When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Best Bait For Old Fashioned Mouse Trap (2024 Updated)

If you’re looking for a way to keep pesky rodents out of your home or office, an old fashioned mouse trap may be just what you need. With so many options on the market, it can be tricky to choose the best type of bait for your trap. Let’s explore some factors you should consider before making a purchase.

Firstly, it’s important to think about the type of rodent you want to catch. Do you need to attract mice, rats, or both? Different types of bait will appeal to different rodents. Additionally, take into account the location of the trap, as some baits can attract unwanted pests like ants or flies.

Another crucial factor is the effectiveness of the bait. You want to choose bait that will lure rodents in quickly and effectively. Pay attention to the aroma of the bait, as some rodents may not be attracted to certain smells.

Are you tired of losing your bait to crafty rodents? Consider using a bait station to protect your bait and ensure that it attracts only your target pests. Or, if you’re looking for a more humane solution, try using peanut butter or oats as bait instead of traditional cheese.

Now that you know what factors to consider when choosing bait for your old fashioned mouse trap, let’s ask ourselves some important questions. Are you tired of hearing rodents scurrying around your home at night? Does the thought of using harsh chemicals or poisons worry you? If so, an old fashioned mouse trap with the right bait could be the perfect solution to keep your home rodent-free.

10 Best Bait For Old Fashioned Mouse Trap

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1
The product is ideal for catching mice in a pack of 12 traps.
2
The product is ideal for catching mice and rats easily and efficiently.
3
The product is ideal for catching mice in households, gardens, and other areas where mice are present.
4
Ideal for catching rats and mice and holding poison in durable, discreet boxes with easy access for exterminators.
5
The product is ideal for catching small rodents in a quick, effective, sanitary, and safe manner for families and pets.
6
Ideal for small animals such as sugar gliders, rats, hamsters, ferrets, squirrels, and chinchillas to sleep in a warm and cozy environment.
7
The product is ideal for controlling rodents such as mice and chipmunks, both indoors and outdoors.
8
The product is ideal for catching mice indoors and outdoors in a simple, humane, non-toxic, pet-safe, and child-safe manner.
9
The product is ideal for controlling mouse infestations in various settings such as homes, offices, and warehouses.
10
Ideal for indoor and outdoor rodent control, cruelty-free alternative to rat traps, safe for children and pets.
The product is ideal for catching mice in a pack of 12 traps.
The product is ideal for catching mice and rats easily and efficiently.
The product is ideal for catching mice in households, gardens, and other areas where mice are present.
Ideal for catching rats and mice and holding poison in durable, discreet boxes with easy access for exterminators.
The product is ideal for catching small rodents in a quick, effective, sanitary, and safe manner for families and pets.
Ideal for small animals such as sugar gliders, rats, hamsters, ferrets, squirrels, and chinchillas to sleep in a warm and cozy environment.
The product is ideal for controlling rodents such as mice and chipmunks, both indoors and outdoors.
The product is ideal for catching mice indoors and outdoors in a simple, humane, non-toxic, pet-safe, and child-safe manner.
The product is ideal for controlling mouse infestations in various settings such as homes, offices, and warehouses.
Ideal for indoor and outdoor rodent control, cruelty-free alternative to rat traps, safe for children and pets.

1. Victor Easy Set Mouse Traps (Pack Of 12)

The wood-based wire snap trap with a large scented plastic trip pedal is an effective tool for catching rodents. Its clean and quick trapping mechanism ensures that the job is done efficiently. The trap can be placed around food, water, children, and pets without causing any harm to them. It is an ideal solution for catching rodents that have run away. The Swiss cheese pedal design eliminates the need for baiting, making the trap easy to use.

This trap is easy to set up and use, making it a popular choice among homeowners and pest control professionals. Its sturdy construction ensures that it will last for a long time, making it a cost-effective solution for rodent control. The trap is also easy to clean and maintain, ensuring that it is always ready to use when needed.

The wood-based wire snap trap with a large scented plastic trip pedal is a reliable and effective tool for catching rodents. Its clean and quick trapping mechanism, along with its Swiss cheese pedal design, makes it an ideal solution for homeowners and pest control professionals alike.

