect cookies for your exchange, there are a few questions to ask yourself. Do you want to go for a traditional holiday flavor like peppermint or eggnog, or something a little more unexpected? Should you choose a classic cookie like chocolate chip or a more unique option? And finally, what will make your cookie stand out from the others on the table?
No matter what you choose, remember that the most important part of the cookie exchange is the time spent with loved ones. So grab a few boxes of delicious treats, wrap them up in beautiful packaging, and enjoy the holiday season with those you hold dear.
10 Best Cookies For Cookie Exchange
| # | Product Image | Product Name | Product Notes | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1
|
 |
It is ideal for decorating Christmas cookies and hosting a cookie exchange party.
|
|
|
|
2
|
 |
The product is ideal for a tasty snack that can be enjoyed at home or shared with friends and family.
|
|
|
|
3
|
 |
It is ideal for gifting cookies, brownies, pastries, cupcakes, and donuts.
|
|
|
|
4
|
 |
This product is ideal for holiday-themed cookie exchanges and comes with 50 double-sided recipe cards.
|
|
|
|
5
|
 |
The product is ideal for those looking for inspiration and recipes for cookie exchange events.
|
|
|
|
6
|
 |
The product is ideal for packaging small bakery items such as cakes, cupcakes, pies, and pastries.
|
|
|
|
7
|
 |
The product is ideal for storing cookies or other small treats in a decorative and playful container.
|
|
|
|
8
|
 |
The product is ideal for classroom exchanges or gifting on Valentine's Day.
|
|
|
|
9
|
 |
Ideal for baking and cooking, these organic chocolate chips add a rich and indulgent flavor to desserts and pastries.
|
|
|
|
10
|
 |
The product is ideal for baking desserts and treats needing semi-sweet chocolate chips with a high cacao percentage.
|
|
1. Colorful Cookie Decorating Set With Exchange Card
Add some festive cheer to your Christmas holiday cookies with the Betty Crocker Decorating Cookie Icing. This pack includes three Christmas colors – Red, Green, and White – that are perfect for decorating your treats. The icing is incredibly easy to use, as it comes ready to use and requires no heating. With this icing, you can decorate your cookies in minutes, making it a great option for busy bakers. The Betty Crocker cookie icing is made in the USA and is gluten-free, ensuring that everyone can enjoy your delicious treats. In addition, this pack comes bundled with an editable cookie exchange card, which provides a great way to share your cookies. You can write your best wishes on the back of the card and share your treats with loved ones and friends.
Celebrate the holiday season with the Betty Crocker Decorating Cookie Icing. This pack includes three Christmas colors – Red, Green, and White – that are perfect for adding a pop of color to your cookies. The icing is incredibly easy to use and does not require any heating, so you can get decorating in minutes. The Betty Crocker cookie icing is made in the USA and is gluten-free, making it a great option for anyone with dietary restrictions. Additionally, this pack comes bundled with an editable cookie exchange card, allowing you to share your treats with others. Simply write your best wishes on the back of the card and exchange your cookies with friends and family.
Make your holiday cookies stand out with the Betty Crocker Decorating Cookie Icing. This pack includes three festive colors – Red, Green, and White – that are perfect for adding some Christmas cheer to your treats. The icing is incredibly easy to use and requires no heating, so you can get decorating in no time. The Betty Crocker cookie icing is made in the USA and is gluten-free, ensuring that everyone can enjoy your delicious cookies. Plus, this pack comes bundled with an editable cookie exchange card, which provides a great way to share your treats with others. Write your best wishes on the back of the card and exchange your cookies with loved ones and friends.
- Comes in three Christmas colors – Red, Green, and White
- Ready to use and requires no heating
- Decorates cookies in minutes
- Made in the USA
- Gluten-free
- Comes bundled with an editable cookie exchange card
- – Limited to three colors
- – May not be suitable for those with allergies to other ingredients
2. Royal Dansk Danish Cookies Tin, Butter, 24 Ounce
Indulge in the rich taste and buttery goodness of Danish butter cookies with the Royal Dansk 24-ounce tin. This classic assortment features a mix of assorted cookies in five distinct shapes – Pretzel Style, Vanilla Ring, Finnish Style, Country Style, and Coconut – some with a delicious coconut or vanilla twist. Every cookie is crafted with the utmost care and attention to detail to deliver the perfect balance of crispiness and buttery goodness in every bite.