Pros

  • Clean and quick trapping mechanism
  • Can be used around food, water, children, and pets
  • Ideal for runaway trapping
  • Swiss cheese pedal design eliminates the need for baiting
  • Sturdy construction ensures long-lasting use
  • Easy to clean and maintain

2. Snap-E Trap: Fast, Strong, Reusable.

The Big Snap-E is the ultimate solution for eliminating large rodents, such as rats, chipmunks, ground squirrels, and other large rodents. This trap is designed with an extra-large trip paddle and a 90-degree strike bar, which means shorter strike distance and doubles the response speed, preventing rodents from escaping once caught.

This trap is easy to set up, bait, and release, making it the ultimate rat trap. The pre-formed bait cup minimizes bait stealing, and the trap catches mice from the front, back, and sides. The base of the trap has two pre-formed holes for easy surface mounting, ensuring that the trap stays in place while it catches rodents.

Made from high-quality steel and durable polystyrene, the Big Snap-E is easy to clean, reusable, and will last for years. The trap features a sanitary disposal system that makes it easy to dispose of the rodents without touching them. The vertical bar is all you need to pull back to release the critter, eliminating the need to touch it.

If you're looking for a rat trap that is effective, reliable, and easy to use, the Big Snap-E is the perfect choice. It's a must-have in any home or business that is experiencing a rodent problem.

Pros

  • Extra-large trip paddle and 90-degree strike bar with a shorter strike distance doubles response speed
  • Pre-formed bait cup minimizes bait stealing
  • Sanitary disposal and easy cleaning for years of use
  • Made from high-quality steel and durable polystyrene
  • Easy to set up, bait, and release
  • Catches mice from the front, back, and sides
  • Features two pre-formed holes in the base for easy surface mounting
  • Reusable and long-lasting

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for smaller rodents
  • – Not suitable for outdoor use

3. Victor M154 Metal Pedal Mouse Trap, Pack Of 12

The wood-based wired snap trap with a metal trip petal is an effective trapping solution that ensures clean and quick trapping. It is ideal for runway trapping and can be used in both reusable and disposable modes. The trap can be safely used around children and pets as it does not contain any harmful chemicals or poisons. The package includes 12 traps in total, making it a cost-effective solution for your pest control needs. Additionally, the package includes an eBook, SJ eBook, which provides valuable information on pest control and trap placement to enhance the effectiveness of the traps.

This trap is easy to set up and use. The metal trip petal ensures a quick and humane kill, leaving behind no mess or odors. The trap can be easily cleaned and reused, making it an environmentally friendly solution to pest control. It is also an affordable option that does not require any ongoing costs, such as batteries or electricity.

The wood-based wired snap trap is an effective and reliable solution to pest control that is both safe and easy to use. With the added bonus of the SJ eBook, users can make the most out of their purchase and achieve optimal results in pest control.

Pros

  • Quick and humane trapping
  • Reusable or disposable options available
  • No harmful chemicals or poisons
  • Affordable and cost-effective
  • Easy to set up and use
  • Environmentally friendly

4. Rat & Mouse Control: 6 Pack Bait Stations

Exterminators Choice Rat Bait Station is a set of six station boxes that are perfect for trapping rats and keeping unwanted visitors from scurrying into your home or lawn. These bait stations are made by professional exterminators to provide an effective and reliable solution to your rodent problems.

The rat bait stations are suitable for both indoor and outdoor use. You can place them inside your kitchen or outside in your garage, tool sheds, lawns, around large warehouses, and buildings to trap pesky rodents. The bait boxes work well with all types of rat poison and mouse bait. Please note that this product is not designed to trap rodents but rather used as a holder for poisonous bait.

The rat bait stations are constructed with a heavy-duty and discreetly green color that easily blends in with shrubs, bushes, and grass. The boxes include a built-in lock system with an included key to ensure that children and pets stay out, making it a safe and reliable option for those with families.

Exterminators Choice is confident that you will see results with their humane mouse trap. They stand by their products and have perfected their rat station through years of use, providing a satisfaction guarantee to their customers.

Pros

  • Professional exterminator-designed rat bait stations
  • Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
  • Works well with all types of rat poison and mouse bait
  • Heavy-duty and discreetly green color that easily blends in with surroundings
  • Built-in lock system to ensure safety

Cons

  • – Not designed to trap rodents directly

5. Sanitary Mouse Traps – 6 Pack

The mouse trap is designed to be safe, with no poison, glue, or touch involved. This makes it a safe option to use, without worrying about snapping your fingers. Additionally, it is easy to clean odors and blood, ensuring that it remains hygienic. The trap is also easy to use and set up. Simply put bait in the cup and place it back into the mouse trap. The trap clamp can be kept open, allowing for both indoor and outdoor use. The mouse trap is efficient and highly sensitive. It is more effective and safe compared to traditional wood or metal traps. With only 0.025 lbs of weight required to trigger it, this powerful trap is suitable for catching small mice. It can completely eliminate the mouse problem. Unlike electronic and ultrasonic equipment that only temporarily scares the mouse away, this trap ensures that the mouse is caught and will not return. Additionally, there is friendly customer support available. If you are not satisfied with the product, the team will do their best to assist you and resolve any issues.