Royal Dansk takes pride in their long-standing cookie craftsmanship that has been providing moments of enjoyment since 1966. They remain true to fine Danish baking tradition by using high-quality, non-GMO ingredients with no artificial preservatives, colors or flavors. This commitment to quality ensures that every batch of cookies is decadent and delicious, leaving a lasting impression with every bite.
The iconic blue tin not only makes for a great gift but also serves as a convenient storage option to keep your cookies fresh and crispy. So, whether you're looking to indulge in a sweet treat or share a moment with loved ones over some delicious cookies, Royal Dansk has got you covered.
- Classic assortment of rich Danish butter cookies
- Distinctly shaped cookies in five shapes with coconut or vanilla twist
- Crafted with care to deliver the perfect balance of crispiness and buttery goodness
- Uses high-quality, non-GMO ingredients with no artificial preservatives, colors or flavors
- Comes in an iconic blue tin for convenient storage and gifting options
3. Joyful Christmas Cookie Box With Auto-Popup Window
The Vintage Kraft Design Bakery Pastry Box with Window is a super value pack that includes 24 cookie boxes in 3 different designs. Each box measures 8.75" x 5.75" x 2.75" inches. The unique and adorable design features Happy Santa, Playful Snowman, and Cheerful Gingerbread Man, adding a festive touch to your baked goods.
These Festive Baked Good Cookie Boxes are easy to use with a crystal-clear window on top that proudly showcases your delicious cupcakes, cookies, cakes, pies, chocolate brownies, donuts, truffles, biscuits, or candy. The window also makes your desserts even more irresistible!
The Christmas Holiday Cookie Pastry Container Box is perfect for gift-giving during the holidays, filling it up with gourmet treats on the go! The auto-popup feature ensures fast and efficient service in the holiday season.
Made from extra durable, eco-friendly paperboard material and biodegradable window film, these pastry containers are of premium quality and will keep your pastry safely intact.
If for any reason you are not satisfied with the product, feel free to message the seller through contact sellers. Your satisfaction is their priority.
- Super value pack with 24 cookie boxes in 3 different designs
- Crystal-clear window on top to showcase your baked goods
- Unique and festive design perfect for holiday parties and gift-giving
- Made from extra durable, eco-friendly paperboard material and biodegradable window film
- Auto-popup feature ensures fast and efficient service in the holiday season
4. Buffalo Plaid Decor Old Red Truck Recipe Cards 4×6 Pack Of 50 Double Sided Holiday Cookie Exchange
Bring the charm and warm atmosphere of a Modern Farmhouse Style to your kitchen with these Classic Check Recipe Cards. These cards come in a pack of 50 double-sided 4" x 6" blank recipe cards with lines, providing ample space for ingredients, directions, serving size, prep time, cook time, and even a special note on the bottom. The cards are printed on sturdy 14pt uncoated cardstock, making it easy to write on and giving them a durable feel.
The Classic Check design of these recipe cards will match most kitchen décor, making them a great addition to any kitchen. These cards are perfect for recording your favorite recipes at home and sharing them with friends and family at a bridal shower or housewarming party.
These recipe cards make a perfect gift for cooking or baking enthusiasts for Christmas, Mother's Day, birthdays, or housewarming. The large writing space makes it easy to fill in the details and keep your recipes organized, while the crisp white paired with black & white plaid design adds a touch of farmhouse style to any kitchen.
- Pack of 50 double-sided recipe cards with lots of writing space to fit ingredients, directions, serving size, prep time, and cook time
- Printed on sturdy 14pt uncoated cardstock that's easy to write on
- Classic Check design matches most kitchen décor
- Great gift choice for cooking or baking enthusiasts for various occasions
- – The design may not be appealing to those who do not prefer farmhouse-style kitchen décor
5. Wilton Cookie Exchange Book
This cookie decorating book offers over 200 easy-to-follow designs that will make your cookies look like they came from a professional bakery. The book includes galleries for many favorite holiday designs such as Spritz, Stars, Snowflakes and Trees. It also offers more than 30 delicious cookie recipes that will make your cookies taste just as good as they look.