The mouse trap is safe to use, easy to clean and efficient in catching mice. It can be used both indoors and outdoors, making it versatile. The trap is also highly sensitive, making it effective in catching small mice. It can completely eliminate the mouse problem, ensuring that it does not return.

The mouse trap is easy to set up and does not require any glue, poison, or touch. It is also easy to clean and maintain. If you have any issues with the product, customer support is available to assist you.

Pros

  • Safe to use with no poison, glue, or touch involved
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Efficient and highly sensitive, making it effective in catching small mice
  • Can be used both indoors and outdoors
  • Completely eliminates the mouse problem, ensuring that it does not return
  • Friendly customer support available

6. Hang-N-Sleep Fleece Hammock For Small Animals

Treat your small furry friends to the ultimate comfort with this cozy hammock. Measuring 13.3 x 13.3 inches, it's the perfect size for hamsters, gerbils, ferrets, sugar gliders, guinea pigs, chinchillas, squirrels, and other small animals. The hammock is made of high-quality Crystal velvet and Arctic Fleece material, which is soft, warm, and fluffy, providing a secure and super comfy resting spot for your lovely pets.

The hammock features a double-layer design, allowing your pets to either lay on the top or snuggle at the bottom layer. It's a perfect playing/hiding spot that will keep your pets entertained for hours. The solid color looks simple yet classic, complementing any cage interior.

The hammock is easy to use and can be quickly attached to cage interiors with the included four metal hooks. It's also machine washable, making it easy to clean and maintain. However, it's important to remove the metal clips before washing to prevent any damage.

Overall, this hammock is a must-have for small pet owners who want to provide their furry friends with the ultimate comfort and relaxation. It's an excellent investment that will keep your pets happy and healthy.

Pros

  • Made of high-quality Crystal velvet and Arctic Fleece material for ultimate comfort
  • Double-layer design allows pets to lay on the top or snuggle at the bottom layer
  • Easy to use and quickly attaches to cage interiors with included 4 metal hooks
  • Machine washable for easy cleaning and maintenance

Cons

  • – May not be suitable for larger animals

7. Snap 'n Kill: 6 Reusable Rat Traps

The Kat Sense Rat Trap is an efficient and reliable solution to controlling unwanted pests in your home. Its sturdy plastic construction ensures that it will last for years to come, while its smart integrated bait cap feature means you can use your choice of bait to lure in rats and mice. Once triggered, the trap's powerful stainless steel spring ensures a mess-free kill every time, with 35% more force than other traps in the market.

Say goodbye to ineffective exterminator methods and hello to the Kat Sense Rat Trap. Set it and forget it. Place the trap near baseboards and corners where rodents might hide, and forget about it. The trap's highly responsive snap mechanism with a sensitive pedal and specially designed jaws-style teeth ensure that rodents are caught every time, with no escape.

These traps are easy to use multiple times and are made of washable materials, making them a hygienic option for efficient rat removal. Press the trap to open over a garbage bin for quick and hands-free touchless disposal. These traps are a reliable and efficient solution to pest control that exceed expectations and are backed by a hassle-free return policy.

Get your pack of six outdoor rat and mouse traps today and get rid of those pesky squirrels for good.

Pros

  • Sturdy plastic construction ensures long-lasting efficiency
  • Smart, integrated bait cap feature allows for the use of preferred bait
  • Powerful stainless steel spring ensures a mess-free kill with 35% more force than other traps
  • Highly responsive snap mechanism with sensitive pedal and jaws-style teeth ensure no escape for rodents
  • Hygienic option for efficient rat removal with washable materials
  • Hassle-free return policy ensures satisfaction

Cons

  • – May not be effective for larger rodents
  • – Can be difficult to set up for first-time users
  • – May not be suitable for outdoor use in extreme weather conditions

8. Catchmaster's Humane Multi-Catch Mouse Trap

The Multi-Catch Mouse Trap is a reliable and easy-to-use solution for eliminating mice. It can trap 10-12 mice per setting and can be used with or without the included glue board. When used without the glue board, it acts as a live catch trap and can even be used outdoors. With year-round protection, the Catch Master Glue Traps are a safe, non-toxic, and mess-free alternative to standalone traps and glue boards. They are effective for up to one full year under normal conditions.