With step-by-step instructions and helpful tips, even beginners can create stunning cookies that are sure to impress. The book also includes a list of necessary tools and ingredients, making it easy to get started right away. Whether you're looking to create cookies for a special occasion or just want to impress your family and friends, this book has everything you need to get started.
In addition to the holiday designs, the book includes designs for birthdays, weddings, and other special events. With so many options to choose from, you're sure to find the perfect cookie design for any occasion. Whether you're a seasoned pro or just getting started, this cookie decorating book is a must-have for anyone who loves to bake and decorate cookies.
- Over 200 easy-to-follow cookie designs
- More than 30 delicious cookie recipes
- Step-by-step instructions and helpful tips
- List of necessary tools and ingredients
- Designs for holidays and special occasions
6. Brown Treat Boxes With Window – 200 Pcs
The Sufficient Quantity Set includes 200 pieces of bakery boxes with window and a 328 ft/ 100 meter long jute rope for packaging, providing ample quantity and a nice combination to meet your daily requirements for dessert packaging and displaying. The cookie gift boxes have a clear, large, and transparent window on top that perfectly displays your cupcakes, cakes, muffins, and cookies. You don't have to open the box to see what's inside, making it simple and convenient for you. These treat boxes with window measure 4 x 4 x 2.5 inches/ 10.2 x 10.2 x 6.7 cm in length, width, and height, pre-folded and easy to assemble, which will not take up space and can be assembled in a short time when needed. The diameter of the rope is 0.04 inch/ 1 mm. This DIY process can bring you a lot of fun and convenience. Our cookie exchange containers are made of quality kraft with PVC window, safe and sturdy, lightweight and strong. The jute rope is reliable and solid, which can serve you for a long time. These kraft cookie boxes can be applied as creative gift boxes for displaying your baking creations such as biscuits, muffins, donuts, and more in the kitchen, home or bakery. They are available for Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, birthday, wedding, Easter, and other holiday celebrations.
- The set includes 200 pieces of bakery boxes and a long jute rope, which is a sufficient quantity for daily requirements for dessert packaging and displaying.
- Clear window design allows you to see what's inside the box without opening it.
- The treat boxes are pre-folded and easy to assemble, making it simple and convenient for you.
- The kraft cookie boxes are made of quality kraft with PVC window, safe and sturdy, lightweight and strong.
- These cookie exchange containers come with a reliable and solid jute rope that can serve you for a long time.
- These kraft cookie boxes can be applied as creative gift boxes for displaying your baking creations such as biscuits, muffins, donuts, and more in the kitchen, home or bakery.
- They are available for Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, birthday, wedding, Easter, and other holiday celebrations.
7. Cookie Jar: Cookie Capers: The Yorkie Cookie Jar By The Bradford Exchange
The Yorkie Cookie Jar from The Bradford Exchange is a paw-some addition to your kitchen, whether you're a Yorkie lover or just love cute dog-themed decor. This cookie jar features a beautiful Yorkie dog art by acclaimed artist Linda Picken, which is expertly reproduced on the side of the jar. It is crafted by hand using high-quality ceramic and hand-painted with intricate details that make the Yorkie art come to life.
The sculptural lift-off lid of the Cookie Capers jar features two fully dimensional Yorkies that seem to be helping themselves to a tasty treat. The lid is embellished with golden bands around the artwork for an extra touch of elegance. The snug rubber ring inside the lid keeps the contents fresh, ensuring that your cookies stay delicious for longer. With its lustrous hand-glazed finish, this cookie jar is sure to add charm and warmth to any kitchen.
Please note that for important information about sales tax, you can check the Storefront Page by clicking on the storefront link above and selecting the Policies Tab.
- Beautifully crafted by hand using high-quality ceramic
- Hand-painted with intricate details that make the Yorkie art come to life
- Sculptural lift-off lid features two fully dimensional Yorkies that add to the charm
- Embellished with golden bands around the artwork and lid for an extra touch of elegance
- Snug rubber ring inside the lid keeps the contents fresh for longer
- Lustrous hand-glazed finish adds charm and warmth to any kitchen
8. Mother's Valentine's Day Puppy Love X's & O's Cookies, Classroom Exchange, 30ct
Celebrate Valentine's Day with a delicious and adorable treat from Mother's. The Valentine's Day Puppy Love X's & O's Cookies are a perfect addition to any classroom exchange or gift for your loved ones. This pack comes with 28ct cookies that are sure to delight anyone who receives them.
Each cookie is carefully crafted with a cute puppy design and a loving message of 'XOXO' to spread the love this Valentine's Day. These cookies are made with high-quality ingredients, ensuring a tasty and satisfying treat for all. They are also individually wrapped, making them easy to share with friends and family.
These Valentine's Day Puppy Love X's & O's Cookies are perfect for those who want to express their love in a sweet and delicious way. They are also ideal for classroom exchanges or as a thoughtful gift for your loved ones. Celebrate Valentine's Day with Mother's and enjoy these delightful cookies with your loved ones.
- Cute puppy design with loving message of 'XOXO'
- High-quality ingredients for a tasty and satisfying treat
- Individually wrapped for easy sharing with friends and family
9. Equal Exchange Organic Bittersweet Chocolate Chips, 10 Ounce
Indulge in a guilt-free sweet treat with these bittersweet chocolate chips that are suitable for vegetarians. Each bag contains 10 ounces of delicious chocolate chips that will leave you wanting more.
These chocolate chips are made with high-quality ingredients and are kosher certified, making them perfect for those who follow a kosher diet. They are also free from any animal products, making them a great option for vegetarians.
Use these chocolate chips to add a burst of flavor to your favorite baked goods, such as cookies, brownies, and cakes. They are also great for melting and using as a dip for fruits or other snacks.
The bittersweet flavor of these chocolate chips is perfect for those who prefer a less sweet taste. They are made with the finest cocoa beans, giving them a rich and indulgent flavor that you won't be able to resist.
Whether you're a chocolate lover or just looking for a delicious snack, these bittersweet chocolate chips are the perfect choice. So go ahead and indulge in a little sweetness today!
- Suitable for vegetarians
- Made with high-quality ingredients
- Kosher certified
- Free from animal products
- Perfect for adding to baked goods or melting for a dip
- Bittersweet flavor is perfect for those who prefer less sweet taste
10. Equal Exchange Organic Chocolate Chips | Semi-Sweet | 55% Cacao | 10 Ounce (Pack Of 12)
Enjoy guilt-free baking with these Vegan, Soy Free, Organic & Free of the 8 Major Allergens Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips 55% Cacao. This 12 Pack of 10 oz bags of Vegan, Organic & Soy Free Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips 55% Cacao is the perfect ingredient for your baking needs. These delicious chocolate chips are produced in a facility that does not process peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, soy, or gluten containing ingredients including wheat, ensuring that you can enjoy them without worries.
The Fairly Traded Cacao from Small-Scale Farmers in Peru & Sugar from Small-Scale Farmers in Paraguay used in these chocolate chips are 100% fairly traded ingredients, making this product not only delicious but also ethical. These chocolate chips are Certified Organic by the USDA and Gourmet Quality. Moreover, they are Certified Kosher, making them suitable for anyone who follows a Kosher diet.
These Vegan, Soy Free, Organic & Free of the 8 Major Allergens Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips 55% Cacao are perfect for all your baking needs. Add them to your cookies, cakes, and brownies to give them a delicious chocolatey flavor. You can also melt them and use them as a dip for your fruits or pretzels. The possibilities are endless with these chocolate chips.
- Vegan, Soy Free, Organic & Free of the 8 Major Allergens Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips 55% Cacao
- Produced in a facility that does not process peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, soy, or gluten containing ingredients including wheat
- Fairly Traded Cacao from Small-Scale Farmers in Peru & Sugar from Small-Scale Farmers in Paraguay
- 100% Fairly Traded Ingredients
- Certified Organic by the USDA
- Gourmet Quality
- Certified Kosher
Best Cookies For Cookie Exchange FAQs
How do I organize a successful cookie exchange with my friends or community?
Organizing a successful cookie exchange with friends or community can be a fun and festive way to celebrate the holiday season. Here are some tips to help you get started:
1. Invite participants: Start by creating a guest list and inviting your friends or community members to participate. Make sure to give them enough notice so they have time to plan and prepare.