Designed with your family's safety in mind, these traps are intuitive and secure. The adhesive formula has been specially designed to prevent hardening, ensuring maximum effectiveness. The Catch Master Glue Traps are proudly made in the USA, fast-acting, and non-toxic, making them ideal for use in residential, commercial, or industrial buildings, both indoors and outdoors. They are especially useful in sensitive areas where rodenticides or snap traps are undesirable or prohibited.

Catch Master takes an Intelligent Pest Management approach to their products. They believe in utilizing a science-based method to tackle pest problems, leaving no stones unturned when it comes to pests. With a solid conviction in their products, you can trust that they will provide an effective solution to your pest problem.

Pros

  • Reliable and easy-to-use solution for eliminating mice
  • Can trap 10-12 mice per setting and can be used with or without the glue board
  • Safe, non-toxic and mess-free alternative to standalone traps and glue boards
  • Effective for up to one full year under normal conditions
  • Ideal for use in residential, commercial, or industrial buildings, indoors and outdoors
  • Specially designed adhesive formula prevents hardening for maximum effectiveness
  • Intelligent Pest Management approach ensures a science-based solution to pest problems

9. Protecta Bait Stations For Mouse – Rtu, One Case 12 Units

The Protecta RTU Mouse Bait Station is a tamper-resistant bait station designed to provide effective rodent control. It comes in a case of 12 stations, making it ideal for larger scale pest control operations. The station is designed to hold 1 oz (28g), 20 g and 15 gram blox baits, ensuring that the bait is securely contained and protected from moisture and other environmental factors. The station is also easy to use, with a simple locking mechanism that ensures that the bait is only accessible to rodents.

Made from durable materials, the Protecta RTU Mouse Bait Station is designed to withstand harsh outdoor conditions and can be used in a variety of settings, including commercial, residential, and agricultural environments. The station is also tamper-resistant, ensuring that the bait is only accessible to rodents and not other animals or children. The station's compact size also makes it easy to install in tight spaces, ensuring that rodents are effectively controlled, even in hard-to-reach areas.

Overall, the Protecta RTU Mouse Bait Station is an effective and easy-to-use rodent control solution that is ideal for both commercial and residential settings. Its tamper-resistant design and ability to hold a range of bait sizes make it a versatile choice for pest control professionals and DIY users alike.

Pros

  • Tamper-resistant design ensures that bait is only accessible to rodents
  • Can hold 1 oz (28g), 20 g and 15 gram blox baits
  • Durable materials and compact size make it suitable for use in a variety of settings

10. Rodent-X: Weatherproof Rat Bait Stations

The Eco Pro Pest Control Rat Bait Station is a sturdy and durable solution for eliminating rodent infestation in homes, yards, warehouses, and offices. Unlike other poorly constructed rodent bait stations, this bait station is built out of sturdy metal and tough, durable, heavy-duty plastic which can be reused again and again. It is 100% weather-resistant, making it suitable for both indoor and outdoor use. With its tamper-resistant, large, pet-safe station, it is secured at all times by two locking mechanisms and requires a key to open the rat station and expose the bait inside, ensuring that little fingers and paws are kept safe from harm.

The kit includes two rat and mouse bait stations for effective perimeter baiting, which can be attached to permanent structures and surfaces, preventing pets, pests, and stray animals from moving them. The bait station can safely catch and eliminate up to three rodents per rat bait block, making elimination swift and cost-effective. It can be used with any rat bait, rat poison or bait blocks (bait not included), so you can choose whether to exterminate immediately or use slower-acting poison, allowing pests to die quietly elsewhere. The kit comes with an instruction sheet for your rat bait boxes, plus a report to help keep pests under control for good.

At Eco Pro Pest Control, their goal is to make pest control safer and more effective, so you can eliminate your rodent problem quickly and easily. They design sturdy, durable bait stations for rats and mice that will hold up to wear and tear and can be used multiple times, making them more cost-effective. If, for any reason, you aren't satisfied with your bait stations, please reach out to them directly so they can make it right.