2. Set the rules: Establish the rules for your cookie exchange, such as how many cookies each person should bring, dietary restrictions, and any other guidelines you want to set.
3. Plan the logistics: Decide on a date, time, and location for your cookie exchange. Make sure there is enough space for everyone to set up their cookies and mingle.
4. Decorate: Set the mood for your cookie exchange by decorating the space with festive decorations and music.
5. Enjoy the exchange: When the day arrives, encourage everyone to share the story behind their cookie recipe and enjoy sampling each other's treats. Make sure to provide take-home containers so everyone can bring home a variety of cookies.
Remember, the goal of a cookie exchange is to have fun and celebrate the holiday season with friends or community, so don't stress too much about the details. Just enjoy the company and the delicious treats!
How many cookies should I bring to a cookie exchange?
The amount of cookies that you should bring to a cookie exchange depends on the number of attendees and the guidelines set by the organizer. Generally, it is recommended to bring at least one dozen (12) cookies per person attending the exchange. This means that if there are ten people attending, you should bring a minimum of 120 cookies.
It's always a good idea to check with the organizer beforehand to make sure that you bring the correct amount of cookies. Some cookie exchanges may have a specific theme or type of cookie requested, so it's important to clarify any guidelines or restrictions before baking.
If you're unsure about how many cookies to bring, it's better to err on the side of caution and bring a little extra. After all, who doesn't love having extra cookies to take home and enjoy? Just make sure to package your cookies in a way that's easy to transport and share, such as a sealed container or a festive bag or box.
Should I package my cookies in a particular way for a cookie exchange?
Yes, packaging your cookies in a particular way for a cookie exchange is essential. The packaging of your cookies is an important aspect of the exchange, and it can make or break the entire event. You want to make sure that your cookies are packaged in a way that is appealing to the eye and that they are safe for transportation.
One of the most popular ways to package cookies for an exchange is by using a decorative cookie tin or box. This will not only keep your cookies fresh, but it will also add a touch of sophistication and elegance to your presentation. Another option is to use cellophane bags tied with a festive ribbon. This is a simple yet effective way to package your cookies, and it allows for easy distribution.
It's important to remember that the packaging of your cookies should reflect the quality of the cookies themselves. Make sure that your cookies are neatly arranged and that they look as delicious as they taste. With the right packaging, your cookies will be the star of the exchange, and you'll leave a lasting impression on everyone who tries them.
What are some tips for making sure my cookies stay fresh for a cookie exchange?
When it comes to cookie exchanges, you want to make sure that your cookies are not only delicious but also fresh. Here are some tips for ensuring that your cookies stay fresh for a cookie exchange:
1. Store the cookies properly: Store the cookies in an airtight container to prevent them from becoming stale. You can also use plastic wrap or aluminum foil to wrap the cookies individually.
2. Choose the right container: Make sure that the container you choose is large enough to hold all of the cookies without squishing them. You can also use a container with a lid that snaps shut.
3. Keep them away from heat and light: Heat and light can cause cookies to become stale quickly. Store the container in a cool and dark place, such as a pantry or cupboard.
4. Add a piece of bread: Adding a piece of bread to the container can help keep the cookies fresh. The bread will absorb any excess moisture and keep the cookies soft.
5. Freeze the cookies: If you're not going to be using the cookies right away, you can freeze them to keep them fresh. Just make sure to wrap them tightly in plastic wrap or aluminum foil before placing them in the freezer.
By following these tips, you can ensure that your cookies stay fresh for your cookie exchange and are enjoyed by everyone.
What are some unique and delicious cookie recipes to bring to a cookie exchange?
When it comes to unique and delicious cookie recipes to bring to a cookie exchange, there are plenty of options to choose from. One popular choice is to make salted caramel chocolate chip cookies, which combine the classic chocolate chip cookie with a sweet and salty twist. Another option is to try out a recipe for pumpkin spice cookies, which are perfect for the fall and winter months. If you're feeling adventurous, you could even try making matcha green tea cookies, which have a unique flavor and a beautiful green hue. For those who love peanut butter, you could whip up a batch of peanut butter and jelly thumbprint cookies, which are sure to be a hit. Ultimately, the key to a successful cookie exchange is to bring something that is both delicious and unique, so don't be afraid to get creative and try out something new!