Pros

  • Sturdy and durable construction with sturdy metal and tough, durable, heavy-duty plastic
  • 100% weather-resistant, suitable for both indoor and outdoor use
  • Tamper-resistant, large, pet-safe station secured at all times by two locking mechanisms, ensuring safety of children and pets
  • Includes two rat and mouse bait stations for effective perimeter baiting, which can be attached to permanent structures and surfaces
  • Can safely catch and eliminate up to three rodents per rat bait block
  • Can be used with any rat bait, rat poison or bait blocks (bait not included), allowing flexibility in extermination options
  • Comes with an instruction sheet and a report to help keep pests under control for good
  • Designed to be sturdy, durable and cost-effective
  • Direct customer support available for customer satisfaction

Cons

  • – Bait not included in the kit

Best Bait For Old Fashioned Mouse Trap FAQs

Are there any alternative baits for an old fashioned mouse trap besides cheese?

Yes, there are several alternative baits that can be used for an old fashioned mouse trap besides cheese. In fact, mice are attracted to a wide variety of foods, so the key is to find a bait that is highly appealing to them. Peanut butter is a popular alternative to cheese because it has a strong scent and is sticky, making it difficult for mice to remove from the trap. Other options include bacon, chocolate, dried fruit, and even pet food. It's important to keep in mind that mice are highly adaptable and may become immune to certain baits over time. Therefore, it's a good idea to switch up the bait every so often to keep them interested. Additionally, it's important to place the bait in the ideal location, such as near a wall or in a high traffic area, to increase the likelihood of attracting mice to the trap.

Can cheese be used as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap?

Yes, cheese can definitely be used as bait for an old fashioned mouse trap. In fact, cheese has been a popular choice for baiting mouse traps for decades. The strong smell and appealing taste of cheese make it an attractive bait for mice. However, it is important to note that not all types of cheese work equally well as mouse bait. Soft cheeses like brie or camembert may not work as effectively as harder, sharper cheeses like cheddar or Swiss. It is also important to use a small amount of cheese as bait, as too much can make it easy for the mouse to steal the bait without triggering the trap. Additionally, it is a good idea to change the bait regularly, as mice can quickly become accustomed to the scent of the same food and start avoiding it. Overall, cheese can be a great choice for baiting an old fashioned mouse trap, but it is important to choose the right type and use it sparingly.

How much bait should be used for an old fashioned mouse trap?

When it comes to an old fashioned mouse trap, the amount of bait to be used is crucial to ensure a successful catch. The ideal amount of bait varies depending on the type of bait and the size of the trap. Generally, a small amount of bait, such as a pea-sized portion, is sufficient for a mouse trap. It is important to use fresh and enticing bait, such as peanut butter or cheese, as mice are attracted to strong smells. If the bait is too much, it may spill over the trap and not allow the trap to function properly. On the other hand, if the bait is too little, the mouse may be able to snatch it away without triggering the trap. It is also essential to place the bait in the right position, such as at the end of the trigger, to ensure a quick and painless catch. In summary, the amount of bait used for an old fashioned mouse trap should be small and strategically placed to effectively catch the mouse.

How often should the bait be changed in an old fashioned mouse trap?

The frequency of changing bait in an old-fashioned mouse trap depends on various factors. If the trap has been successful in capturing a mouse, then the bait needs to be replaced immediately. This will ensure that the trap is ready for the next mouse that comes by. However, if the trap has not been triggered, then replacing the bait every three to four days is recommended. This is because the scent of the bait will start to fade, and the mouse may lose interest in it. It's also crucial to place the trap in the right location to increase the chances of catching a mouse. Placing it near a wall where mice tend to run is an excellent spot. Moreover, it's essential to keep the trap clean and free from any debris or leftover bait that may deter mice from approaching the trap. In conclusion, changing bait every three to four days and placing the trap in the right location are critical factors in catching mice with an old-fashioned mouse trap.

What type of bait works best for an old fashioned mouse trap?

When it comes to catching mice with an old fashioned mouse trap, the type of bait used plays a crucial role in the success of the trap. While there are various types of bait that can be used, some are more effective than others. One of the most effective types of bait is peanut butter. The strong smell and sticky texture of peanut butter makes it a popular choice for baiting mouse traps. Other effective baits include cheese, bacon, and even small pieces of chocolate. It is important to note that the bait should be placed in a small amount on the trap to avoid the mouse being able to take it without setting off the trap. Additionally, it is important to monitor the trap regularly to ensure that any caught mice are disposed of quickly and safely to avoid any health risks.

Leave a Comment